Home International Leaders commit to ‘most expensive and least effective method’ as remand numbers...

Leaders commit to ‘most expensive and least effective method’ as remand numbers soar

0
2
Advertisement
Chip Le Grand

The number of people on remand has surged to an all-time high in Victoria, prompting warnings that an already strained corrections system is on track to reach breaking point in the coming months.

Figures provided to The Age by Corrections Victoria show that as the state entered an election campaign punctuated by tough-on-crime promises and rhetoric from both major parties last month, 3264 prisoners were behind bars waiting for charges against them to be dealt with.

This is the highest number of people on remand since Corrections Victoria started keeping monthly records in 1998, and surpasses the previous watermark in February 2020, when the corrections system was plunged into crisis following the death of Aboriginal woman Veronica Nelson while on remand the month prior.

The number of Aboriginal people in prison has also risen to a new post-pandemic high of 1188 people – a figure representing 15 per cent of Victoria’s total prison population of 7891 people.

Advertisement

Prison guards and lawyers working at the sharp end of the justice system have warned the state’s prison population is on an unsustainable trajectory. Community and Public Sector Union Victorian Secretary Jiselle Hanna, who previously worked for Corrections Victoria, said the spillover of remand prisoners into police station cells was creating a dangerous environment.

“Whoever wins government needs to understand that you can’t keep putting more people behind bars without providing the staff, facilities and resources to safely manage them,” Hanna said.

Opposition Leader Jess Wilson, with son Patrick, leads a walk in Montmorency in memory of Pat Cronin, who died from a coward punch 10 years ago.luis enrique ascui

However, these concerns were dismissed by Jess Wilson. The opposition leader is widely expected to win office on November 28 after campaigning hard on law and order issues. She promised on Sunday to provide whatever additional prison beds were needed to accommodate more people behind bars, but remained firm on the Coalition’s commitment to cracking down on crime.

“We will work with Corrections Victoria. But if you need a prison cell in this state under a government I lead, you will get one,” Wilson said.

Advertisement

“Victorians are sick of waking up every morning to another home invasion, to another carjacking, to another firebombing in this state, and I won’t apologise for getting tough on crime.”

A government spokesperson was similarly unapologetic. They said the latest prison numbers showed Labor’s tighter bail laws, introduced in March last year, were working as intended. Since then, both the remand population and the overall prison population have increased by 30 per cent respectively.

Unapologetic: Premier Ben Carroll.Louis Trerise

“We will not apologise for more people being on remand or in jail,” the spokesperson said. “We have hired more than 1000 prison officers and opened more than 1000 prison beds.”

The opposition is promising to further tighten bail laws by making remand mandatory for anyone, including youth offenders, who reoffends while on bail for a serious offence. It has also committed to increasing the number of offences where it becomes highly unlikely to be granted bail in the first place.

Advertisement

Wilson on Sunday announced that under a Coalition government, Victoria’s Director of Public Prosecutions would be called before parliament once a year to answer questions about how the justice system is functioning.

Wilson would not say whether the Coalition had modelled the likely impact on the corrections system, but said the financial cost of the reforms would be released later this week alongside other election costings.

The price of Victoria’s swollen jails was made clear in the 2025-26 state budget, which set aside $727 million to build and staff an additional 1000 prison beds. More recently, the government announced a further $21 million to open 59 more beds at the Metropolitan Remand Centre (MRC), 150 extra beds at the Ravenhall Correctional Centre, and 29 more spots within the Dame Phyllis Frost Centre.

The extra capacity promised for the MRC, a facility purpose-built for people awaiting trial or sentencing, is less than the monthly increase in Victoria’s remand population between September 30 and October 31.

Advertisement

The number of prisoners serving custodial sentences has remained stable throughout the life of the Labor government. When former premier Daniel Andrews first came to power in November 2014, there were 5045 sentenced prisoners in Victoria. At the end of last month, there were 4621.

The volatility in prison numbers is due to a wildly fluctuating remand population.

CPSU Victorian secretary Jiselle Hanna.Justin McManus

The Community and Public Sector Union’s Code Blue report, released in September, detailed the physical and verbal abuse, other safety risks and poor retention rates faced by people working in the prison system, finding some of the most challenging and dangerous work was in dealing with prisoners on remand.

“Tougher bail laws might make people feel safer, but it’s prison officers and police custody officers who are left dealing with the consequences, and they’re the ones getting hurt,” Jiselle Hanna said.

Advertisement

Sam Norton, a partner with the Melbourne law firm Stary Norton Halphen & Galbally, has been working in the justice system for 25 years and said the problems now emerging are similar to those he experienced when the prison population peaked before the pandemic.

Norton said people on remand are unable to access the sort of rehabilitative programs offered to sentenced prisoners, and recounted a colleague recently handling a case where a prisoner being kept in police station cell was denied proper health and mental health care.

Norton said a predictable consequence of having more people in prison was backlogs in the Magistrates’ Court, which in turn leads to people spending longer on remand.

“Anyone who has engaged to any degree on solutions to crime knows that the most expensive and least effective method is prison, and yet both major parties are running on more prison in circumstances where they’re also trying to talk about budget repair,” said Norton, who previously served as vice-president of Liberty Victoria.

Advertisement

“Whatever happens in the election, people who work in the jurisdiction will hope there can be a reset, without the heat of an election campaign, whether the next government engages productively on finding not just populist solutions, but workable solutions to improve the system.”

Be the first to know when major news happens. Sign up for breaking news alerts on email or turn on notifications in the app.

Chip Le GrandChip Le Grand leads our state politics reporting team. He previously served as the paper’s chief reporter and is a journalist of 30 years’ experience.Connect via email.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: www.smh.com.au