Home International Nurse stabbed in the back by patient in latest case of mental...

Nurse stabbed in the back by patient in latest case of mental health system violence

0
3
Advertisement
Grant McArthur

A nurse suffered a 12-centimetre stab wound in the back at the hands of a patient in the latest incident of extreme violence to emerge in Victoria’s embattled mental health system.

The mental health worker, in his late 30s from The Alfred hospital, is still struggling to recover from the September 11 attack, in which a large kitchen knife was plunged into him, narrowly missing his spinal cord and vital organs.

The nurse spent eight days in hospital recovering from his injuries.Getty Images

His colleague narrowly escaped injury after being chased by the knife-wielding patient, who was being transferred from his home to an acute mental health unit because of his deteriorating condition.

As police, health authorities and WorkSafe continue investigations into the stabbing, the injured nurse’s family and colleagues have warned the case is another example of the increasing dangers faced by workers, patients and the community due to failures in Victoria’s psychiatric system.

Advertisement
Advertisement

“But he was also a very active person before the incident and would run marathons, for example. It is unclear at this stage if he will ever regain his full mobility, strength and agility.

“But it is the mental trauma that he is suffering from the most at the moment.

“What he’s experiencing now is a lot of reliving of that event.”

Following a prolonged period in a community care unit, the patient had been able to return home, while continuing to receive care for schizophrenia under a compulsory treatment order.

When concerns mounted over the man’s deteriorating health and his refusal to take antipsychotic medications, the two Alfred Health mental health workers were tasked with transferring him to a secure facility.

Advertisement

Despite concerns about the man’s increasing psychosis, the experienced nurse and his allied health colleague were not supported by a doctor, police, security guards or lived-experience workers to help risk assess, comfort and de-escalate the patient during the community callout.

During a brief moment when his back was turned during the transfer, the nurse was stabbed. The blade passed so close to his spinal cord that he suffered a fractured vertebra and muscle damage.

The nurse remained in hospital for a week and needed help walking before being discharged to focus on overcoming the psychological trauma.

The patient was taken to a secure acute mental health unit, where he continues to receive treatment. No charges have been laid, though the nurses’ partner said attention needed to focus on gaps in the mental health system rather than the individuals relying on it.

Advertisement

“I don’t think there were enough systems in place to have identified and controlled the risk presented by the patient,” she said.

“It is concerning that that level of risk happens for him and his colleague, and that level of risk is not something that you should have to deal with as part of your work.”

A spokesperson for The Alfred said its two staff members were confronted with “extreme occupational violence” during a community callout, which is subject to an internal review as well as a WorkSafe investigation.

The Alfred’s home-visiting guidelines and approaches are being examined as part of the review.

“Every day, our clinicians undertake incredibly important work helping people experiencing mental health crises, though incidents like this are unacceptable,” the spokesperson said.

Advertisement

“Ongoing support is being provided to the team involved, and we are working with others in the system with the hope of making it safer to continue the much-needed specialist care that helps those in greatest need.”

Health and Community Services Union Victorian branch secretary Paul Healey said the lack of a cohesive system within public mental health meant there are many instances where patients escalate, leaving mental health workers, paramedics, police and the public at risk.

“Every single day mental health clinicians are being sent out to see consumers who are very unwell and risks are being taken with staff and consumers safety to compensate for a lack of funding, lack of staff and a lack of a meaningful and cohesive system that can wrap around the consumer at the most difficult time of their life,” Healey said.

While Victoria’s Mental Health and Wellbeing Act was introduced to create a patient-centred and compassionate system, the injured nurse’s partner is concerned its intent is being compromised by a lack of resources.

Advertisement

“Increasing demand, limited funding and workforce shortages raise concerns about whether community services have the capacity and resources to provide safe and effective support to people with complex needs,” she said.


A Department of Health spokesperson said adverse events in mental health care are rare, and every effort is made to reduce the risk of violence and aggression through staff training and workplace protocols, the spokesperson said.

“Two recent incidents at Alfred Health and Thomas Embling Hospital have been especially distressing for impacted staff and the Office of the Chief Psychiatrist has been working closely with each health service as it undertakes its incident review, supports staff, and implements any necessary changes.”

Read more on Victoria’s mental health crisis:

Advertisement

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: www.smh.com.au