Shenzhen –
Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi’s brief handshake with Chinese President Xi Jinping and subsequent 30-minute discussion with Russian President Vladimir Putin at the APEC summit in China on November 18th highlighted the extraordinary deterioration in Japan’s relations with its two powerful neighbors over the past five years, a period marked by territorial disputes, military tensions, economic retaliation and an increasingly divided international order.
The encounters in Shenzhen offered a rare opportunity for direct communication between leaders whose governments have become deeply suspicious of one another. Yet the circumstances surrounding both meetings illustrated how difficult it has become for Japan to maintain workable relationships with China and Russia while strengthening its security alliance with the United States.
Takaichi smiled and exchanged greetings with Xi during a dinner hosted by the Chinese president, marking their first face-to-face encounter in approximately a year. Although Xi responded with a calm expression, Japanese government officials were quick to dismiss suggestions that the exchange represented a diplomatic breakthrough, describing it as little more than the customary courtesy expected of the summit’s host.
The restrained response reflected the depth of the crisis that has developed between Tokyo and Beijing, particularly since Takaichi’s parliamentary remarks in November 2025 concerning a possible Chinese military operation against Taiwan.
Takaichi suggested that a conflict involving Taiwan could constitute a situation threatening Japan’s survival, potentially providing grounds for the Self-Defense Forces to act under Japan’s security legislation. Beijing regarded the comments as interference in what it considers an internal matter and a challenge to its sovereignty, while Tokyo maintained that its position on Taiwan had not changed.
The controversy exposed a fundamental disagreement that has become increasingly difficult to manage. China considers Taiwan an inseparable part of its territory and regards any suggestion of Japanese military involvement as unacceptable. Japan, however, views peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait as essential to its national security, particularly given the proximity of Taiwan to Okinawa and the presence of major American military installations in Japan.
The deterioration did not begin with Takaichi. Over the previous five years, relations between Japan and China had already been strained by repeated confrontations around the Senkaku Islands in the East China Sea, which Japan administers but China claims as the Diaoyu Islands.
Chinese coast guard vessels have maintained a persistent presence near the islands, frequently entering waters Japan considers its territorial sea. Tokyo regards these activities as attempts to undermine Japanese administration of the territory, while Beijing maintains that its vessels are operating in waters over which China has legitimate sovereignty claims.
The dispute has become increasingly dangerous as Chinese military operations expand around Taiwan and Japan’s southwestern islands. Japanese defense officials have repeatedly expressed concern about encounters involving Chinese aircraft and naval vessels, warning that an accident or miscalculation could escalate into a wider confrontation.
Economic relations have provided another source of friction. In August 2023, China suspended imports of Japanese seafood following the beginning of the discharge of treated water from the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant into the Pacific Ocean.
Japan maintained that the release complied with international safety standards and was subject to monitoring by the International Atomic Energy Agency. China challenged the safety of the discharge and defended its import restrictions as necessary to protect public health.
The disagreement developed into a broader diplomatic confrontation, with Japanese seafood producers suffering the loss of a major export market. Although Beijing later moved toward a partial resumption of imports, restrictions were reintroduced following the renewed Taiwan controversy in November 2025.
The treatment of Japanese nationals in China has further undermined confidence. Arrests under Chinese national security and espionage legislation have alarmed Japanese businesses operating in the country, particularly because of concerns over the scope and interpretation of the laws.
As of the end of 2025, five Japanese nationals remained imprisoned in China, according to Japan’s Foreign Ministry. Tokyo has repeatedly called for the release of detainees and greater transparency, while Beijing maintains that its legal proceedings are conducted in accordance with Chinese law.
These disputes have complicated an economic relationship that remains enormously important to both countries. China continues to occupy a central position in Japanese manufacturing supply chains, and Japanese companies retain substantial commercial interests in the Chinese market.
For Tokyo, the challenge has been to reduce strategic dependence on China without damaging an economic relationship that supports employment, investment and trade. For Beijing, Japan’s closer military cooperation with the United States and its expanding security ties with Taiwan have become growing sources of concern.
The confrontation has also created a difficult political question for Takaichi. Her firm position on Taiwan and national defense appeals to supporters who believe Japan must respond more decisively to China’s military expansion. Critics, however, argue that public statements about hypothetical military scenarios can unnecessarily narrow diplomatic options and increase the likelihood of confrontation.
The danger is that both governments may become trapped by their domestic political positions, leaving little room for compromise even when maintaining dialogue would serve their mutual interests.
Japan’s relationship with Russia presents a different but equally complicated diplomatic challenge.
For much of the period before 2022, Tokyo pursued engagement with Moscow in the hope of resolving the longstanding dispute over four islands northeast of Hokkaido, known in Japan as the Northern Territories and internationally as part of the southern Kuril Islands.
The islands were occupied by Soviet forces in the closing stages of World War II, and the territorial disagreement has prevented Japan and Russia from concluding a formal peace treaty.
Former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe invested considerable diplomatic effort in developing a personal relationship with Putin, holding numerous meetings and exploring economic cooperation as a means of advancing negotiations.
Despite these efforts, the two countries failed to reach an agreement, and the prospects for a settlement deteriorated sharply following Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022.
Japan joined the United States and European countries in imposing economic sanctions on Russia, restricting financial transactions, exports and access to sensitive technologies. Tokyo condemned the invasion as a violation of international law and warned that permitting territorial changes through military force would have serious implications for security in East Asia.
Moscow responded by suspending peace treaty negotiations in March 2022, ending visa-free exchanges involving former residents of the disputed islands and withdrawing from discussions about joint economic activities.
Russia also designated Japan an unfriendly country, reflecting the broader collapse in bilateral relations.
The breakdown was especially painful for former residents of the Northern Territories and their families, many of whom had hoped to visit ancestral graves or maintain contact with the islands where they once lived.
At the same time, Japan faced a difficult economic contradiction. While supporting sanctions against Russia, Tokyo continued to maintain interests in the Sakhalin-1 and Sakhalin-2 energy projects, which are considered important to Japanese energy security.
The decision reflected the practical difficulties of completely severing economic relations with a neighboring resource producer, even when political relations have deteriorated.
Bilateral trade has contracted dramatically, falling from approximately $20.8 billion in fiscal 2021 to $7.6 billion in fiscal 2025, illustrating the economic consequences of the confrontation.
More recently, disputes involving Japanese citizens and companies have added another layer of tension.
A journalist working for the Hokkaido Shimbun newspaper was detained by Russian authorities in October 2026 on suspicion of espionage, prompting demands from Tokyo for an early release. The case has raised concerns about the risks faced by Japanese nationals working in Russia and the ability of the two governments to resolve sensitive consular matters.
Russia’s decision to place local operations belonging to Japan Tobacco under temporary Russian management has also intensified concerns over the security of Japanese corporate assets.
These issues featured prominently in Takaichi’s discussions with Putin following the APEC dinner. The Japanese prime minister conveyed Tokyo’s position on the journalist’s detention and is believed to have sought an early resolution to the dispute involving Japan Tobacco.
The two leaders agreed to continue exchanging views at various levels, an outcome that may appear modest but represents a significant departure from the prolonged absence of meaningful high-level communication.
Nevertheless, the meeting did little to address the fundamental causes of the breakdown in Japan-Russia relations.
Tokyo remains committed to supporting Ukraine and opposing territorial expansion through military force, while Moscow continues to reject Japan’s sanctions and maintains its position on the disputed northern islands.
There is also a wider strategic dimension that Japan cannot ignore. Over the past five years, China and Russia have strengthened their diplomatic and military cooperation, conducting joint naval patrols and air operations in the Asia-Pacific region.
For Japanese defense planners, the prospect of closer coordination between two nuclear-armed neighbors has become a serious security concern, particularly as Japan expands defense spending and develops new military capabilities.
From Beijing and Moscow’s perspective, however, Japan’s strengthening alliance with Washington and closer coordination with other American partners are themselves part of a broader effort to contain their strategic influence.
These competing interpretations have contributed to a cycle in which defensive measures taken by one side are perceived as threatening by the other, encouraging further military preparations and deepening mutual distrust.
Japan consequently faces a diplomatic balancing act that has become considerably more difficult than it was five years ago.
Maintaining close ties with Washington remains the foundation of Japanese security policy, but geography and economic realities make it impossible for Tokyo simply to disregard China and Russia.
China is an indispensable economic partner as well as a major security concern, while Russia remains an important neighboring power whose military activities, territorial disputes and energy resources directly affect Japanese interests.
The contrasting encounters at APEC demonstrated the different stages of these troubled relationships. With China, even a brief handshake attracted attention because relations have deteriorated to the point where ordinary diplomatic contact is interpreted as a potential political signal. With Russia, a 30-minute conversation represented an opportunity to address urgent disputes despite the absence of any broader reconciliation.
Neither meeting should be mistaken for a fundamental change in policy. The territorial disputes remain unresolved, the disagreements over Taiwan and Ukraine are deeply entrenched, and the strategic rivalry involving the United States, China and Russia shows little sign of diminishing.
Yet the encounters also demonstrated that diplomatic communication remains possible even when governments disagree over fundamental questions of sovereignty and security.
The challenge for Takaichi will be to determine whether such limited contacts can develop into sustained dialogue without weakening Japan’s established security commitments or compromising its position on international law.
After five years of escalating confrontation, the question is no longer whether Japan can restore the comparatively cooperative relationships it once sought with Beijing and Moscow, but whether it can prevent those relationships from deteriorating further.
The handshake with Xi and conversation with Putin offered no immediate solution, but they served as reminders that the absence of dialogue carries risks of its own, particularly when the disputes involve neighboring powers whose economic and military influence Japan cannot escape.
Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: newsonjapan.com










