Home National AI Challenges Notions Of Film Education

AI Challenges Notions Of Film Education

0
3

HYDERABAD: A film without a camera, or even actors, or perhaps even without anyone stepping onto a set. Hyderabad’s upcoming AI Film Festival in December is inviting precisely such films, made from generated images and sound, while elsewhere students continue to spend years learning cinematography, editing and direction. And somewhere between these two ways of making cinema lies a rather uncomfortable problem for film education. What, exactly, should one spend years learning when technology can already do so much of the work?

“You can learn the technical aspects through academic training but if you complete a filmmaking course without understanding the arts and life, you are in trouble,” said B. Narsing Rao, the Telangana filmmaker behind Daasi.

Rao’s education, interestingly, began in the village streets, watching potters, blacksmiths, carpenters and cobblers at work. Rao recalled making a documentary about the rocks around Hyderabad, a subject that initially baffled even his cinematographer. It took an album of photographs to persuade him that there was a film there.

Interestingly, Prague Film School co-founder and director Tariq Hager arrives at much the same argument from inside a film school. He considers literature, architecture, painting and history essential to a filmmaker’s education, alongside the practical business of directing actors and completing productions. “A filmmaker who understands literature, architecture, painting, music, design, history and society will naturally have a richer creative vocabulary. These influences shape how a director frames a scene, develops a character, uses colour or approaches a particular subject,” Hager said.

There is, however, a difference between knowing what one wants to put into a film and discovering how difficult it can be to put it there. Prague Film School students begin by studying screenwriting, direction, cinematography and editing before developing their specialisations.

Hager considers this experience especially valuable for students coming from India. Someone accustomed to Telugu cinema, for instance, might find their understanding of characters, visual composition and narrative conventions challenged by classmates who have grown up watching entirely different kinds of films. It is an education in explaining one’s choices as much as making them. Such experience, he argues, remains useful even if the student returns to Hyderabad rather than pursuing work overseas. “An international education should help students become better filmmakers, not simply give them an overseas qualification.”

But how does a student know whether that education has actually been delivered? There is also the possibility of entering the Telugu industry through assisting on productions, or studying another discipline before attempting cinema.

Filmmaker Anurag Kashyap had once suggested that students consider design schools such as the National Institute of Design instead of conventional film schools. Rao agrees with the importance he places on design. He recalled asking director Nagesh Kukunoor which film school he had attended, only to learn that Kukunoor had studied chemical engineering.

Such examples cannot settle the argument for or against formal film education. What they suggest is that the ability to make a film may develop through experiences that have little apparent connection to cinema. Further, a March 2026 study by Digital Futures Lab, Putting Workers First, identified junior editors and other creative workers among those potentially affected by generative AI. Hager recognises the difficulty this could present and said, “This is an important concern, because the traditional entry-level roles in filmmaking have always been a way for young professionals to learn the discipline of production.”

The question also changes what a film school ought to teach. AI can assist with script development, storyboarding, visualisation, editing and post-production, according to Hager, who believes students need to understand these applications alongside their limitations. “Without that foundation, it becomes difficult to distinguish between using technology creatively and simply relying on it,” Hager said, referring to students’ understanding of cinematography, lighting, sound, directing, editing and screenwriting.

Rao has no particular objection to using AI either. He recalled how his brother used it to translate material between Telugu and English, although errors still needed correction. “Don’t rely on AI. Use it wherever you need it but it will not replace the human brain.”

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: deccanchronicle.com