A few months ago I was on a Zoom call with two business-unit CFOs at a company with 100,000 employees. They had just paid a big consulting firm to look at their pricing. The firm found the company was charging less than its own strategy called for. Fixing that added a point or two of margin, and the consulting project paid for itself.
So then I asked: Would you do the same thing for pay?
A long pause. Shrugs. Then one of them said, “Everybody believes we’re making the right ‘people’ decisions. Nothing is obviously broken.”
It almost always is broken. Just not in ways executives can see until someone adds it all up.
Pay is one of the biggest costs a company has. Most companies have a pay strategy on paper: where they want to land against the market, how they use salary ranges, what they say they reward. The finance department watches the total. It knows whether department leaders came in on budget with headcount projections. But the individual decisions behind it (offers, raises, bonuses, promotions) leak millions per year. And under new right-to-information and pay-transparency laws, pay that drifts from the agreed-upon strategy one decision at a time gets awfully hard to explain.
In the data we’ve analyzed so far, about 6% of accepted offers land outside the company’s own ranges, and one company was at 16%. At one company the written policy says offer around the middle of the band; only 19% of hires landed there. Often there’s a good reason. It just isn’t written down anywhere so nobody can explain it.
Added up, though, that’s money walking out the door, and it rarely shows up as a problem. The budget looks fine overall, so nobody goes looking. Across our customers, companies come to us having paid 6% to 7% more than they needed to, mostly because pay in certain functions just veers off course. Some of it is what we lovingly call Special Snowflakes: the vaunted hires, the one-off exceptions. Or it’s the manager who wanted to keep someone happy. Each exception seems reasonable at the time. Add enough of them up and you’ve got a pay strategy built on one-offs.
Compensation is a tough job right now. The market has split in two. On one hand, wage growth is flat and so is voluntary attrition. Nick Lichtenberg at Fortune summed up the week’s data in one line: “Workers are scarce, and they’re still losing ground.”
On the other hand, there are hypercompetitive pockets in AI, AI infrastructure and security. AI and machine learning engineers earn 15 to 20% more in base than comparable technology roles, and at senior levels the premium runs up to 30%. Employers are paying bonuses worth 20 to 24% of base for AI engineering, cybersecurity and data architecture skills.
Compensation teams sit between talent, finance and legal. Talent wants competitive offers to nab top people. Finance doesn’t want to spend more than necessary. Legal wants no pay-equity risk.
And pay compression, as it’s known, is very real: new hires are coming in at close to, or above, what long-time employees make. Three out of four companies in our data select “time at the company” as a factor to reward in their pay model. But in the regression models that look at actual impact, that factor explains nothing: at the typical company, tenure accounts for 0% of the difference in pay. And when tenure does have a measurable impact, 93.5% of the time it actually works against people. The people who stayed are the people whose pay fell behind.
The people who run pay, the heads of Total Rewards, feel this every day. They know with pay transparency looming, an explainable, consistent pay strategy will be crucial. And who makes the call on pay is shifting.
This fall, I was talking with the executive who runs pay at a large company where the head of HR had just announced their retirement. I asked whether they were going to go for the job. The answer? A firm no. They’d rather keep the seat next to the CFO and in front of the board’s compensation committee. That’s where the big decisions about money get made, and pay is money.
Right now, companies control pay with blunt instruments: cap the budget, freeze hiring and raises or lay people off.
Finance is also the only department in the company that has to show its work to someone outside it. Every year an auditor asks where a number came from, who owns it, and whether the trail holds up. That question is now reaching the numbers AI helps produce. In BDO’s survey of 200 finance leaders this fall, 99% said AI touches at least one estimate their auditor reviews, and fewer than half have a way to substantiate every result. The auditors will not let that stand for long. Nobody asks those three questions about a job offer or a bonus payment. The pay leaders who moved next to the CFO expect someone will, and they would rather be in the room that already knows how to answer.
As pay leaders move closer to the CFO and the board’s compensation committee, they can offer something better for the company and its people. Pay decisions that follow the strategy, hold up to scrutiny and can be explained to anyone who asks.
The payoff is millions in savings. Top talent hired for reasons you can actually defend. A system that keeps working as the company grows.
Remember those two CFOs on the Zoom? They didn’t blink to have someone check their pricing. But it didn’t occur to them to check on pay. That’s why the best pay leaders are clamoring for the seat next to the CFO — because pay is money.
It’s time it actually got looked at that way.
The opinions expressed in Fortune.com commentary pieces are solely the views of their authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinions and beliefs of Fortune. This is a repost of Pay Dirt, the Substack by regular Fortune contributor Maria Colacurcio about compensation, AI, and the systems we choose to build.
Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: fortune.com






