OpenAI is doing it. Anthropic is, too: Putting technologists and product operations people in charge of HR is the latest trend among AI-native companies. But Wharton professor of management Peter Cappelli has a warning for companies looking to follow suit: Give the general counsel a heads-up, because “they’re going to be busy.”
His concern? Companies are betting that technical expertise will translate into better people management, when the two require fundamentally different skills.
“I think [organizations] are expecting that technologists will come in there and sprinkle some pixie dust, and then in a little while, all the problems will be gone,” Cappelli says.
While researching his book, Our Least Important Asset, Cappelli examined why companies struggle to manage their people. One culprit, he found, is that many executives are engineers by training, and companies have largely abandoned the management development programs that once taught them how to lead.
Engineers and technologists tend to approach problems through optimization, Cappelli says. But when applied to managing people, that mindset can prioritize cutting headcount over developing and supporting employees—an approach that risks creating more problems than it solves.
That doesn’t mean technologists can’t become effective HR leaders, Cappelli says. But they need to learn the fundamentals of people management first, perhaps through a rotational assignment on an HR team before taking the top job.
For HR leaders worried about being replaced by technologists, Cappelli recommends demonstrating value by helping companies navigate the AI transition and positioning oneself as an expert in change management.
“If you show them a couple of successes, then they’re going to think you’re doing fine,” Cappelli says. “But if you can’t do anything and you’re wringing your hands, then you probably will get replaced.”
P.S. If you haven’t already, check out our 2026 World’s 25 Best Workplaces list. The No. 1 company retains its spot for the second year in a row and third time since 2016. Any guesses?
Kristin Stoller
Editorial Director, Fortune Live Media
kristin.stoller@fortune.com
Fortune Office Hours
This week, Kai Werner, CHRO at software company TeamViewer, answers your burning workplace questions. Responses have been edited for length and clarity.
Q: I’ve been in the same role at my company for about two years. Recently, my boss told me he’s overhauling my position by moving me to a new project, changing nearly all of my day-to-day tasks, and adding more responsibilities.
I don’t feel I have the skills for this new work. What’s more, I’m not interested. It isn’t something I’m passionate about, and I don’t see how it will help my career grow. What recourse do I have? Do I have to accept this new role, or can I push back and keep things as they are?
A: The most helpful first step is to have an open and honest conversation with your boss. Changes like this rarely come out of nowhere, and you may not have the full picture. Ask why he chose you for this role and what strengths he sees in you. It’s also worth discussing what success would look like. Then, share your concerns openly, including any skills you’d need to develop and questions about how this could shape your career.
Your company has a genuine interest in helping you do work you feel good about and finding a role where you can thrive. Hiring and training someone new takes time, so most managers would prefer to explore a solution that works for everyone. That might mean training, a gradual transition, or expanding responsibilities while keeping some of the work you enjoy. Bringing ideas along with your concerns shows that you care about finding a positive solution.
You’re absolutely free to push back; however, work circumstances can change. It’s helpful to keep in mind that things may not stay exactly as they are.
I’d also encourage you to stay open minded. Your boss may see strengths in you that you haven’t recognized yet, and work that doesn’t feel exciting right now could become a valuable opportunity that opens unexpected doors.
Have a workplace situation that you’re unsure how to navigate or a scenario worth unpacking? Send it our way anonymously via this form.
Watercooler
A round-up of the most important HR headlines from Fortune and beyond.
Jargon jumpscare. Employees who use the wrong acronym in front of Cisco’s president face having their meeting terminated. Fortune
Sad desk lunch. Should the lunch break get reinstated? Bosses need to get involved first. Washington Post
Plant perks. Want to boost employee morale? Try office gardens and desk plants. Wall Street Journal
Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: fortune.com










