Home Health ‘Blunt-object obduracy’ and a challenge for the commission to meet

‘Blunt-object obduracy’ and a challenge for the commission to meet

0
2
Advertisement
Michael Bachelard

You might think from the movies that observing an omerta – a code of silence – is an almost high-minded thing. Mafia dons in tuxedos loyally refusing to give up their consiglieri. Elegant, even.

That’s not the way Joel Leavitt does it.

Joel Leavitt giving evidence at the royal commission.

The bikie and alleged standover man, grilled at excruciating length in the Big Build royal commission over the past two days, sniffs a lot and sighs. He evades eye contact, swivels his chair like a washing machine agitator, throws questions back at his questioner (“How do you think you would act if you’ve ever been shot”) and drinks water so copiously from a cardboard cup that he regularly needs to request toilet breaks.

Leavitt’s determination to avoid answering prompted multiple unflattering self-revelations. Among them are that he was terrible at his job as a union health and safety representative, barely knew how to do it and was rarely there.

Advertisement

Then there’s the post-traumatic stress and memory loss he claims to have suffered after being shot in the leg in a bikie clubhouse, the fact that he’s in counselling for it, his drug habit, his inability to handle money and the fact he got drunk last night and is a little hungover.

There’s no elegance in these evasions.

Noticeably, they step up a notch when asked about individuals – fellow bikies or unionists.

Presented with text message exchanges extracted from his iPhone, Leavitt couldn’t remember the full name of “Corbo”, a Rebel bikie whom he’d promised to get a job. What about “Arunta”, another apparent bikie contact, with whom Leavitt discussed some poor wrongdoer who “needs a talking to”? “I don’t know who Arunta is.”

Advertisement

His knowledge of Jonny “Two Guns” Walker, another bikie, this one with a manslaughter conviction who came to work as a CFMEU delegate, was also vanishing, though he admitted doing “consulting” business with him on safety issues.

Leavitt’s verbal gymnastics were contortive.

“To the best of my recollection, did I or could have, or personally could have? Maybe at one time,” went one answer. “To the best of my recollection, it’s definitely a possibility.”

Only when it suited him did clarity make a fleeting appearance.

Advertisement

Asked about a fellow Rebel bikie whom he’d promised a job on a site, he was quick to reveal the man had not, in fact, secured the role. In Leavitt’s mind this seemed to be evidence against the notion that the CFMEU had undue power in the Big Build.

How, I wondered watching this shambles, did the CFMEU of 2023 look their members in the eye and seriously claim this violent, dim-witted, drug-affected, absent man could provide useful health and safety advice and protect them against scurrilous bosses.

Joel Leavitt arriving at the royal commission on Wednesday.Penny Stephens

The commission has the power to compel witnesses under threat of punishment and of all the witnesses over six days of evidence so far, Leavitt has expressed most clearly – physically and verbally – that he was here against his will.

The commission also has the power to compel witnesses to answer individual questions. In Leavitt’s case, that threat was deployed regularly but mostly unsuccessfully.

Advertisement

Chris Carr, SC, one of the fine minds of the Victorian legal profession, dashed his wit against the blunt-object obduracy of Leavitt for a day and a half and, at times, the lawyer showed the strain.

Photo: Matt Golding

Commissioner Chris Kourakis has reminded Leavitt several times that it’s an offence not to answer questions – an offence that carries up to a two-year sentence. But you get the feeling that, for Leavitt – the president of the Bandidos bikie club and someone who’s already taken one bullet – such a punishment is less frightening to him than breaking the underworld code of silence.

Now the commission needs to follow through on its multiple verbal warnings.

Kourakis has been given a strong taste of what he’s in for when dealing with blokes like Leavitt, and how he proceeds from here will set a tone for those still to come.

Advertisement

If the commission fails to refer Leavitt for charges, then other gang members, crooks and union officials equally committed to upholding the code might take his lead and perform in a similar way.

No matter how inelegant it looks.

Michael BachelardMichael Bachelard is a senior writer and former deputy editor and investigations editor of The Age. He has worked in Canberra, Melbourne and Jakarta, has written two books and won multiple awards for journalism, including the Gold Walkley.Connect via email.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: www.smh.com.au