Home International He left her for dead, then tattooed her name on his leg....

He left her for dead, then tattooed her name on his leg. Now her family want the law changed

0
2
Advertisement
Tayla Richardson has spoken out about her mother’s death, calling for new legislation to criminalise those who leave people suffering from a medical episode to die.Joe Armao

Left to die, Narelle Simmons bore the unmistakable marks of domestic violence across her bruised frame, hidden under a blanket with a pillow over her face for over a week.

Her daughter, Tayla Richardson, never got to say goodbye. When funeral directors warned her that viewing her mother’s decaying remains could traumatise her, she had listened.

She was used to seeing her mother’s flesh brutalised. Trapped in an abusive relationship, Richardson says her mother had been duct-taped, degraded, trampled, kicked, burned and chased with a hammer.

Tayla Richardson is calling for legislation change after her mother’s death in 2021.
Tayla Richardson is calling for legislation change after her mother’s death in 2021.60 Minutes

Richardson says the last time she saw her mum alive in September 2021, Narelle had “been beaten from her forehead down to her chin. She was purple and yellow, and she had scratch marks all up and down her arms.”

She gave her mum money, told her she loved her and said she would call soon.

The following month, Narelle was left to endure a lonely death on a mattress in her Cranbourne home. Her partner, Craig Jennion, was nowhere to be found.

Advertisement

Now, five years later, Richardson is calling for legislation change that would protect other women from suffering the same fate, and punish those who leave their “loved ones” for dead.

In Victoria, there is no specific law to criminalise the failure to alert Triple Zero when someone is in dire need of medical help. Gross negligence manslaughter is a charge – but it doesn’t capture the circumstances of some cases.

It is a gap in the law the devastated families of victims of those who have been left to die alone without potentially life-saving medical treatment are fighting to change.

In October 2021, Richardson, then just 21 years old, realised she hadn’t heard from her mother in over a week. When she couldn’t reach her on the phone, she called the Cranbourne police station and asked them to conduct a welfare check.

Tayla and her mum Narelle.
Tayla and her mum Narelle.

By the time officers entered Narelle’s home and found her body, she had been lying there for nine days. Richardson says she instantly knew Jennion was involved.

When Jennion eventually handed himself in, he told them he’d beaten Narelle. He admitted he’d punched her twice in the face and elbowed her in the back of the head. He told them that the next morning when he woke, he had tried CPR before fleeing the scene.

Advertisement

He was arrested and later charged, but not with causing Narelle’s death – a post-mortem exam determined she had died as a result of drug and alcohol complications, pneumonia, chest injuries and haemothorax.

Instead, Jennion was charged with common assault and failing to report a reportable death. He served five months in prison.

“He’s living scot-free,” Richardson says. “I saw him. When I ran into him, he’s got a tattoo of my mum’s name on the back of his leg.

“You have taken away, from an entire family, the right to say goodbye. How does that only deserve a couple of months?”

A legislative blind spot

As families rally for change – and with an election next week – the Victorian Labor Party has committed to introducing a specific law that would criminalise the act of abandoning a person who needs medical help in an intimate partner relationship.

Attorney-General Sonya Kilkenny says there is a gap in the legislation.
Attorney-General Sonya Kilkenny says there is a gap in the legislation.60 Minutes
Advertisement

Attorney-General Sonya Kilkenny says a number of recent coroners’ reports had identified a “gap” in the justice system that allows perpetrators of domestic violence who abandon their partners in a time of need to avoid prosecution.

“It’s terrible, and I think when you talk to people about this notion of a partner abandoning his partner when they need medical assistance or medical support in circumstances where there have been family violence, and you look at that act of abandonment as that final act of control, you know that is wrong,” she says.

“You know it is wrong, and we need a justice system that can address that and hold that person accountable.”

We need to create a criminal offence, she explains, that has never existed in the state.

An offence that will send “a very strong message to all of the community that this is no longer acceptable, and we will be criminalising this kind of conduct in family violence circumstances”.

Kilkenny says the act of abandonment is an “act of final control by a perpetrator”.

The Liberals have also committed to the new legislation.

Advertisement

Shadow attorney-general James Newbury says it’s clear “we need action”.

“The Liberals and Nationals will consider creating both a new offence where a victim in medical need is abandoned and establishing that such abandonment is an example of family violence, in relation to the Family Violence Protection Act 2008 (Vic),” he says.

Parents fight a justice system they say let them down

The new offence is something the family of 26-year-old Amy Bowden have also been calling for nationwide since their daughter’s death.

In February 2024, Amy had overdosed on heroin. Instead of calling for help, her partner Ethan Ross injected her with methamphetamine. He told police he’d acted under the belief the combination of a downer and an upper would reverse the overdose. He was wrong.

Michelle Sposito and Bryan Bowden with a picture of their late daughter Amy Bowden.
Michelle Sposito and Bryan Bowden with a picture of their late daughter Amy Bowden.Jason South

For 24 hours, Ethan failed to get her the help she desperately needed. When he finally did decide to call an ambulance, it was too little too late.

Advertisement

Michelle Sposito, who lives in Melbourne, can clearly remember the exact morning she got the call from South Australian paramedics telling her they were sorry – they’d tried everything, but they couldn’t save her daughter.

“If he had got appropriate help for her, they said she would most likely have survived,” Sposito says.

“He could have made many choices. He knew for 24 hours she was overdosing.”

Earlier this year, Ross was released from prison in South Australia after serving a sentence of nine months for administering a controlled drug to Amy. With time served, he walked out of prison in June.

He was not charged with causing her death – a decision that left Michelle and Bryan feeling they had been let down by the justice system.

It’s a case that concerns Associate Professor Andrew Dyer, an expert in criminal law at Melbourne University.

Associate Professor Andrew Dyer, criminal law expert at Melbourne University.
Associate Professor Andrew Dyer, criminal law expert at Melbourne University.60 Minutes

“On my understanding of what has happened here, Amy has overdosed from heroin. She’s unconscious. She’s in his custody. He then doesn’t call an ambulance,” Dyer says.

“What he instead does is administer drugs to her in the misconceived idea that this might help her to overcome the effects of the heroin overdose. He’s with her for around 24 hours, and it’s only at a very late stage that he does ring an ambulance, by which time it’s too late.

“I’m not pointing any fingers at anybody for not doing their job properly, but on the existing state of the law, Ethan Ross does appear to be sailing pretty close to the wind.”

The case also seemed to concern the sentencing judge who said: “I bear in mind that the neglect on your part … does not form part of the charge … You are not charged with performing an act that endangered life, or performing an act that contributed to Ms Bowden’s passing. You are not charged with criminal neglect.”

Ethan Ross moved back to Melbourne earlier this year.
Ethan Ross moved back to Melbourne earlier this year. 60 Minutes

Now back living in Victoria, where he met Amy years ago, Ross had no answer when asked by 60 Minutes why he chose to wait to call Triple Zero.

Ultimately, it was up to South Australia Police and the Department of Public Prosecutions to decide what Ross would be charged with.

Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: www.smh.com.au