The recent accounts by Usman Khawaja, Cameron Bancroft and Chadd Sayers have broadened the net beyond the three players – Bancroft, Steve Smith and David Warner – who were suspended by Cricket Australia in 2018.
In compiling the list of allegations made against each player over their involvement and/or knowledge of the sandpaper plot, it is notable how the use of language is important in framing each player’s interpretation of the events in South Africa.
The coaches
Darren Lehmann: The former head coach has been accused by Bancroft of having knowledge of the sandpaper plot. It is the first time Lehmann has been put in the frame.
According to Bancroft, Lehmann was present in a dressing room meeting during tea on day two of the second Test in Port Elizabeth where David Warner raised the idea of sandpaper being used on the ball and people agreeing with that proposal.
“Saker and Lehmann were certainly present, although I cannot speak for every word shared,” Bancroft wrote.
Lehmann is also alleged to have told reserve batter Peter Handscomb in the infamous conversation on the walkie-talkie at Newlands after Bancroft was caught red-handed to “get the f—ing sandpaper off Bangers now”.
“In my opinion, if he didn’t know he wouldn’t have said that,” Bancroft wrote.
Lehmann has over the years repeatedly denied any knowledge of the use of sandpaper. CA’s initial investigation also found he had no knowledge. He told investigators his message to Handscomb was “what the f— is going on”.
Lehmann told the ABC on Wednesday night during a commentary shift for the third one-day international between Australia and England in Hobart that he would wait a few days before addressing Bancroft’s claims.
“The allegations … I’ve got to sit back. It’s only just come to light,” Lehmann said. “So I just need to sit back and process all that and work through each allegation. That’s what I will be doing over the next few days.
“I need to have a really good read of it don’t I? What’s transpired, speaking to people, and just make sure I’m saying what I want to say and answer the questions you want to ask.”
David Saker: The former bowling coach has been accused by Bancroft of telling the opener he “needed to do more with the sandpaper on the ball to get it to swing” during lunch on the third day of the Cape Town Test.
Saker is also alleged to have told Bancroft and former captain Steve Smith to lie about the use of sandpaper at their ill-fated press conference after play.
Saker was also present at the Port Elizabeth meeting with Lehmann where Warner raised the idea of the use of sandpaper, according to Bancroft.
Bancroft claims Saker congratulated him in a team meeting before play on the third morning of the Port Elizabeth Test for his ball tampering with sandpaper the day prior.
“I remember my ball tampering with the sandpaper the evening before being discussed and my role being acknowledged in front of the group,” Bancroft wrote. “Much like the celebrations when we took 4-28 the evening before, I received wraps and encouragement from members of the playing and coaching staff, especially David Saker.
“It reinforced the sense that what I was doing was being accepted as part of our collective effort.”
Saker is the unnamed coach in Khawaja’s memoir Sabr who was witnessed having a conversation with Bancroft at lunch in the Newlands rooms before he was busted with sandpaper.
“With a smile on his face, he said, ‘Bangers, whatever you’re doing, we need more of it. It’s wet out there – we just need more of it’,” Khawaja wrote of the coach, who he does not name.
“Then I saw Bangers pick up a piece of sandpaper and put it in his pocket. The coach gave both me and Cameron a wry smile of satisfaction and walked away.”
Saker has not responded to numerous enquiries from this masthead about his involvement in the scandal. His last public comments on the issue were in 2021 after Bancroft’s interview with The Guardian in the UK.
“There was a lot of people to blame. It could have been me to blame, it could have been someone else. It could have been stopped and it wasn’t, which is unfortunate,” Saker said at the time.
“You could point your finger at me, you could point your finger at ‘Boof’ [ Lehmann], could you point it at other people, of course you could. We all know that we made a monumental mistake. The gravity wasn’t as plain until it all came out.”
Graeme Hick and Brad Haddin: Khawaja and Bancroft have alleged the pair, the batting and fielding coaches respectively, were aware of the sandpaper plot in their claim the whole team and support staff knew.
Hick emphatically denied he knew of sandpaper use, saying the allegation was “absolutely false”.
“I have seen the various statements around the coaches and I’m very disappointed with the broad nature of them,” Hick told this masthead. “Khawaja puts it simply: ‘It was all of us. Not the batters, not the bowlers, not the staff. All of us.’ To me what Khawaja is implying here is absolutely false.
“In regard to any discussions around the ball tampering in Port Elizabeth or Cape Town that took place, I will say in true honesty that I did not hear or know anything!!
“My first knowledge of all this was, like many, when it appeared on the big screen in Cape Town as I was sat on the outside balcony at the time.”
Haddin has not spoken about the issue.
The players
Pat Cummins: The Test and one-day international captain is under intense scrutiny after Bancroft and Chadd Sayers challenged what he said in his extraordinary press conference last Friday.
The personal nature of Cummins’ criticism of Khawaja prompted Bancroft and Sayers to publicly contradict the incumbent captain’s claim he had no knowledge of the sandpaper plot.
“It made me feel angry, betrayed and alone,” Bancroft wrote.
“What I saw, experienced and lived with – not only him [Cummins], but everyone else on that tour in South Africa – is not the public account he gave in his press conference and in the years previously when he has spoken on this time.”
The most significant part of the statement for Cummins is the allegation he – along with fellow quicks Josh Hazlewood, Mitchell Starc and Mitch Marsh, and wicketkeeper Tim Paine – was repeatedly consulted by Bancroft on whether the ball was reverse-swinging enough in Port Elizabeth and Cape Town.
Bancroft, though, does not state explicitly that he told the bowlers he was using sandpaper.
“All the bowlers gave me feedback if my work on the ball was working. It was helpful,” Bancroft wrote. “Is it going yet? It’s not going yet, it needs more. So I would use the sandpaper more on the ball.
“There was even a time I was told to stop out of fear what I was doing was becoming too obvious.
“The conversations about the effect the sandpaper was having on the ball were regular, very natural and organic on the field. It is as it is.”
Cummins, Starc, Hazlewood and Lyon released a joint statement in 2021 denying prior knowledge of the plan to use sandpaper, a point Cummins doubled down on last week when he responded to Khawaja’s autobiography.
“When he says we all knew, if that he means we knew sandpaper was going out on the field, he’s 100 per cent wrong,” Cummins said. “I said that consistently for the last eight years. I did not know that was happening. But I think Usman actually says things that are far more serious than that.
“He says that I and others were architects of a scheme to ball tamper with sandpaper. That’s complete and utter nonsense.”
Bancroft, though, does include a line that gives Cummins an out.
“The conversations I remember having with the bowlers about the ball’s movement have troubled me enormously in the years since,” Bancroft wrote.
“When I later heard public statements denying knowledge of sandpaper being used, I struggled to reconcile those denials with my memories.
“I recognise there is a distinction between knowing a ball is reversing, suspecting it has been altered and knowing specifically that sandpaper has been used.”
Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon: Like Cummins, the trio have denied prior knowledge of the use of sandpaper.
While Hazlewood and Lyon have not spoken publicly since the release of Khawaja’s book, Starc has stuck by the 2021 joint statement.
“We were heavily grilled through the process at the time, and since, and I guess I won’t speak on behalf of the bowlers, but where I stand, my opinion hasn’t changed. My recollection hasn’t changed from what we said in 2021,” Starc said.
Tim Paine: Bancroft claimed he had consulted the wicketkeeper to gauge how far the tampered ball was moving. According to Bancroft and Khawaja, Paine was also in the same part of the Newlands dressing room when the unnamed coach approached Bancroft to urge him “to do more with the sandpaper on the ball to get it to swing”.
In his autobiography The Price Paid, published in 2022, he wrote that suggestions everyone in the dressing room knew about sandpaper were “rubbish”.
“Everyone out there was shocked when they looked up on the big screen and saw Cameron Bancroft with a piece of sandpaper in his hand. I was stunned. We all were. My heart sank, I was thinking, ‘What the f—?’”
Usman Khawaja: The opener has admitted to having knowledge of the sandpaper plot in Port Elizabeth and Cape Town.
He wrote he was sitting next to Bancroft in Newlands when an unnamed coach, later revealed to be Saker, approached, urging Bancroft to continue what he was doing with the ball.
“With a smile on his face, he said, ‘Bangers, whatever you’re doing, we need more of it. It’s wet out there – we just need more of it’,” Khawaja writes of the coach, who he does not name.
“Then I saw Bangers pick up a piece of sandpaper and put it in his pocket. The coach gave both me and Cameron a wry smile of satisfaction and walked away.”
Cameron Bancroft: The opener admitted to using sandpaper in the second and third Tests. His explosive and detailed statement overlaps much of what Khawaja wrote in the Sandpapergate chapter, which was dedicated to Bancroft, Warner and Smith.
Unlike Khawaja’s version, Bancroft’s recollection of the Newlands conversation Khawaja witnessed makes an explicit reference to sandpaper.
“It has been documented that a coach approached me during our fielding innings telling me that I needed to do more with the sandpaper on the ball to get it to swing,” Bancroft wrote. “That coach was David Saker and it is true.”
Bancroft served a nine-month ban from the national team. He has not represented the country since being dumped from the Test side in the 2019 Ashes.
Steve Smith: There are multiple accounts of the former captain saying “I don’t want to know” when the sandpaper plot was being hatched in South Africa. They back up CA’s findings in 2018, which resulted in Smith being given playing and leadership bans.
Smith has not spoken publicly since the release of Khawaja’s book.
David Warner: Bancroft claims long-time ball manager Warner hatched the idea to use sandpaper. Warner said he could not be the player to use sandpaper because of the attention on him from the broadcaster, Bancroft wrote, so the job fell to the West Australian newcomer Bancroft.
Bancroft’s statement corroborates CA’s 2018 finding that Warner was the mastermind of the sandpaper plot.
Warner has backed Khawaja’s account in his memoir Sabr, describing it as “100 per cent accurate”. Khawaja did not say it was Warner’s idea to use sandpaper, instead claiming “we were all the architects”.
The former vice captain has accused CA of a cover-up and conducting a “botched” investigation. He said Cummins threw Khawaja under the bus in his press conference.
Peter Handscomb: The Victorian was involved in the conversation with Lehmann on the walkie-talkie. He then went onto the field to chat with Bancroft after the fielder was caught concealing the sandpaper in his underwear.
“He said to me: ‘I think it’s time I take that off you now’,” Bancroft wrote of their on-field exchange.
Handscomb refused to be drawn into the saga last week when questioned after play during a Sheffield Shield match.
Mitchell Marsh: The all-rounder was bowling at the time South African broadcaster SuperSport aired the incriminating footage of Bancroft in Cape Town. He refused to be drawn into Khawaja’s claims the whole team knew of the sandpaper plot, saying last week that he had moved on from the events of eight years ago.
Chadd Sayers: The back-up Test paceman has admitted to taking the sandpaper off the field.
Support staff
Kate Hutchison: Media manager Kate Hutchison left a team meeting before play at Port Elizabeth after expressing her objection to the use of sandpaper.
“I recall her making it clear that she believed it was wrong, that she wanted nothing to do with it, and walking away from the discussion,” Bancroft wrote. “I will never forget that. Somebody had spoken up.
“Somebody had demonstrated that being part of the team did not mean having to accept everything the team was doing. And I ignored it.”
Bancroft said Hutchison also told him of the serious consequences were he to be busted using sandpaper. It was not heeded, nor was her advice to Bancroft and Smith not to appear at the press conference after play in Cape Town.
Read more on the sandpaper scandal
News, results and expert analysis from the weekend of sport sent every Monday. Sign up for our Sport newsletter.
From our partners
Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: www.smh.com.au







