Veterans of the 2018 Sandpapergate scandal will be offered an independent forum for sharing and discussing their memories of the fateful tour of South Africa, as Cricket Australia and players alike seek to stem the bleeding from an episode that refuses to die.
CA’s chair David Boon and chief executive Todd Greenberg unveiled their approach following days of painful public slanging around recollections of the tour and whether the team should have taken collective responsibility for a scandal that finished with long bans for Steve Smith, David Warner and Cameron Bancroft.
The severity of those penalties and the public opprobrium that accompanied them was a driving force for Usman Khawaja to offer an unvarnished account of the 2018 tour of South Africa in his autobiography, including his call for wider accountability. That led to a stinging press conference riposte from captain Pat Cummins, who attacked Khawaja and his version of events.
CA announced the voluntary process, following an emergency board meeting on Tuesday night, in a clear attempt to move the current exchanges out of the public square, but it is unlikely to stop some players from still wanting to tell their truths publicly. Bancroft remains likely to do so, perhaps as soon as this week.
Greenberg also said that CA’s current leadership accepted that the governing body needed to share responsibility for how the episode was handled at the time, and for the win-at-all-costs culture that had developed in the years leading up to the Test series against the Proteas.
“I think everyone has to take some level of accountability, and CA is part of that,” he said. “You’ve heard a number of times through different players that the culture at that time was quite toxic. It was a difficult dressing room. It was a win-at-all-costs mentality, and that doesn’t just start with a group of players. It comes from an entire organisation, and I think there’s a level of responsibility we have to accept.
“In saying that, I think the game and the Australian cricket team has learnt enormous lessons from that period of time. Enormous changes have been made, and credit goes to, first of all, Justin Langer and Tim Paine, who re-created the culture of that team over the first four years, and to Andrew McDonald and Pat Cummins who picked that up and took it to another level.
“It takes a lot for a team like this to have gone through such a difficult period and then to reinvent themselves to be the team they are today.”
Boon and Greenberg also made it plain that the forum, to be overseen by a prominent former judge or Kings Counsel, would be confidential, with the CA board to then decide how much of it would be made public.
“Ultimately, that will be a matter when we get through the end of this with the Cricket Australia board on what we can disclose, and we will look to be as transparent as we possibly can, whilst at the same time protecting the confidentiality of the people that come forward.”
Khawaja and Warner reacted to the press conference on Fox Cricket. Khawaja said he would support the process, but questioned CA’s role as the arbiter of what would be public.
“I’ve always wanted a safe space to chat,” Khawaja said.
“I wish Cricket Australia would have done this a week and a half ago, probably longer ago. There needs to be a safe space where we can chat. But I also have some questions about Cricket Australia, because the public want to know what happened there.
“It’s hard to get the whole truth unless everyone is speaking, support staff and players. And so, if you leave that open-ended, what are you finding? My questions will always be, what is the outcome from this? I don’t think there should be any sanctions. I don’t think the price is being paid was a hefty price. It’s never been about that.
“But the biggest question I have, and I wrote it down, is the board makes the decisions on what comes out at the end. How is that an actual way of trying to present what people are saying? So I can go in there and say something, but then the board can decide that they’re not going to release that, and I just feel like then we just go in a circle again.”
Greenberg, who was previously the chief executive of the Australian Cricketers Association, said that he had spoken extensively with each of Khawaja, Warner and Cummins in recent days, and refused to denigrate any of their wildly conflicting accounts.
“I think they can both be true because it’s their version of events, and their version of events is their truth,” Greenberg said.
“I’m not here to tell someone what they believe, nor should they tell me what I believe. My version of events might be different to yours. They can be true to you, and they can be true to me. That’s the difficulty.
“I’ve had consistent dialogue with both Dave and Uz. I hold them in such enormous, high regard, and I said this to David, and I repeat it here. What David went through, the price he paid, his sanction, for him to come back from that, for him to come back into the Australian team, perform the way he did, for him to finish on his terms; it takes a very special human to do that, and I have such admiration for him, as I do with Usman, and this is their version of events, and it’s not for me to disrespect their view.
“Equally, when Pat speaks or somebody else speaks, I have to accept their version of events at the same time because I wasn’t there, I wasn’t part of it, and I didn’t see it.”
Boon, who is yet to declare whether he will continue as chair beyond an interim period following the resignation of Mike Baird, spoke with sadness about the relationships between the players that he could see fracturing in real time.
“It’s very sad in many ways what’s eventuated,” he said. “As a former player, I know that one of the most important things cricket gives us is the relationships we build and the mateship that endures long after playing careers end.
“My hope is that this process can help strengthen those connections and allow us to focus on what lies ahead. I would encourage everyone to allow the process to unfold respectfully and privately.”
News, results and expert analysis from the weekend of sport sent every Friday. Sign up for our Sport newsletter.
From our partners
Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: www.smh.com.au



