Home Home AI-Generated Election Posters Spark Controversy in Japan

AI-Generated Election Posters Spark Controversy in Japan

0
1

HYOGO –
Election posters featuring AI-generated faces that did not resemble the actual candidates have sparked controversy in Amagasaki, Hyogo Prefecture, after a former prefectural assembly member acknowledged that four candidates in a November 15th city council by-election had used artificial images rather than their own photographs, exposing gaps in Japan’s election laws and raising questions about the use of public funds.

The controversy emerged during a closely contested by-election in which 12 candidates competed for a single vacant seat on the Amagasaki City Council. Voters also went to the polls in a mayoral election on November 15th, which saw incumbent Mayor Kazumi Matsumoto win a second term, while Hiromi Ikeshita secured the council seat.

Of the 12 candidates in the council race, at least four displayed posters featuring images that appeared to have been created using generative artificial intelligence. Some depicted men with tattoos on their arms, while others showed attractive, distinguished-looking older men alongside simple campaign messages.

The posters attracted attention because the faces appeared more like digitally generated illustrations than conventional candidate photographs, prompting questions about whether the people depicted were actually standing for election.

One Amagasaki resident said the artificial appearance immediately discouraged closer examination of the candidates’ messages. “When I saw the posters, I thought they were obviously made with AI, so I didn’t really feel like looking at the details,” the resident said.

The Amagasaki City Election Administration Commission confirmed that at least four posters were suspected of using generative AI. In one particularly striking case, officials said the man depicted on the poster of candidate Hiroyoshi Hara was not Hara himself.

An election official who had previously met Hara said the person shown in the image looked completely different from the candidate.

Despite the discrepancy, election authorities said they had no legal grounds to order the posters removed.

Japan’s Public Offices Election Act has traditionally regulated election posters through requirements governing their dimensions, identification of responsible parties and other administrative details, but it has not required candidates to use photographs of themselves.

Following controversy during the July 2024 Tokyo gubernatorial election, when campaign poster boards were used to display sexually explicit images of women and other material unrelated to candidates, lawmakers revised the legislation to strengthen restrictions on inappropriate content.

The amended law requires candidates’ names to be clearly visible and prohibits material that damages another person’s reputation or violates public morals. However, it contains no provision requiring a candidate’s actual face to appear on an election poster.

An Amagasaki election official said the commission could not intervene simply because a photograph or image was misleading. “There is freedom of political activity and freedom of expression, so we cannot go so far as to say that a photograph is inappropriate and must be removed,” the official said.

Further investigation revealed that all four candidates whose posters had attracted attention shared a connection to former Hyogo prefectural assembly member Hikoharu Konishi, who has repeatedly entered mayoral and other local elections across Japan.

According to the city, Konishi or his secretary had submitted the candidacy registrations on behalf of the four individuals.

Election officials subsequently contacted Konishi to request that the candidates either visit city hall in person or provide copies of identification documents so their identities could be verified.

Konishi reportedly responded that he found the exchanges unpleasant. Because election rules do not generally require candidates to appear personally when registration documents are submitted through an authorized representative, officials had limited means of compelling them to cooperate.

The absence of the candidates themselves further fueled suspicions. Reporters searched Amagasaki for campaign vehicles and attempted to contact the individuals by telephone but were unable to locate them or obtain interviews.

Residents expressed concern that the posters undermined confidence in the electoral process. One said candidates should not engage in such unusual practices, while another questioned whether the individuals were seriously attempting to win office. “It makes me wonder how committed they really are. It’s difficult to sense any sincerity,” the resident said.

The controversy also raised questions about the financial arrangements surrounding election poster production.

Under Japan’s publicly funded election campaign system, eligible candidates can receive government assistance covering certain campaign expenses, including the production of posters.

For the Amagasaki by-election, public funding for poster production was available up to approximately 610,000 yen per candidate, depending on the applicable reimbursement conditions.

The system is designed to reduce the financial burden of standing for office and help ensure that candidates can compete without requiring substantial personal resources.

However, the emergence of four AI-generated posters in a relatively small election prompted speculation that some participants might be seeking to exploit the reimbursement system rather than seriously contest the seat.

A local election poster production company that has worked on more than 1,000 campaigns demonstrated how it incorporates AI into conventional image editing.

The company uses photographs of actual candidates and applies digital adjustments, including brightening skin tones, removing moles and eliminating reflections from eyeglasses.

An employee demonstrated how AI tools could remove the reflection of fluorescent lighting from a candidate’s glasses, explaining that such limited corrections were an appropriate use of the technology.

The company, Ono Planning Office, restricts AI use to image correction and similar adjustments and established its own guidelines on the technology in November.

Company representative Satsuki Ono emphasized the distinction between correcting a real photograph and generating an entirely different person’s face.

“AI can create a completely different face from the original material. That’s no longer a matter of simply correcting a photograph,” Ono said.

Ono also raised concerns about the potential profits available when inexpensive AI-generated images are used for posters that qualify for public reimbursement.

“If someone charges nearly 600,000 yen for posters, creates the images with AI for practically nothing and only pays for printing, there could be a substantial profit,” Ono said.

The presence of four apparently AI-generated campaigns among just 12 candidates made the situation particularly suspicious, Ono added.

Similar concerns circulated on social media, where users questioned whether obtaining publicly funded poster payments might have been one of the motivations for entering the election.

The investigation took a significant turn on November 14th, the final day of campaigning, when reporters located a campaign speech being delivered on behalf of Koichi Sato, one of the four candidates whose posters had attracted attention.

Sato was not present. Instead, Konishi was addressing voters on his behalf.

Referring directly to the controversy, Konishi acknowledged that residents had expressed distrust toward the posters displayed for candidates numbered nine through 12 on the election board.

“These are the posters everyone in Amagasaki has been talking about,” Konishi told the audience while promoting Sato, candidate number 12. He then asked whether people genuinely felt suspicious about the images.

After the speech, Konishi confirmed to Kansai Television that the images had been produced using AI.

Asked whether the person shown on Sato’s poster was actually Sato, Konishi replied, “This was made with AI.”

When asked whether the image was merely an illustration rather than a likeness of the candidate, he answered, “It’s an image.”

He also confirmed that the posters used by the other three candidates were similarly AI-generated representations rather than photographs of the individuals standing for election.

Questioned about allegations that the posters had been created to obtain publicly funded reimbursements, Konishi argued that production costs were matters to be settled between candidates and their contractors.

He said actual costs could exceed the reimbursement ceiling or be reduced through negotiations, suggesting that many candidates would probably seek the maximum permitted amount.

Konishi rejected suggestions that the campaigns had acted improperly.

“We have followed the Public Offices Election Act properly, and the election commission has checked everything and given its approval,” he said. “I don’t think people outside should be making a fuss about it.”

All four candidates who used the AI-generated posters were defeated in the November 15th election.

However, each received sufficient votes to qualify for the return of the 300,000 yen deposit required to stand in the municipal election, meaning they did not lose their registration deposits despite failing to secure a seat.

The outcome has intensified discussion about whether candidates can enter elections, claim publicly funded campaign expenses and potentially emerge financially better off even without winning.

Election consultant Takuma Ohamazaki expressed concern that the campaign financing arrangements could create opportunities for questionable practices.

“Normally, when someone runs for election, they incur expenses and finish with a financial loss,” Ohamazaki said. “In this case, I suspect there may have been people who actually ended up making money.”

There has been no confirmation that the four candidates or their associates improperly received public funds or profited from their campaigns, and the allegations remain suspicions rather than established wrongdoing.

Ohamazaki also warned that increasingly sophisticated AI technology could make future cases far more difficult to detect.

As generative AI improves, election posters may feature faces so realistic that voters and officials cannot easily determine whether they depict actual candidates.

“I think the cat-and-mouse game between technological advances and the provisions of the Public Offices Election Act will continue,” he said.

Legal experts similarly pointed out that Japan’s election legislation has historically been designed to regulate specific, identifiable practices, making it difficult to anticipate abuses arising from new technologies.

They noted that restrictions on political expression must also be carefully balanced against fundamental democratic freedoms, including the right to participate in elections and communicate political messages.

Further changes to the Public Offices Election Act are scheduled for March 2027, including a requirement to disclose when AI has been used in election-related materials.

However, the planned disclosure requirement has drawn criticism because it does not carry penalties for violations and does not necessarily require detailed explanations of which elements of an image have been generated or altered.

Experts questioned whether a simple declaration that AI was used would provide meaningful protection against misleading campaign imagery.

Without clearer definitions of prohibited conduct or enforceable penalties, they warned, candidates may continue exploiting gaps between rapidly developing technology and election regulations.

The Amagasaki controversy has highlighted a broader challenge facing Japan’s democratic system: while artificial intelligence is making campaign materials cheaper and easier to produce, existing safeguards may be insufficient to ensure voters can distinguish genuine candidates from digitally manufactured identities.

With AI-generated faces already appearing on official election boards and campaign expenses potentially covered by public money, the dispute is likely to add pressure for clearer rules governing the use of artificial intelligence in Japanese elections.

Source: KTV NEWS

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: newsonjapan.com