Some conciliatory words about Sandpapergate in South Africa in 2018 would never have brought down Pat Cummins’ captaincy.
But last Friday’s 68-minute press conference, now directly contradicted by multiple players from the tour eight years ago, just might.
The day before Cummins spoke, white-ball skipper Mitch Marsh had used the words “I don’t come from a place of judgment”. How different things may have been if Cummins had used them too.
Cameron Bancroft’s 4000-word revelation about the sandpaper scandal, how widely his ball-tampering work was known and the burden he has carried from it, made for sobering reading on Wednesday night.
Its most incendiary passage, however, was aimed not at eight years ago but at what Cummins had just done. By producing a litany of denials and also attacking Usman Khawaja so stridently over his recollections of 2018, Cummins stirred something in Bancroft.
“The recent release of Usman Khawaja’s autobiography, Sabr, has brought many of those memories back to the surface,” Bancroft wrote. “It was freeing to hear on a personal level the truth of the chronology of events finally out there. A burden I have carried all these years.
“But the final straw for me to write this account was Australian cricket captain Pat Cummins’ press conference. It made me feel angry, betrayed and alone.”
Well before Cummins had finished speaking on Friday at Cricket NSW headquarters in Sydney, shock was reverberating around veteran members of the 2018 tour party.
Most had come to expect that Cummins was a fair and reasonable man, able to speak with balance about difficult issues, and always working on ensuring that Australian cricket was more united and less, to use his word, “siloed” than it had been in 2018. They expected him to lead.
But a press conference in which Cummins torched Khawaja, not only in terms of his memories of Sandpapergate but also his character, left other members of the team with a seriously awkward feeling.
Unsurprisingly, David Warner was first to respond, saying that Cummins had thrown Khawaja “under the bus”. But privately others were also concerned about how personal his words had been, asking whether that had really been necessary.
Two days later, squad member Chadd Sayers found himself expanding on his own memories of the tour, explaining that he had not been able to keep watching Cummins speak.
Bancroft, meanwhile, felt a flood of memories return. Not just those that had been confirmed by Khawaja, but others more recent than 2018. His 2021 experience, mumbling the words “self-explanatory” in an interview in the UK then getting mercilessly shot down by Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon, had also been seared into his mind.
“Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon subsequently released a joint statement denying that they knew sandpaper had been taken onto the field to alter the ball before the television footage appeared at Newlands,” Bancroft wrote.
“Reading that statement was deeply painful. I had memories of conversations on the field in Port Elizabeth and Newlands, feedback about the ball and shared celebrations that made the statement difficult for me to digest.”
One of the most telling sections of the Bancroft essay was the one that showed how it had been media manager Kate Hutchison who was the sole member of the tour party to raise obvious concerns about the sandpaper plot. That is important not only as an illustration of groupthink, but it also begs the question – if the media manager knew, surely the bowlers had to know?
“Our media manager, Kate Hutchison, expressed her objection to what was happening,” Bancroft wrote. “I recall her making it clear that she believed it was wrong, that she wanted nothing to do with it, and walking away from the discussion.
“I will never forget that. Somebody had spoken up. Somebody had demonstrated that being part of the team did not mean having to accept everything the team was doing. And I ignored it.”
Something that Cummins, Starc, Hazlewood and Lyon have never done – nor coaches Darren Lehmann and David Saker for that matter – is provide their own detailed accounts of what took place. It was a missed opportunity on Friday for Cummins not to do so.
Cricket Australia’s truth forum, unveiled on Wednesday after chief executive Todd Greenberg had spoken with Bancroft about what his intentions were, might provide some way for players to be reconciled.
But the more urgent question is whether Australia can continue to be led by a public figure who so badly misread the state of play when he took to the microphones last week. Cummins’ manager Neil Maxwell released a statement on Wednesday night suggesting there was nothing Bancroft had said that Cummins had not already answered. That contention will be hard for many to fathom.
CA’s board, which has the final say on who leads the Australian team or not, will be forced into still more hurried discussions.
The other critical person in all this is of course, Steve Smith, recently arrived in Sydney from New York.
Smith is yet to speak publicly about 2018, and he is also the locum Australian captain whenever Cummins is unavailable. How he views Bancroft’s statement, and Cummins’ rebuttal, will have a significant role to play.
Overall, though, for Cummins and Australian cricket, Bancroft’s 4000 words could be summed up in one sentence. It’s time for everyone to stop bullshitting.
News, results and expert analysis from the weekend of sport are sent every Monday. Sign up for our Sport newsletter.
From our partners
Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: www.smh.com.au







