2026 Fantasy Baseball Top 300: Pete Crow-Armstrong takes over top spot, Josue De Paula debuts

0
2

Here’s our rest-of-season Top 300. Expect this space to be updated every Monday. Players are ranked for 5×5 mixed leagues using a one-catcher format. I include the mixed-league disclaimer because I do reward upside, particularly past the top 200 or so.

⚾️ Baseball is back on NBC: MLB returns to NBC and Peacock in 2026! In addition to becoming the exclusive home of Sunday Night Baseball, NBC Sports will broadcast MLB Sunday Leadoff, “Opening Day” and Labor Day primetime games, the first round of the MLB Draft, the entire Wild Card round of the postseason and much more.

Advertisement

2026 Fantasy Baseball Top 300 overall ranks

**Updated Sept. 21**

Sept. 21

Top 300

Team

Pos

Pos Rk

Sept. 14

1

Pete Crow-Armstrong

Cubs

OF

1

1

2

Yordan Alvarez

Astros

OF

2

2

3

Bobby Witt Jr.

Royals

SS

1

3

4

Ronald Acuna Jr.

Braves

OF

3

4

5

Junior Caminero

Rays

3B

1

6

6

Juan Soto

Mets

OF

4

8

7

Elly De La Cruz

Reds

SS

2

14

8

Pete Alonso

Orioles

1B

1

12

9

Fernando Tatis Jr.

Padres

2B

1

5

10

Kyle Schwarber

Phillies

1B

2

15

11

Logan Gilbert

Mariners

SP

1

66

12

Bryce Harper

Phillies

1B

3

17

13

James Wood

Nationals

OF

5

7

14

Jackson Chourio

Brewers

OF

6

13

15

Corbin Carroll

Diamondbacks

OF

7

25

16

Yoshinobu Yamamoto

Dodgers

SP

2

16

17

Matt Olson

Braves

1B

4

22

18

Tarik Skubal

Dodgers

SP

3

11

19

Jacob Misiorowski

Brewers

SP

4

10

20

Miguel Vargas

White Sox

3B

2

52

21

Mason Miller

Padres

RP

1

24

22

CJ Abrams

Nationals

SS

3

20

23

Michael Harris II

Braves

OF

8

27

24

Josh Hader

Astros

RP

2

28

25

Kyle Tucker

Dodgers

OF

9

21

26

Ketel Marte

Diamondbacks

2B

2

33

27

Oneil Cruz

Pirates

OF

10

31

28

Ben Rice

Yankees

C

1

32

29

Francisco Lindor

Mets

SS

4

37

30

Zack Wheeler

Phillies

SP

5

46

31

Cristopher Sanchez

Phillies

SP

6

19

32

Parker Messick

Guardians

SP

7

69

33

Jose Ramirez

Guardians

3B

3

54

34

Chris Sale

Braves

SP

8

29

35

Corey Seager

Rangers

SS

5

35

36

Mookie Betts

Dodgers

SS

6

44

37

Sal Stewart

Reds

2B

3

26

38

Cade Smith

Guardians

RP

3

47

39

Bryan Woo

Mariners

SP

9

75

40

Brice Turang

Brewers

2B

4

30

41

Jeremy Pena

Astros

SS

7

59

42

Gunnar Henderson

Orioles

SS

8

36

43

Jhoan Duran

Phillies

RP

4

45

44

Zach Neto

Angels

SS

9

39

45

Julio Rodriguez

Mariners

OF

11

18

46

Trea Turner

Phillies

SS

10

48

47

Riley Greene

Tigers

OF

12

53

48

Seiya Suzuki

Cubs

OF

13

51

49

Randy Arozarena

Mariners

OF

14

49

50

Jordan Walker

Cardinals

OF

15

42

51

Alec Burleson

Cardinals

1B

5

55

52

Cody Bellinger

Yankees

OF

16

50

53

David Bednar

Yankees

RP

5

63

54

Jackson Merrill

Padres

OF

17

41

55

Henry Bolte

Athletics

OF

18

86

56

Roman Anthony

Red Sox

OF

19

60

57

Manny Machado

Padres

3B

4

38

58

Louis Varland

Blue Jays

RP

6

64

59

Wyatt Langford

Rangers

OF

20

78

60

Jacob deGrom

Rangers

SP

10

56

61

Mike Trout

Angels

OF

21

61

62

Bo Bichette

Mets

SS

11

77

63

Kevin McGonigle

Tigers

SS

12

72

64

Drake Baldwin

Braves

C

2

74

65

Freddie Freeman

Dodgers

1B

6

76

66

Reid Detmers

Angels

SP

11

85

67

Raisel Iglesias

Braves

RP

7

87

68

Teoscar Hernandez

Dodgers

OF

22

67

69

Isaac Paredes

Astros

3B

5

108

70

Geraldo Perdomo

Diamondbacks

SS

13

98

71

Cam Schlittler

Yankees

SP

12

34

72

Yandy Diaz

Rays

1B

7

70

73

Luke Keaschall

Twins

2B

5

95

74

Brandon Nimmo

Rangers

OF

23

94

75

Shohei Ohtani

Dodgers

DH

1

NR

76

Taj Bradley

Twins

SP

13

216

77

Gabriel Moreno

Diamondbacks

C

3

138

78

Gerrit Cole

Yankees

SP

14

79

79

Bryan Reynolds

Pirates

OF

24

89

80

Daylen Lile

Nationals

OF

25

99

81

Wilyer Abreu

Red Sox

OF

26

96

82

Lawrence Butler

Athletics

OF

27

186

83

Mason Montgomery

Pirates

RP

8

109

84

Sonny Gray

Red Sox

SP

15

101

85

Hunter Goodman

Rockies

C

4

80

86

Kevin Gausman

Cubs

SP

16

203

87

Nolan McLean

Mets

SP

17

91

88

Cal Raleigh

Mariners

C

5

97

89

Otto Lopez

Marlins

SS

14

107

90

Carlos Rodon

Yankees

SP

18

136

91

Ivan Herrera

Cardinals

C

6

92

92

Andy Pages

Dodgers

OF

28

NR

93

Josh Naylor

Mariners

1B

8

84

94

Trevor Megill

Brewers

RP

9

81

95

Jose Altuve

Astros

2B

6

121

96

Shea Langeliers

Athletics

C

7

160

97

Bryan Baker

Rays

RP

10

113

98

Konnor Griffin

Pirates

SS

15

115

99

Logan Henderson

Brewers

SP

19

73

100

Brandon Lowe

Pirates

2B

7

162

101

Paul Skenes

Pirates

SP

20

106

102

Kenley Jansen

Tigers

RP

11

142

103

Munetaka Murakami

White Sox

3B

6

129

104

Jo Adell

Guardians

OF

29

123

105

Luis Garcia Jr.

Yankees

2B

8

118

106

Ranger Suarez

Red Sox

SP

21

120

107

Michael Busch

Cubs

1B

9

110

108

Max Muncy

Dodgers

3B

7

102

109

Kyle Stowers

Marlins

1B

10

112

110

William Contreras

Brewers

C

8

100

111

Tommy Edman

Dodgers

2B

9

82

112

Carson Benge

Mets

OF

30

126

113

Jacob Latz

Rangers

RP

12

116

114

Dominic Canzone

Mariners

OF

31

104

115

Coby Mayo

Orioles

3B

8

199

116

Austin Riley

Braves

3B

9

103

117

Max Fried

Yankees

SP

22

65

118

Christian Walker

Astros

1B

11

148

119

Jonathan Aranda

Rays

1B

12

135

120

Max Clark

Tigers

OF

32

124

121

Jake Bauers

Brewers

1B

13

114

122

Tyler Glasnow

Dodgers

SP

23

128

123

Luis Arraez

Phillies

2B

10

133

124

Chandler Simpson

Rays

OF

33

150

125

Alec Bohm

Phillies

3B

10

137

126

Nick Martinez

Rays

SP

24

177

127

Shane Baz

Orioles

SP

25

168

128

Trevor Story

Red Sox

SS

16

143

129

Nico Hoerner

Cubs

SS

17

111

130

Payton Tolle

Red Sox

SP

26

149

131

Freddy Peralta

Rays

SP

27

125

132

Gavin Williams

Guardians

SP

28

62

133

Ty France

Padres

1B

14

172

134

Jose Soriano

Blue Jays

SP

29

119

135

Kazuma Okamoto

Blue Jays

3B

11

139

136

Shota Imanaga

Cubs

SP

30

194

137

Jake McCarthy

Rockies

OF

34

146

138

Drew Rasmussen

Rays

SP

31

83

139

Bryson Stott

Phillies

2B

11

147

140

Dylan Crews

Nationals

OF

35

134

141

Sandy Alcantara

Marlins

SP

32

105

142

Josh Jung

Rangers

3B

12

192

143

Chase DeLauter

Guardians

OF

36

132

144

Cade Cavalli

Nationals

SP

33

161

145

Spencer Jones

Yankees

OF

37

151

146

Tyler Mahle

Braves

SP

34

190

147

George Springer

Blue Jays

OF

38

155

148

JJ Wetherholt

Cardinals

SS

18

NR

149

Vladimir Guerrero Jr.

Blue Jays

1B

15

58

150

Zack Gelof

Athletics

2B

12

198

151

Ozzie Albies

Braves

2B

13

156

152

Noah Cameron

Royals

SP

35

163

153

Kade Anderson

Mariners

SP

36

145

154

Emilio Pagan

Reds

RP

13

166

155

Steven Kwan

Guardians

OF

39

141

156

Zebby Matthews

Twins

SP

37

258

157

Daulton Varsho

Astros

OF

40

158

158

Ethan Pecko

Astros

SP

38

254

159

Brett Bateman

Blue Jays

OF

41

157

160

Aroldis Chapman

Red Sox

RP

14

57

161

Brandon Marsh

Phillies

OF

42

169

162

Caleb Durbin

Red Sox

3B

13

164

163

Michael Wacha

Royals

SP

39

170

164

Framber Valdez

Tigers

SP

40

122

165

Will Smith

Dodgers

C

9

175

166

Seranthony Dominguez

Mariners

RP

15

NR

167

Connor Prielipp

Twins

SP

41

NR

168

Nolan Arenado

Diamondbacks

3B

14

233

169

Michael King

Padres

SP

42

204

170

Jeff McNeil

Athletics

2B

14

243

171

Jac Caglianone

Royals

OF

43

188

172

Jackson Jobe

Tigers

SP

43

213

173

Vinnie Pasquantino

Royals

1B

16

130

174

Jazz Chisholm Jr.

Yankees

2B

15

NR

175

Jared Jones

Pirates

SP

44

200

176

Colson Montgomery

White Sox

SS

19

167

177

Sean Burke

White Sox

SP

45

275

178

Andre Pallante

Cardinals

SP

46

247

179

Clay Holmes

Cubs

SP

47

182

180

Christian Encarnacion-Strand

Orioles

3B

15

212

181

Garrett Mitchell

Brewers

OF

44

144

182

Jakob Marsee

Marlins

OF

45

220

183

Jarren Duran

Red Sox

OF

46

90

184

George Kirby

Mariners

SP

48

174

185

Joe Ryan

Twins

SP

49

179

186

Riley O’Brien

Cardinals

RP

16

193

187

Travis Bazzana

Guardians

2B

16

180

188

Ian Happ

Cubs

OF

47

178

189

Christian Yelich

Brewers

OF

48

127

190

Davis Martin

White Sox

SP

50

262

191

Grant Taylor

White Sox

RP

17

235

192

Dansby Swanson

Cubs

SS

20

NR

193

Blake Snell

Dodgers

SP

51

23

194

Angel Martinez

Guardians

2B

17

NR

195

Daniel Lynch IV

Royals

SP

52

NR

196

Lars Nootbaar

Diamondbacks

OF

49

205

197

Chase Meidroth

White Sox

SS

21

279

198

Cole Carrigg

Rockies

SS

22

176

199

Spencer Torkelson

Tigers

1B

17

267

200

Jonah Cox

Giants

2B

18

NR

201

Joey Cantillo

Guardians

SP

53

226

202

Heriberto Hernandez

Marlins

OF

50

208

203

Jonah Tong

Mets

SP

54

183

204

Cam Smith

Astros

OF

51

202

205

Ryan O’Hearn

Pirates

1B

18

217

206

Ezequiel Duran

Rangers

SS

23

197

207

TJ Rumfield

Rockies

1B

19

171

208

Robert Gasser

Brewers

SP

55

NR

209

A.J. Ewing

Mets

OF

52

173

210

Josh Bell

Twins

1B

20

214

211

Hunter Brown

Astros

SP

56

68

212

Josue De Paula

Dodgers

OF

53

165

213

Jake Burger

Rangers

1B

21

221

214

Hao-Yu Lee

Tigers

2B

19

260

215

Max Scherzer

Blue Jays

SP

57

291

216

Chris Bassitt

Orioles

SP

58

230

217

Walker Jenkins

Twins

OF

54

248

218

Aaron Nola

Phillies

SP

59

256

219

Willson Contreras

Red Sox

1B

22

88

220

Anthony Kay

White Sox

SP

60

NR

221

Sean Manaea

Mets

SP

61

272

222

Janson Junk

Marlins

SP

62

NR

223

Cristian Javier

Astros

SP

63

NR

224

Tanner Scott

Dodgers

RP

18

191

225

Kody Clemens

Twins

2B

20

210

226

Pedro Ramirez

Cubs

2B

21

292

227

Cooper Pratt

Brewers

SS

24

238

228

Christian Scott

Mets

SP

64

234

229

Carter Jensen

Royals

C

10

242

230

Matthew Boyd

Cubs

SP

65

215

231

Jesus Sanchez

Diamondbacks

OF

55

NR

232

Lazaro Montes

Mariners

OF

56

196

233

Adley Rutschman

Red Sox

C

11

218

234

Keider Montero

Tigers

SP

66

NR

235

JR Ritchie

Braves

SP

67

NR

236

Griffin Conine

Marlins

OF

57

239

237

Trevor Rogers

Orioles

SP

68

244

238

George Lombard Jr.

Yankees

SS

25

297

239

Xander Bogaerts

Padres

SS

26

159

240

Jung Hoo Lee

Giants

OF

58

225

241

JJ Bleday

Reds

OF

59

224

242

Walbert Urena

Angels

SP

69

282

243

Andrew Painter

Phillies

SP

70

232

244

Yainer Diaz

Astros

C

12

NR

245

Blade Tidwell

Giants

SP

71

NR

246

Zac Thornton

Mets

SP

72

NR

247

Eury Perez

Marlins

SP

73

131

248

Brayan Bello

Red Sox

SP

74

NR

249

Maikel Garcia

Royals

3B

16

246

250

Ben Joyce

Angels

RP

19

253

251

Drew Anderson

Tigers

SP

75

NR

252

Andrew Vaughn

Brewers

3B

17

294

253

Dustin May

Brewers

SP

76

187

254

Kodai Senga

Mets

RP

20

189

255

Grayson Rodriguez

Angels

SP

77

NR

256

Donovan Walton

Athletics

SS

27

NR

257

Spencer Miles

Blue Jays

RP

21

NR

258

Dustin Harris

Padres

OF

60

241

259

Rafael Flores Jr.

Pirates

C

13

NR

260

Matthew Liberatore

Cardinals

SP

78

NR

261

Nick Gonzales

Pirates

2B

22

265

262

Eugenio Suarez

Reds

3B

18

201

263

Javier Sanoja

Marlins

SS

28

285

264

Joey Ortiz

Brewers

SS

29

NR

265

Nathan Eovaldi

Rangers

SP

79

NR

266

Matt McLain

Reds

SS

30

287

267

Juan Morillo

Diamondbacks

RP

22

NR

268

Brooks Lee

Twins

SS

31

274

269

Mauricio Dubon

Braves

SS

32

NR

270

Tim Tawa

Diamondbacks

2B

23

281

271

Heliot Ramos

Yankees

OF

61

NR

272

Andres Gimenez

Blue Jays

SS

33

236

273

Tanner Bibee

Guardians

SP

80

152

274

Bryce Miller

Mariners

SP

81

NR

275

Cody Bradford

Rangers

SP

82

266

276

Hector Rodriguez

Reds

OF

62

207

277

Mickey Gasper

Red Sox

C

14

273

278

Will Warren

Yankees

SP

83

206

279

Leo Bernal

Cardinals

C

15

283

280

Calvin Faucher

Marlins

RP

23

NR

281

Wade Meckler

Angels

OF

63

271

282

Emmet Sheehan

Dodgers

SP

84

223

283

Grant Holmes

Braves

SP

85

NR

284

Quinn Mathews

Cardinals

SP

86

181

285

Pavin Smith

Diamondbacks

1B

23

NR

286

Xavier Edwards

Marlins

SS

34

153

287

Emmanuel Rodriguez

Twins

OF

64

296

288

Brandon Pfaadt

Diamondbacks

SP

87

NR

289

Connor Norby

Rockies

2B

24

NR

290

Colt Keith

Tigers

2B

25

237

291

Alejandro Kirk

Blue Jays

C

16

290

292

Nick Pivetta

Padres

SP

88

261

293

Salvador Perez

Royals

C

17

245

294

Nathan Church

Cardinals

OF

65

NR

295

Sam Antonacci

White Sox

2B

26

154

296

Chad Patrick

Brewers

RP

24

NR

297

Marcus Semien

Mets

2B

27

NR

298

Moises Ballesteros

Angels

C

18

NR

299

Michael Massey

Royals

2B

28

NR

300

Dean Kremer

Twins

SP

89

278

September 21 Notes

Falling off: Aaron Judge (ninth), Dylan Cease (40th), Alex Bregman (43rd), Andrés Muñoz (71st), Jesús Luzardo (93rd), Troy Melton (117th), Bryce Eldridge (140th) and 36 other players.

– It’s a fool’s errand, but here’s one last update for the final week of the season. I tried emphasizing two-start starters unless they’re particularly dangerous, but I also tried to take into account that some of the guys currently in line to start twice are going to end up being scratched or making only brief appearances next weekend.

Advertisement

– With no updates yet on Alex Bregman (face) and Andrés Muñoz (knee), I’ve dropped both from the rankings. Pedro Ramírez, who was set to fall off the list with Dansby Swanson back, reclaimed a spot in Bregman’s place. Seranthony Domínguez seems like the likeliest choice for saves in Seattle in Muñoz’s place, so he comes in at No. 166.

– Thank you so much to everyone who has followed along all season. Anyone interested in the full spreadsheet of where players have ranked start to finish, reach out to my gmail at matthewpouliot. I’ll be back in mid-October with the first (or second) go at a 2027 Top 300.

September 14 Notes

Falling off: Shohei Ohtani DH (eighth), Rafael Devers (41st), Jazz Chisholm Jr. (58th), Bryce Miller (177th), Gleyber Torres (183rd), Hayden Wesneski (206th), Royce Lewis (214th), Kyle Bradish (222nd), Michael McGreevy (243rd), Brandon Pfaadt (246th), Braxton Ashcraft (250th) and 21 other players

Advertisement

– I don’t have much of a notes section for you right now, since it’s after 3 am and I’d like to get some sleep. Still, the rankings are updated for the final 14 days of the season. A lot of the pitcher movement this week is elevating guys with three starts remaining and dropping those with only two. I also gave Rockies hitters a nice boost, as they play 10 of their remaining 13 games at home. Padres hitters also got a little lift from that, as they’ll be starting a four-game series in Coors Field on Monday.

September 7 Notes

Falling off: Kyle Harrison (101st), Shane McClanahan (125th), Luis Robert Jr. (163rd), Trent Graham (180th), Joe Musgrove (192nd), Byron Buxton (202nd), Cam Smith (219th), Brendan Donovan (227th), JJ Wetherholt (236th), Eric Lauer (243rd), Jesús Sánchez (247th), Xavier Edwards (254th), Sean Manaea (261st), Samuel Basallo (262nd), Nathan Eovaldi (265th), Connor Norby (268th), Chase Burns (273rd), Shohei Ohtani SP (280th), Tommy White (282nd), Daniel Palencia (285th), Colton Cowser (286th), Taylor Ward (289th), Ezequiel Tovar (290th), Alek Thomas (292nd), Willi Castro (294th), Elvis Alvarado (295th), Brandyn Garcia (299th)

– With three weeks to go, nearly every injured player is off the rankings at this point, with the exception of a few guys hopefully returning before the end of this week. Also, I’m paying a lot more attention to matchups, particularly this week’s. So, some starters with multiple starts this week who wouldn’t normally be in the top 300 make the cut. Also, Athletics hitters have moved up, since they’ll be at home for six games this week. Rockies hitters have dropped off as that team goes back on the road after a week of home games.

Advertisement

Rafael Devers gets an overdue late bump. There really was good reason for concern early on with his strikeout rate up and his bat speed down, but he bounced back nicely in both categories. Amazing is the consistency in his wOBAs since 2021: .373, .373, .359, .364, .365 and .365. His xwOBAs, on the other hand, still show a little decline: .391, .365, .380, .366, .367, .340. Still, it’s been a really impressive season, and getting to 100 runs scored (maybe) and 100 RBI (almost certainly) on the moribund Giants offense is one heck of an accomplishment.

– The Orioles getting swept by Red Sox over the weekend, dropping their postseason odds at Fangraphs to just three percent, would seem to greatly increase the chances that Kyle Bradish gets shut down with a week or two to go. He’s up to 152 innings in his first full year back from Tommy John, and he’s not exactly doing his best work at the moment.

Kyle Harrison might have lost his rotation spot with his performance Sunday against the Reds, though I thought about keeping him on the list anyway, since he could be well set up for wins in middle relief if moved to the pen. In the end, he didn’t quite make the cut. It will be really interesting to see how the Brewers play things the rest of the way. I imagine both Jacob Misiorowski and Logan Henderson will make a couple of shorter starts in an attempt to save bullets for October.

– It’ll be nice to see Corbin Burnes back on a major league mound Tuesday, but given that he threw just two innings in his lone rehab start after Tommy John, so I couldn’t see including him here just yet. San Diego’s Nick Pivetta, on the other hand, at least made it up to 4 1/3 innings in his last rehab start as he returns from an elbow injury. That gets him a spot on the bottom of the list, even if he’s a long shot to get a win Monday in his return.

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: Sports.yahoo.com