Home International Areas the Devils Have Seen Enough In to Start Making Changes

Areas the Devils Have Seen Enough In to Start Making Changes

0
1

The New Jersey Devils are 15-7-0 through 22 games. If you’re wondering what kind of pace that is, it’s a 57-win pace over the full 84-game season. That is pretty, pretty good. So on some level, it may feel awkward to point out or criticize areas that the team could be doing better in. But in the National Hockey League, the Devils know that they cannot just be good: they have to be ready for other teams to eventually adjust to them, or for their competition to eventually play more to their standards. In a recent post-game interview, Sheldon Keefe alluded to this kind of issue.

I don’t know: I don’t get too carried away with that. The record is news to me, like I don’t follow that. I know we’ve been through a stretch of 10 games, 19 days, I don’t even know what the record comes out as. And as you guys know, our starts have not been an issue when I’ve been here, you know, in my time here, we’ve been a really good team among the leads of the league this time of the year each year that I’ve been here. So that’s not new for us. What needs to be new is how we finish the year and how we go through the rest. There’s seventy-five percent of the season remaining, but I have tremendous level of optimism because of our group and how we’ve come together and how we find ways to win, and the depth of our team: that gives me great optimism and excitement to push ahead, and that’s all we’re going to do here is push ahead. We’re not going to be too excited about anything we’ve done to this point.

So, taking Sheldon’s lead here, I am going to try to dive into a few things that I think have had enough time to consider changes. To the Devils’ credit, they have actually gone ahead and tried to rectify one of the slight problems already.

Advertisement

Issue One: The Best Fit Bottom Six

Just a few games into this season, the Devils began to take teams by storm with the help of their superb fourth line of Amadeus Lombardi, Cody Glass, and Jesper Boqvist, who provided depth scoring and a true continuation of the offensive momentum built by the top six. However, once Connor Brown returned to the lineup, this group was split up. Meanwhile, the third line, led by Evan Rodrigues at center in each iteration until tonight, has almost always been underwater in expected stats. Only one combination, with Anthony Mantha and Stefan Noesen on the wings, had expected numbers similarly dominant to the other three lines at the time.

Now, there are a couple problems with that. Stefan Noesen, in the usual makeup of this roster, cannot stay in the NHL due to salary cap constraints. Anthony Mantha, meanwhile, is out at least a month due to a fracture in his throat. I think the Devils have been very deliberate about not getting too comfortable with any line or special teams usage that they think cannot be sustained due to potential future roster moves, so Noesen has remained the odd man out of the lineup despite not necessarily being the worst performer on the team on public models.

Per MoneyPuck, there are 12 line combinations that have been together for 20 or more minutes this season. They are ordered here by expected goals percentage. You will notice that Evan Rodrigues centers three of the five lines that are carrying under 50% of the expected goals in their shifts, while Cody Glass has been unable to center a line over 50% since the Boqvist-Lombardi union was split.

To be fair here: many of these lines have not played much together yet. For lines that have only played 20 or 30 minutes together, they are still one pretty good game away from being well over 50% in expected goals. But the two lines in the bottom half that have played over 60 minutes together were the lines that were broken up by necessity when Anthony Mantha got hurt. When he returns, I do not think the plan should be to reunite them. For the other lines that have still not gotten much time together, they largely deserve another chance or two to prove they can move in the right direction.

Advertisement

However, I do not think Evan Rodrigues should necessarily remain at center. Yesterday morning, on Twitter, I asked three questions prior to the morning skate. The first such question was about Amadeus Lombardi. Lombardi, who played center throughout his young career until this season, has learned to play wing while in the earliest days of his NHL career. But after 19 appearances in the NHL, I asked if it was time to see him down the middle.

I was then pleased to hear that the Devils happened to be thinking along the same lines. During morning skate, Amanda Stein tweeted out that Stefan Noesen appeared to be out of the lineup for the night, while Lombardi was taking the lead at center on the third line. Sheldon Keefe later mentioned that the third line needed help transporting the puck, and that Rodrigues would help out on some faceoffs and assist with the defensive responsibilities to ease Lombardi into the spot. To me, this makes a lot of sense. Rodrigues, over much of his career, has played at wing. He certainly slides over from time to time, and there are years that he plays more center than others, but the spread of the lines on MoneyPuck above make me think that he is struggling to create offense in the center role this season.

Per Natural Stat Trick, Rodrigues has the lowest goals for percentage of any Devils forward who has played each of the team’s 22 games at five-on-five at 50%. Among those players, he also has the lowest expected goals percentage at 48.10%. Among the three players with lower xGF% numbers, only Connor Brown (38.42% in 160:46) has played over 75 minutes at five-on-five. The model at HockeyStats by Patrick Bacon and JFresh agree: the fourth line has yet to replicate the viability of the Lombardi-Glass-Boqvist group, and the third line has yet to really get going with Rodrigues at center except for the few games he had Mantha and Noesen together.

We will see how well Amadeus Lombardi can spell the third line into something more productive, but I fear it may remain difficult while Mantha is out of the lineup. But if they can at least win their shifts more consistently, the Devils can get back into a more regular attack where they roll four lines without fear. Meanwhile, I am interested to see if Hameenaho can elevate the fourth line like he did in his first appearances against Washington.

Advertisement

Issue Two: The Best Fit Third Pairing

Johnny Kovacevic’s ankle injury has been devastating to what was a very good thing he had going on the third pairing with Declan Chisholm. With Chisholm’s comfort moving the puck and Kovacevic being a defensive brick wall, their synergistic abilities gave the Devils a third pairing that, per MoneyPuck, ranked fourth in expected goals percentage among all NHL pairings with 120 or more minutes together as of today.

When reducing the qualification point to 85 minutes played and looking at the current third pairing of Declan Chisholm and Brenden Dillon, things start looking much worse. Out of the 122 pairings in the NHL to have played 85 or more minutes, the Chisholm-Dillon pairing ranks 75th with a 47.9 xGF%. However, as far as public models go, there is some disagreement on how well this pairing has performed. On Natural Stat Trick, their number falls slightly to a 47.01 xGF%. But on Bacon and JFresh’s HockeyStats, the same pairing is assigned a 42.6 xGF%. CJ Turtoro’s Post Hockey comes out a bit between at a 45.5 xGF%.

Advertisement

Changes to this unit may be more difficult to come by. Anton Silaev, after one strong game, was sent to Utica. Vladislav Kolyachonok remains in the NHL as an extra, but it remains to be seen whether the Devils will scratch Dillon while Kovacevic is on injured reserve. I will have more to say about Dillon’s performance in the third section of this article, but I think there’s a bit of uneven treatment here. Statistically, the worst-performing defenseman on the roster right now is Dillon. He’s the only defenseman who has been on the ice for more goals against than goals by the Devils at five-on-five. His being on the ice tends to be a drag on expected numbers. In Silaev and Kolyachonok, there are two lefties who have shown promise through one appearance each that they might be able to provide steady enough presences to play NHL hockey for the Devils. If the club is willing to scratch, waive, or loan Noesen to the AHL to make room for forwards who haven’t exactly been as productive as him, I think Dillon can at least sit a couple games to see if Kolyachonok has the stuff to hack it at this level in this system.

The cover photo of this article fits an issue that many people have noticed with Dillon: despite being a physical defensive defenseman, he gets caught in positions where he is left unable to make a play far too often. When he was paired with Anton Silaev against Washington, Silaev had two forwards around a loose puck. Silaev took his man, Alex Tuch, out of the play. But Dillon was caught roving around too much, and Pierre-Luc Dubois was able to get to the loose puck first and beat Hellebuyck for a crucial goal. I do not doubt that Dillon can make explosive defensive plays here and there, but since his 1000th game he has never seemed as on in the defensive zone as he was beforehand.

With Kovacevic out and Casey still working towards a return, I don’t have an easy answer here. But I think we have seen enough of a sample of the Chisholm-Dillon pairing to guess that it is not going to get that much better than this.

Advertisement

Issue Three: Special Teams

Despite having a very talented roster, the Devils have had a bottom-10 special teams group in the league this season by results, but a top-10 group by expected results. On the power play, per Natural Stat Trick, their 6.97 goals per 60 minutes ranks 23rd in the league, while their 9.99 expected goals per 60 ranks 8th in the league. On the penalty kill, their 12.17 goals against per 60 minutes ranks 29th in the league, while their 7.2 expected goals against per 60 ranks 3rd in the league. Here, I give the qualifier of public models versus the data that teams are actually working with. When I watch the power play, it doesn’t look like a group that has forced a ton of unstoppable chances, while the penalty kill has tended to lapse and give up near-certain goals here and there.

The Power Play

While the Devils have done very well at creating a high volume of power play shot attempts, there is a player who has been a considerable outlier in on-ice offensive generation. Per Natural Stat Trick, 10 of the 11 players on the team who have played 25 or more minutes on the power play have an on-ice expected goals per 60 over 9.0, but the one who sits below that is Evan Rodrigues, who has played 35:54 on the power play while the team has produced 7.96 xGF/60 and scored just 6.69 goals per 60. The pattern for Rodrigues has been clear across five-on-five and the power play: offensive generation reduces while he is on the ice. He has scored a couple nice power play goals, but the team features other players who I think can shoot the puck. Lenni Hameenaho can shoot the puck: he had three power play goals in Utica prior to his call-up, and they often used him on the left wall for one-timers from the circle. And if they wanted Timo Meier to take more shots from the wall or bumper, Stefan Noesen has a strong history as a very productive netfront player on the power play. Hameenaho and Noesen have only appeared in a handful of games each, but neither have gotten an opportunity there. With Mantha out of the lineup, I think the Devils have enough of a sample to suggest that the power play generated better offense with Rodrigues on the bench, and they could probably start trying Hameenaho or Noesen at least on PP2 depending on who is in the lineup. That sample for Rodrigues goes well beyond this season, too. In each of his three years in Florida, the Panthers never scored even six goals per 60 minutes of Rodrigues’ power play ice time, despite him playing over 100 minutes in each of those seasons. By comparison, from 2022-23 in Carolina to 2024-25 in New Jersey, teams with Noesen on the ice on the power play scored 8.8, 9.36, and 11.19 goals per 60 minutes when he parked himself in front of the goalie.

Advertisement

To me, this goes to something Keefe and the Devils talk about often: getting traffic in front of the net. They do not set a ton of stationary screens, and flash screens can be a little hard to come by when two or three forwards on the power play are waiting for a low pass through traffic while the opposing PK is collapsed almost entirely in the low slot. By designating someone who is just going to park netfront in screen: whether it’s Brown, Meier, or Noesen (and Noesen has the best history here), the other four players on the ice can pass and rotate and shoot at a goalie who hopefully is not tracking their movement too well.

The other power play question is whether Luke Hughes or Dougie Hamilton should be the quarterback on the first unit. Statistically, the Devils generate better chances with Hamilton on the ice on the power play (11.46 xGF/60 for Hamilton to 9.72 for Luke). The actual goals scored early on this season have been as close to the same on a rate basis as you can get. I think there are two things they can do here. They can put Dougie on PP1 and probably create a few goals out of his point shot, and likely more goals than the current first unit has been scoring. Alternatively, it might be time for power play coach Ted Donato to suggest a little more creativity out of the players on the walls so that Luke Hughes is able to rotate down and attack the net.

Per Post Hockey, in the games that have been tracked Luke Hughes has remained at the point, quarterbacking the power play for 98% of his advantage ice time. Given how Post Hockey tracks power play roles, this means that he has not been able to rotate down and either make passes or take shots closer to the net too often.

Advertisement

But look at how Luke Hughes beat the Stars.

Look at how he beat the Rangers.

Look where he got to when he beat the Flyers.

Even his goal against the Knights was a one-timer from the top of the left circle. Luke has only scored twice this season when truly above the circles: his pullback wrister against the Blues, and his slap shot above the left circle against the Rangers. Luke is not a player who thrives off of sitting patiently at the point and waiting for a shot like Dougie Hamilton: he kills defenses when he’s able to get in motion. As long as the conception of the Devils’ power play does not take advantage of his skating ability, we are not going to get the most out of him there.

Advertisement

The Penalty Kill

While the power play is frustrating but useful here and there, the penalty kill is completely baffling. Even now, I still barely know what to make of their struggles. A great penalty kill allows six, seven, or maybe eight goals against per 60 minutes of kill time. The Devils only have two players: Dougie Hamilton (6.68 GA/60 in 35:55) and Jonas Siegenthaler (7.44 GA/60 in 40:19) who have gotten those kinds of results on the penalty kill. Their best performing forward still on the team is currently Nico Hischier, who has been on the ice for 11 goals against per 60 in 32:43. Mercer (9.95 GA/60 in 18:04) had been doing somewhat well with him prior to the Hellebuyck trade.

The PK curse is getting just about everyone else. Cody Glass, Connor Brown, and Brett Pesce have all been on the ice for porous defensive results at a rate of over 13 GA/60. Evan Rodrigues is at the worst among forwards at 14.9/60. Luke Hughes and Brenden Dillon are the worst among defensemen at 18.89/60 and 19.22/60, respectively. But again, the baffling thing is that nobody is even close on an expected level to that.

Some things remain true when looking at expected numbers: Siegenthaler (5.28 xGA/60), Hamilton (6.58 xGA/60), and Hischier (6.81 xGA/60) are still above the rest. Brenden Dillon (9.45 xGA/60) is still faring considerably worse. But everyone else who has been in the cursed group has had an xGA/60 between 7.24 (Rodrigues) and 8.33 (Brown). On some level, I feel like there is something that the public models are not picking up here, though. Is everyone being careful about keeping their sticks in the right passing lanes? Should a defenseman be picking up players by the net a little earlier? Should a high forward be giving chase to a puck carrier a little quicker? Or is it something even more elusive, like players not changing off quick enough and making tired mistakes later in the kill? This article is already long enough, so that will have to wait for its own post, but the message is clear: the penalty kill is not working.

Advertisement

Brad Shaw was hired to replace Ryan McGill, who for all intents and purposes ran very effective penalty kills under Lindy Ruff and Sheldon Keefe. I said McGill could be missed when the Devils decided not to renew his contract. At the time, I noted that in each of his three years with the club, the Devils’ PK operated in the top 10 of the league on a rate basis, though the expected numbers took a dip in his final year with the club. Now, the expected numbers are great, but through 104 games, the Devils have killed only 76.8% of opponent power play opportunities under Brad Shaw. Currently, they’re killing only two out of every three penalty kills.

Brad Shaw has a long history as a highly respected defensive coach, and I thought he did a great job with Tortorella in Philadelphia prior to his hire by Keefe. But I don’t know how long a team can operate with a penalty kill that is only succeeding 66.7% of the time. I say that with this qualifier: I don’t even believe, truly, that he should be fired, and I’m not entirely sure if I will feel that way 20 games down the line if the team continues to win despite a poorly performing penalty kill. The five-on-five defense is solid, and the team is winning. Does the team try to get another voice in on the penalty kill? Does Keefe run it himself for a stretch? Is anyone in the organization like Andy Greene or Martin Brodeur seeing something from above that they can put their two cents in about?

What they can do right now is see if shifting personnel here and there makes a difference. Statistically, their best hope of killing a penalty is to have Siegenthaler, Hamilton, Hischier, and Glass on the ice. Do they maybe try getting Bratt out there more? Boqvist? Jack? All three have killed penalties with success in recent years, albeit not in top usage. If Stefan Noesen came back into the lineup, would they try him there, considering he has been on the ice for a total of zero goals against in over 40 penalty killing minutes (mostly 2024-25) since coming back to New Jersey? On back end, Brenden Dillon seems to be a drag in both expected and actual goals against. Can they trust Declan Chisholm, who has only totaled a bit over 38 career penalty killing minutes with three goals against in his career? Would they play Kolyachonok there if he came in for Dillon?

Like with the third pairing, the answers are not going to be easy in the absence of Kovacevic. But I think they are at the point where they need to try something new.

Advertisement

Your Thoughts

What do you think about these issues? What do you think of Keefe trying Lombardi down the middle tonight? Do you think the power play is heading in the right direction? Do you think anyone will get in on the third pairing before Kovacevic returns? Leave your thoughts in the comments below, and thanks for reading.

Credit to MoneyPuck, Natural Stat Trick, HockeyStats, and Post Hockey for their respective expected goals numbers, and to Natural Stat Trick for their goal rate stats.

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: Sports.yahoo.com