ANN ARBOR, Mich. — Circulating on social media the past few weeks, there have been images of Michigan football head coach Kyle Whittingham walking away from huddles, on the sideline, his headset mic flipped up. Often when he’s shown on TV, his mic is flipped up, and he appears to be looking at the action on the field like a deer in headlights. Thus, the narrative is that he’s disengaged.
Fair or not fair?
Advertisement
According to Wolverines defensive coordinator Jay Hill, who played under Whittingham at Utah and then coached under him there for years before reconciling in Ann Arbor, it’s not fair. It’s simply a narrative that starts when your team isn’t doing well.
“I think right now people are looking for things,” Hill said. “Coach Whitt is the most engaged coach there is. I mean, he’s on the headset. If he walks away from a huddle or something like that, he’s on the headset with exact focus on what we need to be doing at that point.
“If you watch all coaches in those situations, not everyone is right in the huddle at all times. That’s just not how it is. And I think the reality is that right now people are searching for things that are going on. We just can’t do that. The key is what do you got to do to win, and let’s get involved in everything that we need to do to win.”
When a team isn’t doing well, and isn’t winning — especially at a place like Michigan — everything is under a microscope. But fans and media can’t see what they can’t see, because college football programs are notoriously closed off. We can’t hear the sideline chatter or practices to know just how engaged or not engaged a figure like Whittingham truly is. All we can do is take the word of those closer to it.
Advertisement
And if the Wolverines were winning, we wouldn’t need to.
Offensive line coach and interim offensive coordinator Jim Harding has been with Whittingham longer than any other coach on his staff, having joined him at Utah in 2014. He’s seen some ups and downs, but his take is that it’s still the same Whittingham in Ann Arbor as it was in Salt Lake City. It’s less about the fire and desire as much as trying to figure out his change of scenery.
“I think he is as competitive as he’s ever been,” Harding said. “It’s a matter of — I think all of us, me included, you’re trying to learn the kids in this new program, what kind of motivates them? What are the things that you’re really trying to press upon, but yet also embrace everything, the great tradition that is here.
“And so I think there is a learning curve. I don’t wanna speak for coach, but it’s a really, really good question. In my opinion, he’s as fiery, demanding. For me, trust me, he has no problem yelling at me when I’m wrong. And so I think that, to me, shows that he still has the passion. He’s just trying to, again, not to speak for him, trying to figure out what is the formula here at Michigan as we continue to learn each other, if that makes sense.”
Advertisement
Social media has become something of a firestorm. But that’s bled into real life, as well.
While fans and media have had their takes in articles and on podcasts (I’ve done both, and one is included below via YouTube, and the other is linked here), it reached a fever pitch at the Oregon game, when in the aftermath of the 31-7 loss, fans crowded outside the visiting press conference tent and voiced their displeasure in person.
Whittingham demurred on Monday, first saying he wasn’t aware of it, before admitting it’s part of the job. But Harding says that’s part of who he is — the outside noise doesn’t get to him.
Advertisement
“As competitive as he is, I know that it wears on him to lose,” Harding said. “And I don’t mean this to come off arrogant or unaware: I honestly don’t think he is overly concerned about what people say outside of this building. And I know that that might sound wrong. But I think as a leader or any person in a position of leadership, if your concern is all the other, the noise outside, you’re doing a disservice to the kids that you’re in charge of.
“And again, I don’t wanna speak for him, but in terms of how upset he is and bothered by the season, I would say immensely. Because we have not, in my 10 years or 12 years with them, we did not have a season — 2017, we ended up 6-5. We had a bunch of injuries on the offensive line that year — 7-6. And that would be the closest in the time that I’ve been with him, where you’d be in a position like this.
“And so I’m sure it’s weighing on him immensely, but not necessarily because of the external stuff from the fact that we’re not as successful as what we should be.”
There are plenty of faults to go around, of course. While the defense has been mostly elite, the issues have mostly stemmed from the offensive ineptitude this season. From the inability to settle on a quarterback, to the ‘rhino’ position, escalating to Jason Beck’s firing on November 8.
Advertisement
Harding’s unit, the offensive line, has particularly regressed, which he notes has had seven permutations throughout the year. Though Whittingham has continued to look forward, pointing to his need to get players via recruiting and the transfer portal, Harding says he can look back and see some areas where he’s gone wrong since he arrived in Ann Arbor.
“I can’t speak for everybody, but they’re just being completely transparent. There are so many things I wish I would have done in the offensive line room,” Harding said. “And I’m not gonna expand on it right here because we have to go practice. But there, and again, I don’t wanna speak for everybody else, but I have said that — I’ve talked to mentors I have in the profession, of things that I know I should have done differently coming here. But like I said, hindsight’s 20-20, but yeah, absolutely.”
Neither speculated on the tenuous nature of their jobs with a new athletic director coming in, with Trev Alberts slated to begin on December 1. But Harding did note that it’s part of the job that if you don’t get results, you might find yourself out on the chopping block.
This article originally appeared on Wolverines Wire: Michigan football assistants defend Kyle Whittingham amid criticism
Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: Sports.yahoo.com








