Home International The MLBPA’s Nuclear Weapon Against A Salary Cap

The MLBPA’s Nuclear Weapon Against A Salary Cap

0
2

MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred has said that MLB owners won’t compromise on salary cap. So with talks seemingly stalled, we are hearing the MLBPA and players are considering a disclaimer of interest as an option.

Disclaiming is a dramatic tool with serious consequences, sometimes described as triggering a “nuclear winter.”

Advertisement

What Is A Disclaimer Of Interest?

A disclaimer of interest dissolves the union and turns it into a trade association. The union gives up its ability to bargain collectively for the players. It isn’t a formal process. It can be as quick as the union’s executive director sending a letter to the Commissioner’s office stating that the union no longer represents the players as their bargaining agent. Players typically authorize the move by vote, and a simple majority (50% plus one) is enough. Unanimity is not required.

Baseball’s Unique Antitrust Position

Baseball has a history no other sport shares. Since Federal Baseball Club v. National League (1922), reaffirmed in Toolson (1953) and Flood v. Kuhn (1972), MLB has enjoyed a judge-made exemption from federal antitrust law. Congress narrowed that exemption in the Curt Flood Act of 1998. The Act lets major league players bring antitrust claims over conduct “directly relating to or affecting employment of major league baseball players,” on the same footing as athletes in other sports. Two limits matter. Only major league players have standing under the Act. And the Act leaves the labor exemption in place, which is why a disclaimer would be necessary before players could sue.

Advertisement

Why Would The MLBPA Do It?

Team owners are competitors under the law, and competitors can’t agree to fix the marketplace. Restrictions such as payroll controls, limits on free agency and rookie pay, along with a collective lockout, are antitrust violations on their face. When those restrictions sit inside a collective bargaining agreement (CBA), the CBA acts as a protective bubble that shields the league from antitrust liability. Dissolving the union bursts that bubble. The real goal is leverage: the threat of litigation, or an actual lawsuit, puts pressure on the league to settle on better terms. The stakes are high because antitrust damages can be tripled, which could mean catastrophic monetary awards against the league.

For example, if the proven monetary damages is $500 million (which is a lot to begin with), then it would be tripled to $1.5 billion.

How It Could Unfold

Advertisement

The likely sequence is a disclaimer, quickly followed by a player lawsuit claiming that the league’s conduct, starting with any lockout, violates antitrust law. The first claim would ask a court to declare the lockout unlawful and lift it. If the players win, the league would appeal. If the lockout is ultimately ruled unlawful, the league would have to resume operations. The NBA example shows how quickly this can play out: the NBPA dissolved on November 14, 2011, sued the next day, and had a deal by November 26.

Negotiations would be more challenging. Without a bargaining agent, the league would deal with lawyers for the individual player plaintiffs, so CBA talks would morph into lawsuit settlement talks.

MLB Sham Defence

MLB would argue that the only reason the MLBPA has dissolved is to gain leverage, and once they get what they want, they will just put the Union back together. On top of that, MLB would argue that MLBPA executives would still be directing things behind the scenes. This is MLB’s sham argument.

Advertisement

Would a disclaimer end the season?

Not necessarily. The point of dissolving is to save the season in the short term by creating pressure to reach a deal. Timing still matters and whether the union disclaims will largely depend on how close the sides are to a deal. Being “sort of close” won’t be enough, because until everything is agreed, nothing is agreed.

This article was originally published on Forbes.com

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: Sports.yahoo.com