Good afternoon, Pittsburgh Steelers and NFL Draft fanatics. Before the squad heads across the state to take on the Philadelphia Eagles and try to end an astounding 61-year drought in that city, it’s time for the monthly mailbag! Today, we’ll talk through a plethora of questions surrounding this perplexing offense, how they could reshape their receiver room through the NFL Draft and, of course, quarterback discourse. As always, I sincerely appreciate all of the thoughtful questions you provided across various platforms.
Without further ado, here we go.
Advertisement
Q: Should we expect the Steelers’ offensive line to decline without Mason McCormick? Could Gennings Dunker be a solution to that problem?
The most disappointing part of Sunday night’s blowout loss to the Cincinnati Bengals wasn’t the result itself, but losing one of their top ascending young players for the foreseeable future. Thankfully, the injury wasn’t as bad as it initially looked, with McCormick having a chance to potentially return in the playoffs. In the meantime, Pittsburgh will miss him most in the run game, where his chemistry with Troy Fautanu noticeably improved on the left side this season, allowing them to generate consistent displacement. Throw in Zach Frazier, and that trio is a big reason the Steelers‘ run game currently ranks first in EPA/play and sixth in success rate.
As for his replacement, Spencer Anderson will get the first crack at it because he’s a known commodity with more experience at the position. Mike McCarthy can do some cool stuff with him in space, which gets highlighted quite a bit when he’s deployed as a sixth offensive lineman, but he, like Brock Hoffman, comes with natural limitations in pass protection. Interior pressure is a pocket passer’s worst nightmare, and this offense is already struggling to throw the football downfield as is. Gennings Dunker was essentially a career right tackle in college, played primarily right guard in the preseason and is coming off a significant injury. Ultimately, they may be forced to turn to him, but expectations should be tempered.
Q: Can Pittsburgh get out of the DK Metcalf and Michael Pittman Jr. contracts after this season?
Advertisement
A: Technically, yes, but it’s most likely going to be an either/or type of situation. DK Metcalf’s contract is a candidate for one of the worst in the NFL. Since they restructured his deal over the summer, the only realistic out would be to designate him as a post-June 1 cut, which would help soften the blow in 2027 but leave additional damage down the road. Pittman, who may not return in time from injury to make a positive enough impression with the club, seems to be the more likely odd man out. The Steelers would accrue a little over a $15M cap hit, with just under $11M in cap savings, per OTC.
Q: Should Omar Khan be on the hot seat just a little if this trajectory continues?
A: Even as someone who is lower on Omar Khan than the general consensus, a hot-seat conversation seems a bit premature. General managers typically get more leeway in this business, largely because they work more directly with ownership, and no organization values stability (sometimes to a fault) more than the Steelers. It feels like the fan base credits Andy Weidl with their recent success on draft weekend, but that feels unfair to completely strip one person’s contributions from their collaboration. He inherited a 9-7-1 roster, and they’ve remained competitive in that range every year since, which we know is good enough for Art Rooney II. Zero postseason wins with the core of prime T.J. Watt, Cam Heyward and Minkah Fitzpatrick is a tough look, and they weren’t able to flip any of those guys into assets for the future, either.
We’ve seen GMs like Howie Roseman get off to cold starts and eventually build championship contenders. We’ve seen other examples, like Brandon Beane, where they help accelerate rebuilds but cool off over time. Khan, like the Steelers, just seems to be stuck in the middle. The biggest area of improvement is rather obvious: he’s handed out some brutal contracts (see above) to older players, and the post-Chase Claypool trades haven’t been great, either. The public perception of everyone associated with this organization will improve once they have a long-term quarterback solution. Mike McCarthy was hired in part because he’s someone they believe can help solve that problem. So we’ll see. Ask me again in a year or two.
Advertisement
Q: The Steelers’ passing game is gross to watch. Who is most to blame? And why do you think Aaron Rodgers refuses to throw over the middle?
A: It’s a combination of things, really. Having a No. 1 receiver who can’t beat press-man coverage, combined with a declining 42-year-old quarterback on his farewell tour, can make things difficult. It’s also worth noting that McCarthy isn’t doing enough schematically right now to spring guys open and hasn’t figured out how to get the most out of players like Germie Bernard, either. Rodgers has never been a high-volume attacker in that area of the field, but he was at least giving it a whirl in spurts over the first month of the season. That has pretty much been eliminated entirely since then. Whether it’s the accumulation of hits or a fear of throwing interceptions, it’s not just limiting the passing game; it’s bleeding into their rushing attack as well.
Q: In a world where there isn’t a quarterback worth taking in the first round, who are some wide receiver prospects that make sense?
A: LSU’s Jackson Harris is a personal favorite of mine so far this season and someone who should continue to rise up the consensus boards as more people get eyes on his tape. He’s a smooth mover who checks a lot of boxes: size, the potential to run a robust route tree, the capacity to play above the rim and a proven ability to create explosives in different ways. Indiana’s Nick Marsh is another guy who has taken a leap this season in a new offense and would have better statistical production if he had better quarterback play. He might have the highest ceiling among the playmakers expected to go inside the top 50, but he does all of the little things well. His attention to detail as a route runner, tenacity as a blocker and alignment versatility will make him a hot commodity for a myriad of teams come April.
Advertisement
Q: How do you think the Steelers’ QB room will play out next season? Should we put any stock into Chris Collinsworth’s comments on Sunday Night Football?
A: It’s hard to predict right now, mainly because, with all of the changes to the college football landscape, it’s more difficult than ever to predict which quarterbacks will declare for the NFL Draft. Common sense would tell you that they need to take another big swing at the position this offseason. Assuming they’ll be picking in the early 20s again, they should have options. Running it back with the current trio would be an extremely unusual approach, especially considering this is a franchise that’s never been content with knowingly taking a step back to kickstart a rebuild.
Drew Allar is pretty much guaranteed to be in the fold, and if the Steelers aren’t starting a rookie in Week 1 next year, he should be the guy getting the first crack at things. The potential curveball would be them signing someone in free agency, although that pool is mostly filled with aging players they should avoid. Drew Lock is going to be a name to watch the rest of the way, considering how well he’s played with Seattle. Like we saw last cycle with Malik Willis, it doesn’t take an incredible sample size to get paid on the open market with how desperate teams are.
Q: Do you think LaNorris Sellers would be a fit for McCarthy’s style of offense?
Advertisement
A: He’s without a doubt going to be one of the most polarizing prospects in this entire class, but Sellers is an absolute tank, flush with the tools McCarthy covets: size, arm talent and athleticism. The South Carolina product got off to a concerningly slow start to his 2026 campaign but has since turned it on by playing with more confidence, which led to a signature five-touchdown performance in a win against arguably the best defense in the country in Oklahoma. Sellers has never been blessed with a healthy ecosystem around him, which has stunted his development and, in turn, made him a difficult prospect to evaluate. But if he continues to play well down the stretch, it’s safe to assume the Steelers will be doing their homework on him for sure.
Q: Growing up a Steelers fan, which season was your favorite?
A: The 2005 Super Bowl team will always hold a special place in my heart for a couple of reasons. When they drafted Ben Roethlisberger the year prior and immediately ripped off 15 straight wins, it felt like they were the team of destiny, until they were derailed in very painful fashion by the Patriots in the AFC Championship Game. The following season wasn’t as smooth early on, but that team peaked at the right time with a winning formula. Luckily, my father took me to those first two playoff games, which is something I’ll remember forever.
I still recall being taken aback by how the radio hosts and Colts fans at the tailgates alike weren’t even giving Pittsburgh a chance to advance. The Jerome Bettis fumble remains one of the most shocking plays to this day, but it literally felt like everything was happening in slow motion as that sequence unfolded. Fortunately, they survived, even if that contest shouldn’t have been that close to begin with. But that’s another rant for another day. They routed Denver the following weekend, and I think I was nervous for two weeks straight leading up to the final game. Ike Taylor was my favorite player growing up, so seeing him get a game-clinching interception was pure football nirvana. It’s nostalgic, but the redemption element holds weight, too.
Advertisement
Related Headlines
Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: Sports.yahoo.com










