Sam is just one of many West Australians who launched an Instagram account to document his new build in Kennedy Bay a year ago.
He and his daughter picked the block of land south of Perth due to its proximity to the ocean – a coastal dream Sam had ever since he moved to WA a decade ago – and they anticipated updating their account with day-to-day updates on the build’s progress for their small following.
Sam, who asked for his last name not to published to avoid it impacting his career, paid about $346,000 for the block of land, and after extensive research, landed on Perth-based New Choice Homes to do the build.
Their prices were competitive, he told this masthead, and they were promised predictability and a shortened build time for their home, which Sam said was a simple concept.
His family wanted just the structure of the house established – none of the finishings, no extras – so he and his daughter could move in and start their new life as soon as possible. The company told him he could expect completion as early as July next year.
However, as problems began to mount, Sam’s build diary took a hard turn.
“100 days without construction on site. Still paying rent. Still waiting. Still no confirmed restart date. A building delay isn’t just a delay. Every extra week means more rent, more uncertainty, and more pressure on the family,” he posted.
“Homeowners don’t expect perfection. They know delays happen. But they expect to be told what’s going on.”
What was supposed to an account to document their happy journey on the way to a new home became a means for Sam to document what he claimed were ongoing problems with his build.
The first sign things weren’t going according to his plan was when the slab got poured ahead of schedule – meaning his independent building inspector couldn’t attend and check its specifications and construction.
However, he resolved trust the process once bricks arrived on the site and it looked like construction on the frame was about to begin.
But then, the days started to pass.
“Weeks were passing by, and I said to myself, ‘Sam, shut up. Don’t say anything because you’re going to upset them’,” he told this masthead.
About 108 days after the slab was poured, Sam finally decided to post to his Instagram build diary.
“Bricks arrived, bricklayers didn’t. 12 weeks since slab, how long did you wait?”
The post attracted dozens of comments, with other build diary pages lamenting their own experience with WA’s well-documented brick delays. Some said their bricks had gone down about four to five weeks, while others said they had waited as long as 14 weeks.
“The post was viewed 8500 times,” Sam told this masthead.
Soon after the post went up, he got a phone call from a New Choice employee, who left “not a very friendly voicemail”.
“He’s saying ‘You’re posting on social media and you shouldn’t be doing that’,” Sam said.
An email sent to Sam read similarly:
“To clarify, the reason for my initial outreach was to discuss the appropriate way forward through open discussion and ensure your concerns are directed through the correct internal channels for resolution,” the employee wrote.
“As mentioned, negative commentary on social media will not expedite the progress of construction, nor assist in achieving a resolution.”
Sam responded, pointing out the ACCC said consumers had the right to share genuine reviews, and offering to correct anything that was inaccurate.
Bricklaying at his property started shortly after, and Sam thought he was back on track.
But the problems kept coming, and Sam kept documenting.
In August, he got an email from the company’s portal advising him his roof framing had been completed, and it was ready for his independent building inspector. However, when Sam visited the site shortly after, the roof framing material was still on the ground.
He called it the “most ridiculous update yet” on his Instagram page, in a post that gained about 5000 views.
Then, in October, a drip leak caused parts of the slab to be flooded, and wrecked new material that had only just been put down.
Sam had been driving by when he saw the water streaming from the floor, and raced in to try and stop it.
Deeply frustrated, he posted to social media again.
“Builders are legally responsible for supervision. New Choice Homes, why did we – not you – discover our home flooding?” Sam wrote.
“How many days had it been leaking before we found it?”
His building inspector came to look at the leak damage, and also reported three defects back to Sam. The pictures went straight to his Instagram account.
This time, a more senior New Choice Homes worker got involved.
But, Sam said, rather than addressing the issues he continued to document, the biggest issue appeared to also be Sam’s public commentary.
“I have been following your web page and Instagram page and am disappointed to see the content you are sharing about us,” the worker wrote to Sam.
“I would like to arrange a time for you to come in and discuss what it is you are not getting from us and what New Choice Homes can do to give you an experience that you are happy with.”
But Sam said it was too little, too late.
Speaking to this masthead, a New Choice Homes spokesperson said their team had made multiple attempts to meet with Sam, but he had rejected their offers. Sam said he had wanted all communication to remain in writing.
“We are 7½ months into his build, are well within our contracted time frames and our team liaises with him regularly to update him and address his concerns relating to what we think are normal issues during construction,” the New Choice spokesperson said.
“The only delay experienced was with respect to bricks, an industry-wide issue since the beginning of the year, which I am sure you are aware of.”
The spokesperson said the flooding issue had happened over a weekend, and there had been no real structural damage as it was not at the lock-up stage.
However, advice from Sam’s independent building inspector, seen by this masthead, said a metal door frame would likely need a rust treatment, and a plasterboard may need to be replaced pending moisture checks.
“If we are given the chance to complete his home, we will most certainly rectify any issues (at our expense) brought up during construction including rectifying any damage or defects, and hand over a home to a high quality,” the New Choices spokesperson said.
“[Sam] is very capable and confident in sharing his experience online via a dedicated Instagram page and a dedicated website, which is updated by him regularly.
“We have welcomed this from the start as it was an opportunity to get exposure and still hope that we can give him a good experience.
“He also has the option of taking things further using the correct channel of putting in a notice of proposed complaint with the Building Commission, which to date he has not done.”
Sam told this masthead he had made two attempts to complain to Building and Energy, but they warned him he would need to wait until the agreed end of the build to file something formally.
And therein lies the problem. He said there were very few mechanisms for customers to sound the alarm when the build was in the middle of going wrong – rather than waiting for any calamitous outcome.
“What effective intervention is available before the contractual completion date, when delays and potential defects are already being documented?” he said.
“Regulation should help prevent problems from escalating, not just provide remedies after the damage is done.”
From our partners
Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: www.smh.com.au





