Home International ‘Not acting in good faith’: The empty block becoming a thorn in...

‘Not acting in good faith’: The empty block becoming a thorn in a booming suburb’s side

0
4
Advertisement

In a booming inner Melbourne village desperate for community hubs, residents and traders say a vacant shopfront and neighbouring razed block have become a glaring dead zone on a humming local strip.

The West Footscray village is the kind of place locals greet their baristas by name.

On a relaxed Sunday morning, tables are lined up outside Barkly Street cafes filled with people leaning back on wooden chairs, chatting happily with their kids and dogs in tow. A Makers Market put on by the traders association opened on Saturday in a vacant shopfront, and a yoga studio, wine bar and pizza joint are among local businesses who give up their space for the annual Footscray West Writers Fest.

But some feel there’s an outlier on the strip. The Uniting Church’s brick shopfront and large neighbouring razed block are off-limits and empty – the shopfront, vacant for about a decade.

Footscray West Writers Fest co-founder Jess Lilley in front of the vacant Uniting Church block at 557a Barkly Street, West Footscray. Jason South

Writers fest co-founder and artistic director Jess Lilley approached the charity about using the shopfront for the event back in 2024, and was told the space (a brick and concrete box) did not have toilets and was not in “a fit state” to lease. When Lilley offered to organise toilets, and asked if six months was enough time to get the shop in better shape, the answer was still no.

While the Uniting Church lets the shop and land sit unusable and empty, the neighbourhood is contending with a deficit of community space, Lilley said.

“It just sucks because the community is exploding around here. It’s a really active and engaged community, and it feels like there should be some momentum, but this village just never takes off,” Lilley said. “It feels like they’re not acting in good faith.”

Advertisement

Lilley and backers argue the church’s behaviour amounts to land banking, which she says is “reprehensible” for an organisation meant to support the community. The issue – which is symptomatic of a more complex problem, whereby high construction costs, elevated taxes and charges, expensive finance and subdued apartment values are deterring landowners from developing projects – is widespread in Footscray.

The land comprising some 1580 square metres might be akin to a pin on a map in the Uniting Church’s property portfolio, but in West Footscray, it’s a glaring physical divider on Barkly Street, Lilley said. She suggested the church should invest in making the space usable, even temporarily. The Uniting Church blocks are among several vacant sites in the village.

Migrant Coffee co-owner Andrew Ly said business owners on the strip tried to work together to make it more vibrant.

“When you have a party who is not willing to contribute to that … it’s such a shame,” Ly said. “When you have an empty part [of the strip], what that means is there’s nothing going on there. There’s no reason for people to go there.”

The vacant Uniting Church shopfront at 557 Barkly Street, West Footscray.
The vacant Uniting Church shopfront at 557 Barkly Street, West Footscray.Jason South

Uniting Church confirmed it plans to develop a modern worship and community space on the site, comprising gathering and meeting spaces, dual kitchens, an “indoor enchanted garden” and a carpark. However, the plans – initially intended to be put to council in mid-2026 – are yet to publicly materialise.

Advertisement

“Like all projects of this size there are many pre-planning issues to resolve, including a design within the flood overlay, engineering suitable to ground conditions, fire safety aspects in building to a boundary and traffic management in developing the land suitable to the surrounding environment,” a Uniting Church spokeswoman said.

“We have been focused on developing a proposal that satisfies the needs of a widely varied worshipping community at Footscray while providing a modern facility that meets the needs of today. This takes time and it is important to get it right.”

The church that previously stood on the vacant 1053 square metre grass block at 557a Barkly Street was declared unsafe due to its age and wear and tear, before it was bulldozed in 2021, the Uniting Church spokeswoman confirmed.

She cited “vandalism and rubbish dumping” as additional factors behind its demolition, and said remaining structures “do not satisfy the legal requirements for leasing”.

“The remaining minor structures will be demolished with the forthcoming project,” the Uniting spokeswoman said.

At the Makers Market on Barkly Street on Sunday, families wandered in to get a start on their Christmas shopping, marvelling at local artists’ work in what was a vacant shop just days ago. The West 3012 Business Association is waiting to hear whether they’ll be able to renew their short lease on the space, which they secured through a council grant, association president Reem Sweid said.

Advertisement

Sweid, who co-founded West Footscray Arts with Lilley, believes the church has a different obligation to the community than private landowners. She said more than 90 people applied to stock their work at the market.

Before they find out about the lease, though, the women are just happy to see a vacant shopfront put to good use.

Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: www.smh.com.au