Home International Pokies reform must not be a lost cause

Pokies reform must not be a lost cause

0
2
Advertisement
Illustration by Megan Herbert

The outgoing boss of the NSW Independent Casino Authority, Philip Crawford, effectively criticised the Minns government for its demonstrable unwillingness to introduce timely and effective harm-prevention law reforms (“Labor lacks bravery on pokies: Watchdog”, November 16). Around 2016, his counterpart Chris Sidoti resigned because of apparent concerns with a lack of impartiality in the elected government balancing public interest with industry profits. Surely the alignment of legitimate serious common concerns from these two senior public officials responsible for overseeing the regulation of gambling and alcohol in NSW, though more than 10 years apart, is sufficient to suggest that the regulation of these harmful and powerful industries is a lost cause? Has it been effectively and systematically captured by pernicious commercial/political vested interests, aided by complicit elected lawmakers? The regulatory concept of “capture” has been recognised by the High Court (see McCloy v NSW) and the US Supreme Court as a serious form of “corruption”, and should be treated as such. Tony Brown, Newcastle

Poker machines are a lightning rod for concern about public welfare.
Poker machines are a lightning rod for concern about public welfare.Peter Braig

Respective governments of NSW – and other states of Australia, for that matter – ought to be developing phasing-out plans of pokies from clubs. Instead of cold-turkey culling, let’s just say we accept your fallible arguments about preventing disintegration of clubs (i.e. jobs) if pokies are spontaneously ripped out from underneath them. And so if and when the phasing out with parallel programs in place is complete, and clubs can’t stand up on their own without those pokies (or a much greater regulated position therein), then “the market” has spoken. It means the fundamental activity of the club (food, sport, drinking, community use) must be profitable on its own; otherwise it’s essentially redundant. Governments can save their faces via this slower phasing-out by giving clubs ample time to improve their attractiveness. It’s not sad or unfortunate that clubs might vanish. Communities either support their clubs/pubs without pokies or accept their demise. Sad is the dismal profiteering of pokies ad infinitum. Ted Bush, North Epping

Poker machine reform seems a niche where our state government could act without the whole electorate taking fright. It might actually provide some cost-of-living relief, and there would definitely be votes in it. Instead, although it looks like paralysis, we suspect the government is in financial thrall to the gambling industry. And patience is wearing thin. Surely, the point of being in government is to make a real difference – not simply get re-elected. Margaret Johnston, Paddington

Truth always comes out

I have never understood why adults with children do this (“Deceit and debt behind ‘good’ divorce”, November 16). If one does the other over, the offspring will eventually find out. It may be the day they are shopping for new uniforms. Or when the new partner moves into the penthouse above the food bank they are shopping in. Or even when they hear things and finally piece the puzzle together. But this level of bastardry is special. And it is abuse. No amount of mandatory training for the accountant and lawyer, nor referrals back to the Family Court, will change this. In the end he is smiling, all the way to the bank. David Neilson, Uralla

Advertisement

Thank you for continuing to investigate harm within the family law system (“Surveilled, scared and broke”, November 14), following Wendy Tuohy’s reporting on September 11. For those of us who have advocated for children and protective parents for years, sustained scrutiny is welcome. Please keep following the story beyond the exposure of individual suffering. The lack of statistics on Family Court outcomes is inexcusable. For example, why can’t we know how many parents were separated from their children by the court and why? Which recommendations from successive inquiries have been implemented? Who checks whether reforms actually protect families and, more particularly, children? What happens when safeguards fail? Above all, how are children’s own accounts and wishes reflected in decisions governing their lives? Being heard must mean more than having their words recorded. The next chapter should track responsibility, action and results. Women and children need to know what has changed in practice – and who will answer for what has not. Ariel Johnson, Eastgardens

Grateful for Greenwich

I have never been in Alex Greenwich’s electorate, but I am mightily glad that he is there in the NSW lower house, fighting for reasonable and necessary matters such as VAD, compassionate abortion rights and decency towards our LGBTQ residents (“‘Distressing’: Greenwich’s office graffitied with homophobic slur”, November 16). Ironically, his attackers are unaware of their own ignorance and absurd beliefs. They attack from the gutter or, in Mark Latham’s case, even lower than that. John MacKay, Asquith

The Jillaroos celebrate winning the World Cup over New Zealand in Brisbane on Sunday.
The Jillaroos celebrate winning the World Cup over New Zealand in Brisbane on Sunday.Getty Images

League of their own

Congratulations to the Kangaroos and Jillaroos for their gutsy Rugby World Cup wins over New Zealand (“Top of the world”, November 16). They have set the stage for hopefully another terrific Trans-Tasman competition next month in the cricket. Watching the men’s game in particular, one couldn’t help but be impressed at the large-scale singing of the national anthems by both the players and the crowd, accompanied by some streams of tears on the faces of those in both teams. On reflection, this should be the norm, rather than the sometimes mumbled lip-syncing or dour looks that Australian athletes have been prone to display. Our Oceanic neighbours have shown us up in this department, rightfully recognising that while their nations are not without faults, there is great honour in representing one’s country, and thus it is right to vocalise pride and actually mean it. Hopefully, this might be a sign of the new norm for the Green and Gold that will be on display before big sporting contests. Peter Waterhouse, Craigieburn (Vic)

Advertisement

Close the (Sandpaper)gate

Chadd Sayers has bravely made a confident statement to confirm Usman Khawaja’s assertion (“Sayers claims whole Test side knew of sandpaper plot”, November 16). Patrick Cummins has conveniently closed his chapter and will not be taking any further questions. It is time Cricket Australia put the matter to bed once and for all, for cricket fans not only in Australia but around the world. Peng Ee, Castle Cove

A million years ago, in our school cricket team, we picked one side of the ball with our fingernails and shined the other side with hair gel and saliva. What’s changed? It’s been going on forever! Rod Bartlett, Woonona

Judy Hungerford (Letters, November 16) suggests a separate edition. However, the whole thing should be called off because of the bad light reflecting on the entire pitch. Allan Gibson, Cherrybrook

As Europe faces riots in the streets, the US struggles with violent division, and the Middle East is at war, I’m grateful to live in a place where the biggest raging conflict is about a game of cricket … that happened eight years ago. Paul Ichilcik, Darlinghurst

All this talk about cricket ball tampering really is much ado about scuffing. Malcolm McCallum, Dulwich Hill

Advertisement

Labor’s housing fix is working

Doesn’t the falling auction clearance rate (down at 44 per cent) simply mean the government and economic pundits were correct, and it has been investors driving the price of housing up by out-bidding would-be owner-occupiers (“Repeal tax changes to avoid crash: Coalition”, November 16)? Take them out of the equation and normality returns. Investors can still obtain a negative gearing advantage by building a new home, thus increasing housing stocks. How is that bad? Chris Hennessy, East Ballina

No one screams more loudly than a wealthy person about to lose a tax rort. Norm Neill, Darlinghurst

It seems Tim Wilson is all about containing evil inflation everywhere but in one area of our economy. In arguing for a repeal of the government’s housing tax reforms, he is seeking to protect his biggest supporters’ source of wealth: ever-inflating house prices and a reward economy built around an unproductive asset class. In so doing, he is perpetrating the usual LNP hoax that favours wealth over work. Peter Hull, Katoomba

Shadow treasurer Tim Wilson is unhappy with changes to tax laws that affect housing investors.
Shadow treasurer Tim Wilson is unhappy with changes to tax laws that affect housing investors.Alex Ellinghausen

While the headlines bewail “housing down” and the Coalition wants tax laws reversed, the keywords from the banks are that “housing investment is down”. Before negative gearing for housing was introduced by the Coalition, there was no weeping or gnashing of teeth over housing investment. There was also not a housing crisis. The Coalition wants the tax reforms abolished now, before anyone notices any long-term benefits from the changes. Meanwhile, investors will sit still until they see which way the wind will blow, and those who already have dwellings will probably keep them as a nice little earner. Donald Hawes, Peel

Your correspondent (Letters, November 16) implies that no one takes bold action when in government. The Albanese government took bold action to bring an end to about 30 years of outrageous increases in house prices, generating great inequality. It introduced incentives encouraging the installation of solar panels and batteries, greatly boosting solar power. Little credit is given for these wonderful initiatives. Bill Ogilvie, Bathurst

Advertisement

Hot mic hiccup

Yet another puerile comment from Mr Albanese (“‘No one was hurt’: Albanese sorry for ‘hot mic’ incident”, November 16). When can we have a statesman/woman rather than a schoolboy in charge of the nation? Sue Martin, Clareville

I’m more interested in knowing the facts. Does a phone stored near your heart interfere with your rhythm, or is it only a risk if you have an implanted device? Please explain. Lisa Clarke, Watsons Bay

Anthony Albanese (left) with Climate Change Minister Chris Bowen (right) greeting Andrew “Twiggy” Forrest at COP31.
Anthony Albanese (left) with Climate Change Minister Chris Bowen (right) greeting Andrew “Twiggy” Forrest at COP31.AAP

As Natassia Chrysanthos reports, Albanese claims to be sorry for his “hot mic” incident, but the crude blokeyness of his mindset was, as James Paterson said, a bad look. In itself, the grubby remark might be seen as trivial, but on an international platform, the PM should have been more circumspect. It is yet another of his gaffes, following his boorish remarks about Kylie Minogue, his coarse “melons” response to the Japanese PM, the Helen Haines dirt sheet, his prevarication over the golf club debacle, and earlier, his failure to win the Voice referendum. It is about time the self-important PM stepped down to allow one of his untainted, more articulate ministers like Jim Chalmers or Katy Gallagher the chance to establish themselves as vote-worthy leaders before the 2028 federal election. If the increasingly vulnerable Albanese opts to stay on as leader, the ALP might well lose. Ron Sinclair, Windradyne

While their comments were crass and lacking scientific support, at least PM Albanese and Environment Minister Bowen were laughing at their own discomfort and destruction of reproductive health rather than laughing at the discomfort and destruction of our Pacific neighbours as did former immigration minister Dutton and former PM Abbott when Dutton said “time doesn’t mean anything when you are about to have water lapping at your door” in regard to time delays and climate change. Surely, by now, all politicians should follow Joe Biden’s mantra that you should “always assume the microphone is on”. There really is no such thing as a private conversation or joke when a microphone and the press are around. Merilyn McClung, Forestville

Anthony Albanese says he has not ruled out posing in a group photograph with Vladimir Putin at a coming APEC meeting in China. He might as well have posed with Ivan Milat for the message this sends to many people, and I think most Australians would be appalled if he did not sit that one out. Matt Kaarma, North Nowra

Advertisement

Gas giants’ hot air

Well, I could hardly say that I am shocked that the gas producers don’t like the proposed gas reservation plan (“Top industry chiefs, unions ‘are united’ to pass gas laws”, November 16) despite overwhelming support from industry and unions. After making an absolute killing with windfall profits due to the Ukraine and Iran conflicts, the prospect of having to supply affordable Australian gas to Australian consumers sits uneasily with them. The Coalition is against the plan because that is what they do, and the Greens, as usual, are letting the perfect stand in the road of the good, although a gas export tax would be a popular move. Wouldn’t it be great if these gas producers decided that they could do the right thing and supply Australians with some of our own gas? But no, they must protect their mega profits and executive bonuses above all else. I guess it is a case of however much profit you make it is never enough. Ross Hudson, Mount Martha (Vic)

Katherine Deves, One Nation’s latest upper house candidate, speaks to the media on Sunday.
Katherine Deves, One Nation’s latest upper house candidate, speaks to the media on Sunday.George Chan

One Nation half pregnant

So One Nation wants to run candidates in every NSW lower house seat (“One Nation announces NSW candidates”, November 16)? I guess they don’t know about the aphorism “quality not quantity”. Peter Miniutti, Ashbury

I was bewildered to read about possibly One Nation’s most prominent candidate for the coming state election, Katherine Deves, uttering a concern about bureaucrats supposedly arguing about men breastfeeding and getting pregnant. I feel I’ve been in the dark about this obvious, all too important issue that evidently must be a hot subject throughout NSW. Con Vaitsas, Ashbury

  • To submit a letter to the Sydney Morning Herald, email letters@smh.com.au. Click here for tips on how to submit letters.
  • The Opinion newsletter is a weekly wrap of views that will challenge, champion and inform. Sign up here.

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: www.smh.com.au