Matthew Schaefer’s clutch late goal helps Islanders to stunning comeback win over Blue Jackets

0
3

This is what the Islanders’ future looks like.

Two goals from Matthew Schaefer, the second tying the game at two with under a minute to go, helped the Islanders to a stunning 3-2 comeback win over the Blue Jackets on Sunday night at UBS, as Simon Holmstrom potted the winner with 37 seconds to go.

For the first time since Feb. 1 of last season, the night Mat Barzal hurt his kneecap, he started on the top line alongside Bo Horvat, allowing Cal Ritchie to start in his natural position at center on the second line between Jonathan Drouin and Kyle Palmieri.

That configuration, since Ritchie began showing out in training camp, is one that could give the Islanders their highest ceiling, but it is dependent on the 21-year-old prospect — called up for his Islanders debut Friday night in Washington — being able to handle it.

Matthew Schaefer of the New York Islanders reacts after he scores a goal during the first period when the New York Islanders played the Columbus Blue Jackets Sunday, November 2, 2025. Robert Sabo for NY Post

Ritchie, at least so far, is 2-for-2 on that score, playing his best period in D.C. after being shifted to center and looking right at home on Long Island in the same role against Columbus.

The Islanders, as a result, played with a balanced attack, as coach Patrick Roy rolled four lines for much of the game.

That did not, however, make it an easy night.

While the Isles dominated the shot count and the game early on, Schaefer’s power-play goal was their only breakthrough.

With the Blue Jackets sticking around, it felt only a matter of time before they tied it up, and indeed, Miles Wood’s redirection from Adam Fantilli made it a 1-1 game at 15:21 of the second.

With 7:50 to go in the game, Denton Mateychuk broke through, jamming in Kirill Marchenko’s rebound that came off him to make it 2-1 Blue Jackets. It was the 20th shot of the night for Columbus, and at that point, the Islanders were sitting on 35.



Alexander Romanov and Tony DeAngelo, who have continued to look shaky since Romanov’s return from injury in Carolina, were the pair caught on defense for the goal.

Coach Patrick Roy has taken to playing Romanov with Scott Mayfield and Schaefer with DeAngelo at certain points during games — particularly after penalty kills — and it wouldn’t be a surprise if the Islanders tried to do so more regularly.

That wasn’t, however, the end of things.

Skating at six-on-five, Schaefer’s shot got through traffic and off the stick of Anders Lee to tie the game at two.

Islanders right wing Simon Holmstrom (10) celebrates his winning goal during the third period against Dennis Schneidler-Imagn Images

Seconds later, before the Blue Jackets could earn a point by getting to overtime, Holmstrom knocked the puck in on a scramble in the crease to win the game.

For the second straight game, the Isles’ penalty kill was perfect, keeping the puck out on a trio of Columbus power plays in the second period that could have turned the game, and a fourth in the third period.

Bo Horvat #14 and Mathew Barzal #13 of the New York Islanders battle for the puck against Sean Monahan #23 of the Columbus Blue Jackets at UBS Arena on November 02, 2025 in Elmont, New York. NHLI via Getty Images

David Rittich, who surprisingly got the start ahead of Ilya Sorokin — set to return to the net Tuesday against the Bruins — was much improved from his last showing at Carolina, stopping 20 shots.

In the main, though, this game served as another building block of evidence that Ritchie could be a long-term option to center the second line.

The 21-year-old has yet to get on the scoresheet through two games, but has looked solid in all phases, and particularly dangerous in transition. His line gave up next to nothing defensively, a highly encouraging development for a trio centered by someone playing his ninth NHL game, and second with the Islanders.

Had the Islanders converted their slew of early chances, this would have looked far more encouraging on the scoreboard.

Nevertheless, a second straight win since Ritchie has been called up — and a second straight win in which the lineup looked balanced and Ritchie looked right at home — is a pretty big building block all on its own.

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: nypost.com