Home Health Anxious, jobless and broke: Can Britain help its doomed youth?

Anxious, jobless and broke: Can Britain help its doomed youth?

0
1
Advertisement
David Crowe

London: Governments often respond to media headlines about a crisis by releasing worthy reports that calm the debate with some reassuring facts.

In Britain, however, a new report suggests the crisis among young people is even greater than first thought.

The number of people in Britain aged 16 to 24 who are receiving incapacity benefits has more than doubled since 2012.Bloomberg

The UK is on track to have almost 1.3 million young people not in education, employment or training. Many of these NEETs, as they are known, are already on welfare benefits. More are set to join them. It is a crisis, undoubtedly, and it is getting worse.

The public has been told for months that Britain had about 1 million NEETs, and argument has raged about how to encourage more young people to get a job. The new report, presented to Prime Minister Andy Burnham by a trusted Labour ally, admits it could take more than a decade to fix the problem.

Advertisement

In grim detail, the report paints a picture of young people who are sidelined from the workforce and destined for poverty. It describes people leaving school and going onto benefits without the skills they need, or the incomes they would like, to make more of their lives.

The facts and forecasts, in short, are horrifying.

Since 2012, it says, the number of people aged from 16 to 24 who are receiving incapacity benefits has more than doubled to 250,000. The number receiving the main disability payments – the Disability Living Allowance or the Personal Independence Payment (PIP) – has doubled to over 400,000 over the same time.

The report’s author, Alan Milburn, says the extent of the problem is staggering.Getty Images

“That trend shows no sign of slowing down,” it says. A decade from now, 820,000 young people are expected to receive the PIP. That means one in every nine in this age group will be on this benefit. The number of young people claiming PIP is expected to quadruple from 2013 to 2037.

Advertisement

The report’s author, Alan Milburn, a cabinet minister under Labour prime minister Tony Blair, calls this trend staggering – the sort of word government reports usually avoid. He finds that conditions such as anxiety and depression, ADHD and autism are driving much of the growth among those aged from 16 to 24. Together, these conditions account for two out of every three new claims.

The cost is not measured in the welfare bill alone, of course. Some of the NEETs are not on welfare, but they are lost to the workforce. Milburn warns that Britain faces much broader costs from this loss.

“The problem is growing, not stabilising,” he says. Of the 1 million who are NEET today, 60 per cent have never had a job, and this ratio has risen over the past two decades. The review suggests that 16.3 per cent of young people could be NEET by 2031. That means 1.27 million people.

Without change, the country will carry an annual cost of £21.6 billion (about $42 billion) and rising. This includes the outlay on benefits, the impact on health costs and the foregone tax revenue from so many people being disengaged from work.

Advertisement

There are obvious parallels with the Australian debate over young people and disability care. Anyone tracking the cost of the National Disability Insurance Scheme should read the UK report.

Milburn sets out five broad proposals to curb the growth in NEET numbers.

First, a new benefits system for those under 25 to replace PIP and universal welfare in favour of a “youth allowance” with higher rates for those who live independently.

Second, a cut in the levy on employers – known as National Insurance – for the workers they hire aged from 21 to 24. This would start in retail and hospitality.

Third, a payment to employers who help fix the problem. Those who take on a young person who has been NEET for six months would receive £3,000. Another £2,000 would be added if the young person faced great barriers, such as a disability.

Advertisement

Fourth, more spending on training places for those aged over 18. As in Australian reports on the same theme, Milburn is strongly in favour of more apprenticeships.

Fifth, more obligations on schools to identify students at risk. This would include requirements to offer work experience and other support.

There are other ideas over more than 100,000 words – the report, unfortunately, is as long as an average novel – but the solutions are tentative. Burnham is backing Milburn, but he is a long way from putting concrete proposals to parliament. And he may not get the numbers to do anything ambitious. His predecessor, Keir Starmer, was rolled by Labour backbenchers when he tried to reform welfare last year.

There are also glaring gaps in this work. The incentives in the welfare system are fundamental to what happens, but there is very little discussion about how the payments for those who sit at home compare to the minimum wage for those who go to work. And there is nothing about those who cheat the system: the word “fraud” does not appear.

Advertisement
UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham delivers his leader’s speech at the Labour conference in Liverpool in September.Bloomberg

Another gap is in the age groups studied. Spending on health and disability benefits is growing fastest for the young, but it is rising sharply for all. Milburn says the overall bill for disability and incapacity benefits for working-age people has risen from £37.7 billion in the year to June 2019 to £55 billion in the year to June 2025.

That is a surge of 46 per cent over just six years after adjusting for inflation. The total bill will rise another 24 per cent over the next six years. It is forecast to hit £68 billion in 2031. But there is nothing in the report to address this broader problem because Milburn was limited to looking at the young.

Milburn rules out welfare cuts as the answer. He outlines changes that will cost more money in the near term in the hope of saving money a decade from now. There would be no savings until 2036 at the earliest. This is what Burnham wants: a message about investing in young people, not taking something away from them.

Advertisement

Bear in mind that the UK is already struggling to fund its current spending – or investment – on its people. The government deficit is forecast to be £133 billion this year, or 4.3 per cent of GDP. (In Australia it is expected to be 1.6 per cent of GDP.)

Millions of British workers will feel the weight of these trends. They will work and pay taxes to cover the cost of a growing cohort who choose to quit the workforce. It should be no surprise, over the years to come at the ballot box, if more of these workers decide the cost is simply too great.

Get a note directly from our foreign correspondents on what’s making headlines around the world. Sign up for our weekly What in the World newsletter.

David CroweDavid Crowe is Europe correspondent for The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age.Connect via X or email.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: www.smh.com.au