Capital Gain
The number of vacant shops on Melbourne’s suburban shopping strips has blown out this year for the first time in a decade, but falling consumer confidence is not behind the slump.
While retailers are struggling all over the city with a slowdown in spending, suburban shopping streets are powering on – bar a handful that are undergoing major construction works.
Real estate agency Fitzroys has released its annual Walking the Strips report detailing retail vacancies in 37 of the city’s busiest shopping villages and streets.
While all strips suffered store closures during COVID’s lockdowns in 2020-21, this year’s report shows construction activity on four major shopping strips helped increase this year’s vacancy average rate to 8.1 per cent from last year’s 7.2 per cent.
“You’ve got to look beyond the numbers to see what’s going on,” Fitzroys’ James Lockwood said.
“And it’s pretty clear. There are four main strips which are going through generational renewal and development: Chapel Street, South Yarra; Toorak Village; Carlisle Street, Balaclava; and Lygon Street, East Brunswick.”
Chapel Street, South Yarra, which has struggled to find a new identity after its status as a fashion mecca collapsed in the early 2010s, took another hit this year, with vacancies more than doubling to 20.7 per cent from 9.1 per cent.
The north end of Chapel Street is dominated by construction at Gurner and Qualitas’ $5 billion Jam Factory redevelopment, and there are three more projects on the horizon.
“When there’s construction, there’s less parking and accessibility,” Lockwood said. “They come back when it’s getting close to the end.”
Toorak Village, where vacancies have nearly doubled to 13.6 per cent from 7.7 per cent, is also going through a massive redevelopment wave and established retailers have fumed at the loss of parking during construction.
The prospect of change contributes to the stasis. Many landlords are waiting for new planning amendments to be finalised. Then they would be able to strategically review their holdings and commit to new leases with new and existing tenants, Lockwood said.
“On the flip side, when the strips have gone through the development phase or the level crossing removals, you see what’s happened on the other side,” he said
Puckle Street, Moonee Ponds, where more than 2000 residents have been added over the past 10 years, is sitting comfortably at 2.4 per cent in No.3 position.
Lockwood pointed out steady development around the strips of Centre Road, Bentleigh – in the second spot at 1.6 per cent – and Glen Huntly Road, Elsternwick, which scored a vacancy rate of 4.6 per cent.
“They all had their level crossing removed, and they have bounced back.”
The overall health of these shopping strips is also improving. While the number of speciality shops has fallen, food and beverage and services have increased their share. Services tenants are up 2.2 per cent to 29.2 per cent and food is at 31 per cent.
During periods of economic uncertainty, discretionary spending is often the first area households reduce, hitting fashion, gifts, homewares and other speciality categories.
But there is another reason the strips are diversifying? “Beauty, gyms, cafes – they can’t be replicated online,” Lockwood said.
Lowest vacancy
Church Street, Brighton, reclaimed its spot as the strip with the smallest number of empty shops, clocking a vacancy rate of 0.7 per cent.
Last year, the village was pipped by Centre Road, Bentleigh, which rose slightly to 1.6 per cent from last year’s 1 per cent.
One of its few empty shops – No.15c – has been leased to Alex Fevola’s Runway Room Cosmetics.
Nichols Crowder agent Cameron Williams, who did the deal, said: “It’s her third shop. The first one was in Sorrento and the second one is in High Street, Armadale.”
Meanwhile, the empty shop at No.63 was recently bought by the Carla Zampatti group for $5.8 million in an off-market deal transacted by Stonebridge.
And the blacked-out empty bank branch at 53-55 Church Street? Records show Mecca founders Jo Horgan and Peter Wetenhall paid $3.9 million for it in 2024. Mecca is housed across the street at No.58.
Part of Church Street’s success is its restricted three-block length and good access to public transport, according to the volunteers at Biccy’s Op Shop.
Dawn, 92, hasn’t been into the city for years. While that’s partly due to safety concerns, it’s also because Church Street has “everything you need”.
“And every weekend it’s packed,” Dawn said. “We’ve got the cinema and the church. The station and the bus provide excellent service and are never late.”
While the street is full of high street fashion shops, “more and more are coming into the op shop”, Dawn said. Biccy’s donated $100,000 last year.
Co-volunteer Barbara said there was also plenty of fashion to attract shoppers – Sportscraft, Country Road, Assemble, Perri Cutten, Oroton, Hoss, Husk, Seed, Cable are dotted all the way down the street.
But the increasing number of the chain store boutiques is a source of disquiet on the street, where there is already plenty of anger about planning laws that could allow 12 storeys in the village and six storeys in the immediate vicinity.
One shop owner, who declined to be named, said “corporate shops” were taking over the strip.
“One shop closes and then they move in. They can afford to lose money. We’re small businesses and no one does anything for us.”
Travelworld co-owner Julie Avery, who is secretary of the local traders’ association, said: “I can see why the corporate businesses want to be there. They want to be here and High Street, Armadale.
“We get a lot of visitors on the street, especially on the weekend. The cafes and pubs are really busy on the weekend.”
Williams said: “What happens when you have that many women’s apparel shops on the strip? You don’t increase the size of the pie – you decrease the size of the slice.”
Tam talks
Surprisingly, the High Street, Armadale, strip doesn’t make the top 10 because it’s the other location where local and national businesses are keenest to get a foothold.
Once full of antique shops and bridal boutiques, the street is now packed with women’s fashion boutiques, jewellers and beauty shops.
Its vacancy rate of 6.5 per cent is slightly higher than last year’s 5.1 per cent, but it has held steady over the years.
While there are newcomers to the cashed-up strip, many retailers downsize or upsize into another shop rather than leave, according to Belle Commercial’s Tamara Gross, who has been dubbed the “Queen of Dramadale” by fans of her social media account, Tam Talks Real Estate.
Last summer, Gross got Sydney and Byron Bay jeweller Love Isabelle into a 69-square-metre space at 1250 High Street after a three-year search for the right spot.
In other moves, Perth-based Flannel is subleasing Country Road’s old digs at No.1031 and Perri Cutten has relocated to No.1147.
Gross told Capital Gain that rental costs and the dominance of online shopping were driving retailers into smaller shops rather than leaving the street.
“Everyone wants to be on High Street or Church Street or vice versa,” said Teska Carson’s Reece Israel, who is also active on the strip.
Israel negotiated Oroton’s move out of No.1039 and into Perri Cutten’s old space at No.1079-1081.
Other recent deals include Effie Kats opening at 980 High Street, Nadia Bartel’s Henne into No.1008, and activewear retailer The Upside subleasing Diida’s old space at No.1077.
“High Street is like a game of chess,” Gross said. “I’ve had the best year of my professional life.”
The Business Briefing newsletter delivers major stories, exclusive coverage and expert opinion. Sign up to get it every weekday morning.
From our partners
Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: www.smh.com.au





