Home Health ‘What is a man?’ Leaked talking points lay bare tightly controlled Coalition...

‘What is a man?’ Leaked talking points lay bare tightly controlled Coalition campaign

0
2
Advertisement
Angus Delaney

What is a man? How much does a loaf of bread and two litres of milk cost?

These are the pressing questions for which Coalition candidates are being provided scripted answers as the opposition seeks to avoid any last-minute campaign gaffes, according to documents leaked days out from the state election.

The Coalition is running a carefully managed campaign behind Jess Wilson by providing scripted lines to candidates. Luis Enrique Ascui

Daily “talking points” from the Coalition’s campaign headquarters, obtained by The Age, also instruct political hopefuls how to manage voter queries over the dumped Liberal candidate for Williamstown, Paul Lindemann, and racist remarks made by a party volunteer.

The concerted effort to avoid any embarrassing moments or signs of inconsistency coincides with the party privately warning candidates they may be covertly recorded by their political enemies at early voting booths.

Advertisement

The talking points also reveal the Coalition’s full-throated decision to join the gender wars, with scripted lines provided to candidates following One Nation’s pledge to ban trans women from using female bathrooms, and the federal government’s review into puberty blockers.

In the first daily note – provided to candidates on November 18, one day after Opposition Leader Jess Wilson said the use of puberty blockers in Victoria’s public health system should be reviewed – Coalition candidates were coached on the topic under the subhead “issues of the day”.

This included instructions on how candidates should manage specific questions including “What is a man?”

Candidates were told to respond: “A biological male.”

Advertisement

They were also told how to answer question of “where should trans [people] get changed?”

“We’re not proposing to replace gendered facilities with gender-neutral toilets,” candidates were instructed to say. “If businesses and organisations want to construct gender-neutral facilities that is a matter for them.”

The same briefing also contains go-to lines for discussing the use of puberty blockers. It directly parrots language the party used in media releases attributable to Wilson.

“Right now, the Carroll Labor government allows life-altering puberty suppressants to be prescribed for Victorian children despite contested views from experts in this treatment space,” the briefing said.

Advertisement

The document advised candidates to tell voters biological sex matters, and “we shouldn’t be afraid to say that”.

“Women and girls should be able to use female-only toilets and change rooms with privacy, dignity and confidence,” it said. “I don’t support replacing those facilities with gender-neutral toilets.”

The Coalition’s campaign has relied heavily on Wilson’s popularity.Simon Schluter

All daily talking points contain a fact sheet filled with figures to help candidates avoid getting caught by “gotcha questions”, including the Reserve Bank’s cash rate and the unemployment rate, the cost of a dozen eggs and two litres of milk, and the price of a litre of unleaded petrol.

On the first day of the 2022 federal election campaign, then-opposition leader Anthony Albanese admitted he made a mistake when he couldn’t answer questions from journalists about the cash and unemployment rates.

Advertisement

Peter Dutton during the 2025 federal campaign also made a gaffe by underestimating the price of a dozen eggs during a televised debate, saying they cost $4.20 – well below the $8.80 price tag at Woolworths.

The Coalition’s leaked documents draw attention to its tightly managed campaign, which has put Wilson at the centre and kept other MPs somewhat out of view.

Wilson has taken occasional risks in front of the media on the campaign trail, including an unscripted trip to a Wodonga pub favoured heavily by One Nation voters, and handing out how-to-vote cards at an early voting centre in Kew.

But except for rare appearances by trusted media performers like frontbenchers Brad Battin and James Newbury, and some joint press conferences with candidates, the Coalition’s campaign has been risk-averse to maintain its lead in the polls.

Advertisement

In addition to being provided with scripted messaging, candidates have been repeatedly warned in meetings they are at risk of being covertly recorded by volunteers for other parties at polling booths, according to a Liberal source speaking anonymously to detail internal conversations.

Last month, the Liberal candidate for Sunbury, Simmone Cottom, was caught on tape telling people to vote for One Nation in the upper house. She later said she regretted the comments.

Political hopefuls are also being urged to shut down conversations with voters regarding Lindemann, the party’s former Williamstown candidate, who was disendorsed after The Age revealed he posted offensive remarks about Indigenous people on a burner Facebook account. Lindemann is now standing as independent.

On Wednesday, this masthead also published footage of Lindemann chasing down a man he alleged defaced his corflutes. He later reported the incident to police.

Advertisement

In talking points from Thursday morning, the Coalition’s campaign HQ instructed candidates how to respond if asked by voters: “Were you made aware of the citizen’s arrest?”

“When Mr Lindermann [sic] was a candidate the campaign was aware that he caught someone vandalising his signs and that he referred the matter to police,” candidates were told to say.

“Any other questions around that are now a matter for Mr Lindermann [sic] as he is no longer our candidate.”

Candidates on Friday were also coached how to respond to questions over bigoted slurs used by a Liberal volunteer in Dandenong.

Advertisement

“The comments made by a volunteer are appalling, racist and completely unacceptable,” the document said.

“The volunteer, who was not a party member, will not be permitted to volunteer again.”

Read more on the Victorian election:

Angus DelaneyAngus Delaney is a state political reporter at The Age. Email him at angus.delaney@theage.com.au or contact him securely on Signal at angusdelaney.31Connect via email.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: www.smh.com.au