‘Bigger than Hansie Cronje’s match-fixing’: Geoffrey Boycott weighs in on Australia’s Sandpapergate controversy originally appeared on Cricket News. Add Cricket News as a Preferred Source by clicking here.
KEY TAKEAWAYS:
-
Geoffrey Boycott has called the Australian sandpaper scandal bigger than former South Africa captain Hansie Cronje’s match-fixing.
-
His case rests on how many people were involved rather than on the offence itself.
-
Cronje was banned for life, while Cape Town’s three players served nine to twelve months.
Advertisement
Geoffrey Boycott calls Sandpapergate bigger than anything he has seen in cricket
As new revelations on the Sandpapergate continue to flare up each day, Cricket Australia and bowlers Pat Cummins, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Starc continue to get under the fire. Amid this, former English great Geoffrey Boycott has placed the scandal above the Hansie Cronje affair.
The former opener made the argument in his column for the Telegraph, and he based it on how many people were involved rather than on what they did.
“The sandpaper scandal is even bigger than Hansie Cronje’s match-fixing, which ripped apart South Africa cricket more than 25 years ago. This is bigger than anything I have read or seen in cricket: a whole team cheating,” Boycott wrote.
Advertisement
He drew the line between the two cases through the number of people who knew. “Cronje’s crimes mainly involved him recruiting a couple of junior players, Herschelle Gibbs and Henry Williams, into his scheme. The rest of the squad and coaches had no idea,” he added.
Boycott then turned to what Cameron Bancroft set out this week, and to the eight years in which three men carried the punishment alone.
“But sandpaper involved the whole Australian team. The squad and coaches were all up to their necks in it, plotting and planning to cheat en masse, and the cover-up let three players take the blame. It is mind-blowing and unbelievable how they all went along with it. That is how huge it is,” he said.
MORE: Sandpapergate peace deal: AUS players’ union chief urges shared responsibility among 2018 batch
Advertisement
How the Hansie Cronje scandal compares with Australia’s sandpaper cover-up
Boycott’s description of the Cronje case is broadly accurate. The South African captain denied the allegations for four days in April 2000 before admitting he had taken money from a London bookmaker, and he was sacked that same week.
The King Commission later heard what he had offered his teammates. Cronje put 15,000 dollars in front of Herschelle Gibbs to score fewer than 20 in the fifth ODI at Nagpur, and the same sum in front of Henry Williams to concede more than 50 in that match.

Neither man went through with it. Gibbs made 74 off 53 balls, and Williams hurt his shoulder before he could finish his second over.
Advertisement
The sanctions reflected how the game viewed the offence. Cronje was banned for life in October 2000, while Gibbs and Williams were suspended for six months each.
Cape Town produced nothing on that scale. Steve Smith and David Warner served twelve months, Cameron Bancroft nine, and no coach was punished at all, with Darren Lehmann cleared by Cricket Australia’s investigation before resigning days later.
More: ‘A great leader’: Hazlewood threatens Test exit if CA sacks Cummins over Sandpapergate
Why Geoffrey Boycott is right about the scale but not about the crime
On the arithmetic, Boycott has a case. Cronje worked alone with two recruits, and nobody has ever suggested the South African coaching staff knew a thing about it.
Advertisement
What Bancroft has described in Cape Town is a different shape of problem. The plan was discussed in the dressing room, feedback on the altered ball came back from the bowlers, and two coaches were present when it was talked through.
Where the comparison strains is in treating the two as the same offence at different volumes. They are not the same offence.
Cronje sold the result of a cricket match to a betting syndicate, which attacks whether the contest was real at all. That is why he never played again, while Smith and Warner were back inside a year. Ball-tampering is cheating inside a game both teams are still trying to win.
Boycott’s strongest point is the one he makes last. Three men absorbed eight years of punishment for a decision that, on Bancroft’s account, far more people took, and that is the charge Cricket Australia has still not answered.
Advertisement
For all the latest cricket news, opinion, and commentary, and to share your voice, head to our Facebook, Instagram, and X (Twitter) pages.
Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: Sports.yahoo.com









