Home International Here’s what fakes about the Putin-Xi-Trump summit you were fed by Western...

Here’s what fakes about the Putin-Xi-Trump summit you were fed by Western propagandists

0
3

Fabricated summit images spread fast because they fit pre-existing biases, and too many analysts preferred narrative over protocol and facts

By Igor Denisov, Senior Research Fellow, MGIMO University, Institute for International Studies

Some professional clowns, posing as experts on diplomacy, are sharing AI-generated fake images of the Shenzhen summit to illustrate Xi Jinping’s supposed protocol snubbing of Vladimir Putin.

Here’s one of them: Putin sulking at a separate table as Xi and Trump chat away merrily during the APEC summit banquet.

And here’s a real screenshot from Chinese TV.

It clearly shows there was only one main table. All the heads of delegations were seated there, including the representative of Taiwan – not to mention the leader of Russia.

Some – like the former US ambassador to Russia and current Russophobe think-tanker extraordinaire Michael McFaul – had the decency to delete their posts after seeing their embarrassing mistake. Others remained steadfast: so what if it’s fake, it still reflects how we feel about the situation.

You’d have to be a fool to think the Chinese handled protocol in a non-Chinese way and seated one of their main partners at a separate table. Moreover, since Xi Jinping attended the banquet together with his wife, Peng Liyuan, Putin’s seat to her left was also one of the most honored.

This seating arrangement corresponds to the traditional protocol under which that place is given to the second most senior guest. So Putin’s placement does not indicate any lowering of his protocol status. Especially since, in another setting (the so-called APEC family photo), Putin was given a more honorable place than Trump.

Another, and even more obvious, fake is a video of Xi demonstratively refusing to shake Putin’s hand. This one accumulated some 3.6 million views and was shared over Facebook, Threads, and other social media.

Again, this is easily verifiable as false, even if you actually believe the Chinese leader would break protocol in such a childish way. Each of the multiple times Xi and Putin shook hands at the summit, they did so in front of a different background, and the one seen in the viral fake video is from the August SCO summit in Bishkek. In some cases, the video is even watermarked with the username of its supposed creator, whose X account was created on November 18 and who has admitted to editing an old clip with Grok.

For some actual sensible analysis of the protocol, let’s look at the Putin-Xi-Trump meeting.

Putin is on the right side of the host, while Trump is on the left. The Chinese Foreign Ministry follows the principle of “the place of honor is to the right of the host.” Even so, there is nothing uniquely Chinese about this. It fully corresponds to international practice. Now watch closely. In the photo with their wives, Trump was placed first, Putin second. The same at the banquet.

In the APEC family photo, Putin was first, Trump second. The same at the trilateral meeting.

In other words, the Chinese did not single out either the Russian or the American leader as the one ‘chief guest,’ preferring instead to rotate them. And that is undoubtedly a wise decision.

Here’s one more detail. The name of the meeting that will go down, if not in textbooks, then certainly in articles, translates from the Chinese 中俄美元首深圳会晤 as ‘Shenzhen meeting of the heads of state of the PRC, the Russian Federation, and the United States’. China-Russia-US Shenzhen Summit. As host, Xi Jinping determined the order in which the countries were mentioned in the event’s title, and Russia came before the US. That decision was not protocol-related, but political.

As for the APEC summit itself, on purely formal protocol grounds it would have been perfectly logical to place Russia further back, since Russia (unlike the US) was not one of APEC’s founding members and only began participating in the forum in 1998, joining in the last group together with Peru and Vietnam. China also was not a founding member, but it joined APEC much earlier, in 1991. And yet, as we can see, full respect was shown to the leader of our country. One would have to be completely detached from reality to keep believing otherwise to the very end.

It is astonishing how many experts, including professors from leading American and European universities, believed the fake APEC photographs. It seems that high academic titles are no guarantee of immunity against fakes – especially when an image fits one’s own political assumptions and one does not want to change them. Yet the world is changing. Perhaps it is time to propose a new measure of an event’s international significance: the number of AI-generated fakes it produces. The more of them there are, the less the summit or visit fits familiar templates. And, most likely, that is precisely why it can be considered successful.

What surprises me most is not even that prominent experts believed fairly crude fakes. Much more interesting is the reaction some of them had to being debunked: yes, the photograph may have been fake, but the conclusions drawn from it were entirely correct. I do not know what such professors teach their students. I fear that even during their lectures, if facts do not confirm their hypothesis, it is enough to declare that the unverified hypothesis still reflects reality anyway.

The statements, views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of RT.

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: rt.com