Opinion
If you walk down Melbourne’s Bourke Street mall or Sydney’s George Street, you’ll see a bit of Australian retail history.
In Bourke Street above the DJs sign you can see the words Buckley & Nunn, a retail giant put out of business in the 1980s, engraved into the beautiful old facade. It’s similar if you’re in Sydney where stands a striking Gowings sign.
The signage of both Buckley & Nunn and Gowings is a reminder that change is a constant.
What is also a constant is that in so many cases, both here and overseas, poor management often leads to the death of a business.
And we have concrete evidence that Australian business management is also a major factor in the country’s poor productivity performance.
The Productivity Commission’s recent report on business performance and ways to improve it attracted most attention for its findings about the amount of red tape faced by local firms.
But its insights into the quality of Australian business management should be compulsory reading.
It found that if local business managers lifted their performance to that displayed by their American counterparts, Australian productivity would rise by 9.8 per cent. That’s 10 times faster than it managed to grow over the past decade.
The Productivity Commission’s report found Australian managers were sandwiched between Italians and Mexicans in terms of the improvement that could be made if they lifted their games. Nations including France, Britain, Sweden, Japan, Germany and Poland were all ranked ahead of Australia.
The commission came up with a few reasons for Australia’s poor performance. One is this nation’s large number of very small businesses (four employees or less) where there’s little attention given over to strategic thinking or long-term decision-making.
Another reason cited by the commission is that Australian businesses are good at identifying opportunities but poor at implementing change.
Given the world is going through the start of an AI revolution that proponents argue will change almost everything, the inability of managers to implement change is a considerable worry.
According to the commission, management in this country is already behind the AI curve. It found Australian firms have lower rates of AI use than many overseas counterparts. Almost 80 per cent of American businesses, for instance, have already adopted at least one AI technology. In Australia, less than 60 per cent have.
It’s not just the Productivity Commission that’s found local businesses are technological laggards. The Melbourne Business School this month released research showing Australians had among the lowest levels of AI training in the developed world with less than a quarter reporting they had undertaken AI-related training or education. That’s a business management failure.
CPA Australia, which recently surveyed businesses here and across Hong Kong, Malaysia, mainland China and Singapore, found local firms had “the lowest level of broad AI integration”.
Businesses that reported higher levels of AI usage reported higher profits than those afraid to take the technological leap.
Again, that’s a management failure.
The stakes are incredibly high. If Australian businesses are being managed by poor performers who don’t understand or fail to embrace change, the cost will be borne by the nation’s workforce.
As the commission notes, good managers are vitally important.
“Better management practices are associated with better business outcomes. Firms with stronger management practices tend to be more productive, profitable, innovative and likely to survive,” the commission said.
“Better management can also help firms identify, adopt and make effective use of new technologies.”
Corporate history is resplendent with examples of poor management. From Blockbuster video (which decided against investing in Netflix) to HIH Insurance (Australia’s worst corporate collapse), bad decision-making is part and parcel of business.
The poor performance of Australian management, and its impact on the nation’s productivity level, is nothing new.
Back in 2012, then senior Treasury economist David Gruen (with fellow economist Ben Dolman), produced research which showed that Australian management levels were well below those of their American counterparts.
Reflecting on the slowdown in Australian productivity since the start of the 20th century, the two authors suggested that improving the management performance among Australian manufacturing businesses would lift productivity by about 8 per cent. That’s not far off what the Productivity Commission found with its research, more than a decade later.
When the report was released, there was hand-wringing from the Australian business press. You couldn’t blame Australian management for holding back the nation’s productivity performance. It had to be something outside the control of local managers.
However, as the commission noted, “responsibility for improving management capability mainly falls on business”.
This goes to a point recently made by the Reserve Bank’s deputy governor, Andrew Hauser (who happens to be an Englishman).
Quizzed on Australia’s poor productivity performance, he noted that in this country at least, the answer always seemed to be “the government”.
“This is something of an Australian thing: ‘this is a problem, government must solve it’, or ‘government is the problem’,” he said.
Hauser pointed out that apart from the US, productivity had been pretty poor around the world for years.
As he said, “red tape is not a feature of every country facing low productivity”. But low investment is. Australian businesses, along with their counterparts in most other nations, have not invested enough in technology.
Again, a management decision.
If you believe the hype, the world stands on a technological transformation that could dwarf the industrial revolution or the advent of railways or the establishment of the World Wide Web.
The question is whether the managers of Australian businesses are up to the task of using AI to make their businesses more efficient, more profitable, more productive.
Or will they go the way of Buckley & Nunn or Gowings – as historical curios?
Shane Wright is a senior economics correspondent.
The Opinion newsletter is a weekly wrap of views that will challenge, champion and inform your own. Sign up here.
From our partners
Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: www.smh.com.au




