OSAKA –
The Osaka District Court on November 18 ordered a hospital to pay 220,000 yen in compensation after a 12-centimeter metal key was discovered lodged in the throat of an 82-year-old patient who died several days later, ruling that the hospital had failed to properly manage the key but rejecting claims that the incident caused his death.
The patient, Kenichi Onishi, had operated a printing-related business in Osaka before his death in 2022. His family had sought 16.5 million yen in damages from the medical corporation operating the hospital, arguing that negligence had allowed him to accidentally swallow the key and that a resulting bacterial infection contributed to his death.
According to the family, Onishi was admitted to a hospital near his home in January 2022 after falling and fracturing a bone in his chest. He remained hospitalized while undergoing rehabilitation.
In September that year, Onishi complained of throat pain and tested positive for COVID-19. Suspecting pneumonia, hospital staff conducted a chest X-ray, which revealed a metal object approximately 12 centimeters long lodged in his throat. The object was removed, but Onishi died several days later.
The key was used to operate the zipper of a special one-piece garment worn by Onishi, who had been diagnosed with mild dementia. The garment was designed to prevent patients from interfering with intravenous lines and other medical equipment.
The hospital had previously acknowledged that the key had most likely been left on a table near Onishi’s bed, where he could have accessed it.
Onishi’s son said he had initially imagined that his father had swallowed a small, ordinary key by mistake. However, seeing the actual object left him shocked by its size, weight and irregular shape.
“When I saw it, I couldn’t believe it,” his son said. “It was heavy and oddly shaped. I still can’t stop thinking about how much my father must have suffered.”
The family argued that the hospital’s failure to secure the key allowed Onishi to swallow it accidentally. They also claimed that the swallowed object caused a bacterial infection that contributed to his death, making the hospital legally responsible for the fatal outcome.
The hospital did not dispute that it had been negligent in managing the key but maintained that Onishi died from COVID-19 and that there was no causal relationship between swallowing the object and his death.
In its November 18 ruling, the Osaka District Court found that the hospital had breached its duty to manage the key appropriately. It ordered the medical corporation to pay a total of 220,000 yen, including compensation for the emotional suffering Onishi experienced.
However, the court rejected the family’s argument that the hospital’s negligence caused his death. It also ruled that the hospital could not be considered legally obligated to confirm that Onishi had not swallowed the key after it went missing.
The decision left the family with only a small portion of the compensation they had sought, despite the court’s recognition that the hospital had mishandled the object.
Following the ruling, the family expressed disappointment and criticized the hospital’s patient management procedures.
“It’s disappointing. If the hospital had properly managed things, this would never have happened,” a family member said. “I wish they had taken better care of their patients.”
When approached for comment, the hospital said the person responsible for responding to media inquiries was unavailable.
Source: YOMIURI
Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: newsonjapan.com








