Getting out of credit card debt can save you thousands of dollars, but choosing the wrong debt relief program could leave you paying more than you expected. Two common approaches, debt settlement and debt management, promise to help borrowers escape balances that only ever seem to go up.
Debt settlement seeks to negotiate a reduction in the amount you owe. Debt management plans, or DMPs, generally require you to repay your entire principal balance but can substantially reduce interest charges and fees.
For consumers struggling with unsecured debt, such as credit card balances and personal loans, a settlement might eliminate thousands of dollars in principal. When you feel your debt has grown larger than you can possibly pay off, that reduction may be worth the service fees, taxes and collection costs that come with it.
Ultimately, your choice depends on your income, outstanding balances, interest rates and ability to make monthly payments.
Advertisement
The costs of debt settlement vs. debt management
Understanding the total cost of each approach is essential before committing to a program.
Debt settlement
Debt settlement companies, such as National Debt Relief, negotiate with creditors to accept less than the full amount owed, usually through a lump-sum payment or an agreed series of payments. In exchange, the creditor agrees to forgive the remaining eligible balance.
For-profit settlement companies generally direct you to make one monthly deposit into a dedicated savings account in your name. This account is what eventually pays for your settlements and program fees. The monthly deposit amount is designed to fit your budget. The accumulated funds eventually become the money used to negotiate settlements.
Advertisement
The strategy relies partly on creditors becoming willing to accept less than the full balance rather than risk recovering nothing. However, creditors are not required to negotiate or accept a settlement.
For example, suppose a borrower owes $20,000 in credit card debt and a creditor agrees to accept $10,000 as payment in full. The borrower eliminates $10,000 in principal, representing a 50% reduction before accounting for fees, taxes and other costs.
According to a study conducted by the consulting firm EY for the Association for Consumer Debt Relief, the average debt balance before settlement was $21,320 and the average settlement amount was $10,680, which is approximately half off of the debt owed. In all, the average net savings of using a debt settlement company was $6,370 or 30% of the debt balance.
Average financial outcomes per client, Settled Accounts only
Advertisement
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Enrolled Debt | $19,080 |
| Debt balance immediately before Settlement | $21,320 |
| Settlement Amount | $10,680 |
| Debt Reduction | $10,640 |
| Debt Reduction as a share of debt balance immediately before Settlement | 50% |
| Fees | $4,270 |
| Fees as a share of Enrolled Debt | 22% |
| Debt Reduction per $1 of Fees | $2.50 |
| Net Savings | $6,370 |
| Net Savings as a share of debt balance immediately before Settlement | 30% |
| % of clients with at least one Settled Account who realize Net Savings | 98% |
Debt management
Debt management plans take a different approach. Rather than negotiating principal forgiveness, nonprofit credit counseling agencies work with participating creditors to reduce interest rates and establish affordable repayment schedules. These arrangements can lower annual percentage rates, or APRs, sometimes to single digits. However, the actual concessions depend on the creditor, the account and the counseling agency’s agreements.
Borrowers typically make one monthly payment to the counseling agency, which distributes the money to participating creditors. Most plans aim to repay enrolled debts within three to five years. Creditors may also waive certain fees or stop charging new late fees while the borrower complies with the agreement. The reduced interest charges allow more of each payment to go toward principal.
Imagine you have $20,000 in credit card debt carrying a 24% APR. Assuming a fixed interest rate, no additional purchases and monthly payments sufficient to eliminate the balance in 60 months, you would pay approximately $575 monthly and about $14,500 in interest.
Advertisement
If a debt management plan reduces the APR to 8%, the monthly payment would fall to approximately $406. Total interest would decline to roughly $4,300 over the same period. That represents approximately $10,200 in interest savings before program fees. Unlike debt settlement, the borrower would repay the entire original principal balance.
Nonprofit status does not guarantee low fees or high-quality service. State laws and accreditation requirements may impose additional standards, but consumers should still request a written fee schedule before enrolling.
What to know before you decide
Another cost of debt settlement can appear after a creditor forgives part of the balance. Under federal tax law, canceled debt generally counts as taxable income unless an exception or exclusion applies. According to the IRS, qualifying creditors generally must issue Form 1099-C when they cancel $600 or more in debt. However, the $600 threshold is a reporting requirement, not the minimum amount of canceled debt that can be taxable.
Advertisement
Take, for example, a borrower who settles a $20,000 credit card balance for $10,000. If the remaining $10,000 qualifies as taxable cancellation-of-debt income, the borrower must include that amount when calculating federal income taxes. Assuming the entire amount is taxed at a 22% marginal federal income tax rate, the additional tax would be $2,200. Combined with the hypothetical $5,000 settlement company fee, the borrower’s original $10,000 reduction would produce only $2,800 in net savings.
That calculation excludes potential state income taxes, additional account charges and interest accumulated before settlement. However, not every borrower owes taxes on forgiven debt. IRS Publication 4681 explains that canceled debt may be excluded from taxable income when the borrower is insolvent immediately before the cancellation or when the debt is discharged in a qualifying bankruptcy proceeding.
For borrowers with substantial financial hardship, these exceptions can change the economics of settlement. If you are in these circumstances, it is well worth the money to hire a tax professional who can determine whether the exclusions apply.
While debt management plans require borrowers to repay 100% of their principal balance to avoid cancellation-of-debt taxes, debt settlement offers substantial out-of-pocket savings by significantly slashing the actual principal owed. Even when accounting for potential tax considerations or interim account fees during the accumulation phase, resolving obligations for a fraction of their face value typically delivers a lower total cash outlay than committing to repay every dollar of principal through a management plan.
Advertisement
The primary financial advantage of debt settlement lies in its aggressive approach to balance reduction. Although outcomes vary depending on specific creditor terms, the discounts negotiated on participating accounts have the power to reduce the overall capital required to resolve your liabilities.
It will be helpful to run a side-by-side comparison of the two approaches to see in your case where the bottom-line advantage lies. Calculating those net numbers will bring clarity, and show you how to maximize your savings and accelerate your path to financial freedom.
Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: nypost.com









