A proposal to let asylum seekers enter the German job market sooner has been welcomed by many lawmakers and economists, but critics warn that key exemptions and recent cuts to integration courses could undermine the effort.
Germany’s Federal Interior Ministry has announced plans to allow some asylum seekers to work sooner after arriving in the country.
The proposal was presented by Federal Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt of the conservative Christian Social Union (CSU) party in Berlin over the weekend.
Many economists, as well as the Interior Ministry’s coalition partners in the centre-left Social Democrats (SPD), have welcomed the idea as a pragmatic response to labour shortages and a way to speed up integration.
At the same time, refugee organisations, migration researchers and members of the Green party have raised important critiques, warning that the reform may help fewer people than it appears to – and could actually end up excluding more asylum seekers from work.
What exactly is the Interior Ministry proposing?
Under the plan, asylum seekers would generally be allowed to take up employment after three months in Germany, even if their asylum application has not yet been decided.
This would apply both to regular employment and so‑called mini‑jobs, the Interior Ministry told AFP.
At present, asylum seekers can theoretically apply to work after three months, but in practice many cannot because they are required to remain in initial reception centres, where employment is usually prohibited.
READ ALSO: Planned immigration crackdown by Bavaria’s CSU slammed as ‘propaganda’
The ministry’s new “immediate employment plan” would remove that obstacle, allowing people to work regardless of whether they are still living in a reception facility.
Reducing work bans for refugees to a maximum of three months had been agreed by the conservative Union parties (CDU/CSU) and the centre-left Social Democratic Party (SPD) in their coalition agreement made last year.
The Interior Ministry also stressed that there would be no obligation to work, and that employment would have no influence on the outcome of the asylum procedure.
What is the plan designed to achieve?
The Interior Ministry has framed the reform in strongly economic terms, saying that the main aims are to reduce social welfare costs, ease labour shortages and enable asylum seekers to support themselves financially sooner.
“Anyone who comes here should be able to work – and quickly,” Minister Alexander Dobrindt told Bild am Sonntag, adding that “the best integration is into the world of work”.
READ ALSO: The planned changes to immigration and citizenship in Germany in 2026
Economists have echoed this logic. Clemens Fuest, president of the Ifo Institute, called the proposal “a step in the right direction.”
Marcel Fratzscher, president of the German Institute for Economic Research (DIW), described the plan as “smart and long overdue.”
How many asylum seekers will be able to seek work in Germany sooner?
This is where things get complicated.
While the headline change suggests broader access to work after three months, several large groups of asylum seekers will not benefit. As planned, the reform will continue to exclude:
- People from countries officially classified as “safe countries of origin”
- Dublin cases, where another EU state is responsible for the asylum claim
- People whose asylum applications have already been rejected
- People deemed not to be cooperating with the authorities
Crucially, WELT reported that the coalition is also planning to expand the list of safe countries of origin, potentially to include the so-called Maghreb states (Algeria, Libya, Mauritania, Morocco and Tunisia).
If that happens, the number of asylum seekers subject to ongoing work bans after three months could actually increase despite the reform.
READ ALSO: ‘Short-sighted’ – Cutting access to integration courses in Germany doesn’t make sense
How have people reacted?
Support has come first and foremost from economists and the governing parties. Dirk Wiese, parliamentary secretary of the SPD, told the Rheinische Post that work is “decisive for successful integration,” particularly for learning German.
Similar sentiments were expressed by SPD deputy parliamentary group leader Sonja Eichwede, who welcomed the implementation of the proposal from the coalition agreement.
However, some supportive voices have also issued warnings. Marcel Fratzscher argued that faster access to work must be accompanied by investment in training and long‑term prospects.
This concern has become a central theme of the criticism. Recently, the Interior Ministry announced plans to restrict free access to integration and language courses.
Among others, Green politicians have highlighted this contradiction. Marcel Emmerich, domestic policy spokesman for the Greens, called the move a “deceptive manoeuvre,” adding that integration courses are “central to sustainable integration”.
Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: thelocal.de
