Home National Oil Co.s Reap Huge Profits During Iran War; Windfall Taxes Needed

Oil Co.s Reap Huge Profits During Iran War; Windfall Taxes Needed

0
1

Chennai: Oil companies have seen their profits surging multi-fold during the Iran war. While US oil companies have already garnered $130 billion in profits, the figure is expected to touch $234 billion this year. Indian oil exporting companies, including Reliance, too have seen their profits surge. As crude prices cool off, countries should impose windfall taxes on oil companies, and India should consider bringing down ethanol blending levels to address concerns of consumers, says Ajay Kedia, MD, Kedia Commodities.

How did the Iran war translate into billions of dollars in additional profits for global oil companies and oil traders?

Whenever there is global uncertainty, crude oil and energy prices react very quickly. This time too, as soon as the US-Iran war started in February, prices moved sharply, touching almost $120 a barrel. This meant that energy costs nearly doubled.

The Iran war has translated into an opportunity for certain sectors, while others have been adversely affected. US oil and gas companies earned around $130 billion in profits between April and September 2026, which is almost three times their average earnings.

ExxonMobil, America’s largest oil producer, reported a net profit of $15.3 billion in Q3 2026, double the amount it reported in the corresponding period last year. One of the important factors behind this was the increase in crude prices. Last year, prices were around $61-$62 a barrel, whereas this year they went up to approximately $115.

Chevron also earned approximately $12 billion in Q3 2026, which was a remarkable 380 per cent higher year-on-year.

On the domestic front, we have seen India’s biggest oil company, Reliance’s oil-to-chemicals business, report EBITDA of more than Rs 25,000 crore in Q2 FY27, up by around 66-67 per cent. Export-oriented companies have benefited significantly from the improvement in profit margins.

In many ways, the Iran war turned out to be like a Diwali period for US oil companies and Indian oil refineries.

While most oil companies have seen their profits rise, why did US oil producers and refiners benefit while some Middle Eastern oil producers suffered losses?

We need to compare the present crisis with the energy crisis of 2022. At that time, the epicentre of the disruption was the Black Sea region, particularly Russia and Ukraine. Russian production was continuously declining, but the impact on the US and the Middle East was relatively limited.

This time, however, the epicentre is the Middle East. The US is currently one of the world’s biggest oil producers. It has also had access to crude supplies from Venezuela. Companies such as ExxonMobil and Chevron are based in the US. Since international prices remained elevated throughout the last six to seven months, these companies benefited without being directly exposed to the conflict zone.

The situation was very different for Middle Eastern producers such as Saudi Aramco and ADNOC. They faced infrastructure and shipping risks because of the closure of the Strait of Hormuz. Iraq’s participation in the market was negligible, while Saudi Arabia attempted to use pipelines and alternative routes to transport crude. However, these alternatives involved significantly higher costs.

The Middle East also faced infrastructure damage, disruptions in shipments and elevated insurance and freight costs.

Therefore, while US producers and refiners gained from the higher international prices, Middle Eastern producers lost market share and, in some cases, revenue. The geographical location of production and the ability to transport oil became critical factors determining who benefited from the crisis.

US oil companies have been making billions, but American consumers have been paying more for fuel. How do you explain this irony?

Whenever something of this magnitude happens, ultimately the end user has to pay more. We have seen US producers earn billions during the last seven months. Companies such as ExxonMobil and other producers benefited because their production continued and their refineries were operating well.

The immediate disruption in supplies from the Middle East created an opportunity for US producers and refiners to earn additional margins. Higher international prices translated into better earnings for them.

Recently, there were reports that average oil prices in the US were around $112-$115. While companies benefited from these prices, the cost of living for American households increased tremendously. The tariff war and other economic pressures have already added to the burden on consumers.

The US has also faced diesel supply disruptions. Before the election, there were attempts to secure diesel supplies from Russia. More recently, Marco Rubio’s visit to India and his interaction with the country’s biggest oil refining company brought attention to the US’s dependence on external refining capacity.

The US has good crude production, but it has not built sufficient refining capacity to meet all its requirements. This has created a mismatch between crude production and the availability of refined products.

India too has experienced the impact, with retail fuel prices remaining somewhat elevated.

So, while one section of the industry is making substantial profits, consumers are paying more. That is the contradiction we are witnessing in the present energy crisis.

Doesn’t this make us wonder whether the war has become a source of extraordinary profits for companies at the expense of ordinary people? Once the war ends, should windfall taxes be imposed on oil companies? How can consumers be compensated for their losses?

Ultimately, whenever such a crisis occurs, consumers end up paying the price. We have seen several government policy interventions during energy crises, but the burden of financing them often falls on the public.

We can take the example of the 2022 energy crisis in Europe. At that time, energy prices surged to around $130. European governments introduced windfall taxes because companies were making extraordinary profits as a result of the crisis.

The principle behind such taxation is that when companies earn unusually high profits because of a war or an extraordinary geopolitical situation, a portion of those earnings should be channelled towards providing economic relief.

US companies have earned billions of dollars during the current crisis. It is estimated that their profits could reach $234 billion in 2026, given that crude prices remained above the $100 mark for a substantial period. US Senator Elizabeth Warren also highlighted the possibility of imposing additional taxes on the industry.

India needs to examine the issue carefully as well. Reliance has benefited from higher refining margins, particularly in its export-oriented oil-to-chemicals business. However, Indian Oil Corporation, BPCL and HPCL have faced marketing and LPG under-recoveries.

Therefore, imposing the same tax on every oil company could be counterproductive. The companies are not all in the same position, and their exposure to the crisis is different.

I believe temporary windfall taxes should be considered whenever companies make abnormal profits. The objective should be to ensure that extraordinary gains arising from a crisis also benefit the people who have borne the higher costs.

As crude oil prices begin to cool off, do you think retail fuel prices in India will also come down?

Yes, I believe they should eventually come down. At present, our procurement costs are still very high because of elevated international crude prices.

Whenever energy prices rise, they also affect overall inflation. The government is keen to control inflation, particularly because food inflation is already a concern due to the El Nino-related risks.

If energy inflation rises further, it will become a double whammy for the Indian government. Higher energy costs affect transportation, manufacturing and several other sectors, eventually feeding into the prices consumers pay.

As crude prices come down gradually, the government will review the situation and look at ways to bring energy inflation under control.

However, the reduction in retail fuel prices may not happen immediately. Oil marketing companies are still dealing with substantial under-recoveries. Once crude prices settle down, perhaps in the range of $70-$75 a barrel, these under-recoveries should decline.

That could create room for a reduction in prices, but it will take some time. I expect a gradual correction over the next couple of months rather than an immediate reduction.

During the war, India increased ethanol blending, with the government arguing that it helped reduce crude imports and save foreign exchange. If ethanol blending is saving foreign exchange, why are consumers not seeing a corresponding reduction in petrol prices?

Our original E20 objective was to achieve 20 per cent ethanol blending by 2030. We have achieved that target much earlier than anticipated.

However, there are concerns about vehicle performance. There have been reports of reduced mileage, and consumers are questioning the economics of the arrangement.

If I am paying for 100 per cent petrol but receiving a mixture containing only 80 per cent petrol, I would naturally expect some corresponding benefit. The performance of vehicles is another important concern for users.

At the same time, we should recognise that the ethanol industry has benefited considerably. According to the latest figures, ethanol procurement worth more than Rs 1.72 lakh crore has taken place. Ethanol producers have benefited, and manufacturing capacity has expanded. Biofuel infrastructure is also gradually improving.

So, while the policy has helped build a domestic ethanol industry and reduce dependence on imported crude, we must also examine whether consumers are receiving adequate benefits.

If the government is procuring only 80 per cent petrol because of 20 per cent ethanol blending, shouldn’t petrol prices also come down?

Yes, ideally, consumers should see some benefit. Energy costs have increased by almost 45-50 per cent in some countries. In India, the government has tried to manage the situation through a combination of measures, including some price adjustments and the 20 per cent ethanol blending programme.

However, oil marketing companies are still facing substantial under-recoveries. Once crude prices settle down, say in the range of $70-$75 a barrel, these under-recoveries should come down. That could make a reduction in retail fuel prices possible.

We must also consider the government’s larger economic priorities. Food inflation could become a significant concern in 2027 because of El Nino and its impact on agricultural production. If energy inflation remains elevated as well, the government will face additional pressure.

Therefore, I do not think the government will want to sustain higher fuel prices for a prolonged period. As crude prices gradually decline, there should be room for some correction, although it may take at least a couple of months.

Reports also indicate that ethanol procurement costs were higher than the pre-tax refinery-gate cost of petrol. Is ethanol blending economically viable without government-administered procurement prices, incentives and assured purchases by oil marketing companies?

When we discuss the economics of ethanol production, we must first look at the prices of the agricultural commodities used in the manufacturing process. These include maize, paddy and other agricultural products.

We have recently seen sugar prices increase. Maize prices too have risen by more than 20-25 per cent year-on-year. When the prices of these inputs increase, the cost of ethanol production also rises.

The government must ensure that agricultural production remains strong. This year could be challenging because of El Nino and the possibility of poor rainfall.

If agricultural production is affected, procurement costs will rise. That will have a direct bearing on the economics of ethanol blending.

Therefore, the E20 policy could face challenges if agricultural commodity prices remain elevated. We need to examine the availability and affordability of feedstock before assuming that higher blending levels will automatically translate into economic benefits.

The long-term viability of ethanol blending will depend on the cost of agricultural inputs, the production capacity of manufacturers and the procurement arrangements put in place by the government.

If crude oil prices are coming down, shouldn’t oil marketing companies also consider reducing their ethanol blending levels?

There is no doubt that E20 blending has raised several concerns. We have heard reports of mileage reduction of around 3-5 per cent, besides compatibility issues, particularly in older vehicles.

The issue of food versus fuel is another important concern. This year, poor rainfall and the possibility of a weak monsoon could affect maize and sugarcane production, which are important inputs for ethanol manufacturing.

According to some recent reports, ethanol blending could decline to around 15-17 per cent because of these constraints.

However, rather than looking at the issue only in terms of reducing blending levels, I believe the government should consider giving consumers a choice.

For instance, consumers could be offered different options, such as 100 per cent petrol, E10 or E20, depending on their vehicle requirements and preferences.

This would allow people with older vehicles or those concerned about mileage and compatibility to make an informed decision.

Several countries that have adopted ethanol blending have not made it mandatory for all consumers. They have provided options. Countries such as China have also made significant progress in electric vehicles. Should India look at alternatives instead of mandatorily pushing ethanol-blended fuel?

Yes, there are alternatives that India needs to examine. The electric vehicle market has expanded tremendously over the last couple of years. The Indian government is also working on hydrogen-based vehicle technology, although developing and commercialising that technology will take time.

We should not look at ethanol as the only solution to our energy security concerns. There are several options available, including electric mobility and other alternative fuels.

However, our immediate priority is to safeguard foreign exchange reserves. We have already seen a significant decline in our forex reserves, and reducing dependence on imported crude remains important for the country.

At present, the government does not have a proposal to return to E10 or E0. The blending programme has already been upgraded, and the policy direction is towards greater use of ethanol.

But going forward, the government must balance energy security with consumer interests. It should take into account vehicle compatibility, mileage, agricultural production and the cost of ethanol.

The ultimate objective should be to reduce India’s dependence on imported crude without placing an unfair burden on consumers.

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: deccanchronicle.com