Home International What if the Browns had kept Len Dawson? Maybe a disastrous trade...

What if the Browns had kept Len Dawson? Maybe a disastrous trade is avoided

0
3

EDITOR’S NOTE: In marking the Browns‘ 80th birthday, we present 10 vignettes that help define each 10-year period, along with eight “Story of the Decade” articles. This is the “Story of the Decade” for the franchise’s third-10-year period, 1966-75.

Put yourself in Mike Phipps’ cleats.

Advertisement

You barely missed a Heisman Trophy as a “Cradle of Quarterbacks” college star.

An NFL team viewed you as its franchise QB, but to get you had to fork over one of the most popular figures in its history.

You arrived as Led Zeppelin’s “Whole Lotta Love” lit up WMMS-FM, in the 25th season of the Browns’ classic history. The previous 24 produced 15 appearances in league championship games.

1 / 16

Eight decades of legends. Cleveland Browns Hall of Famers

Cleveland Browns fullback Jim Brown is shown breaking a tackle during the 1963 Pro Football Hall of Fame Game at Fawcett Stadium in Canton. Brown carried the ball 291 times for 1,863 yards in 14 games during the 1963 season.

(Canton Repository file photo)

“Stairway to Heaven” wasn’t about you. You didn’t turn into Otto Graham (105-17-4 record as Cleveland’s starting QB), or Milt Plum (33-16), or Frank Ryan (52-22-2), or Bill Nelsen (34-16-1).

Advertisement

Your record (24-25-2), your interceptions (81) and your placid persona made you a B-side disappointment as the franchise magic cracked.

Cleveland Browns quarterback Mike Phipps (15) at the line of scrimmage against the St. Louis Cardinals at Busch Stadium, Sept. 29, 1974.

Cleveland Browns quarterback Mike Phipps (15) at the line of scrimmage against the St. Louis Cardinals at Busch Stadium, Sept. 29, 1974.

Michael Elston Phipps disappeared from Cleveland 50 years ago and for the most part was never heard from again.

He did surface on camera with a gray head of hair in 2022, accompanied by his former college teammate Don Kiepert. “This is Purdue” interviewer Kate Young asked about his Browns days.

“Have you ever been booed?” Phipps said.

On Jan. 27, 1970, NFL Commissioner Pete Rozelle carried “the card” to a podium at the Belmont Plaza Hotel in New York City. Imagine if he had said:

Advertisement

“With the first pick in the NFL draft, the Pittsburgh Steelers select Mike Phipps, quarterback, Purdue.”

Phipps to Pittsburgh would have made sense.

The Steelers’ actual No. 1 pick, Terry Bradshaw, was erratic at Louisiana Tech. His last game brought a 34-14 loss to East Tennessee State in the Grantland Rice Bowl. The Steelers had just drafted Notre Dame QB Terry Hanratty at No. 30 overall in 1969.

Was spending the No. 1 on Bradshaw the latest shaky move by a Steelers team with a 7-33-2 record across the previous three seasons?

The safer pick was the consensus All-American, Phipps, who in 1968 led then-No. 1 Purdue to a 37-22 win at No. 2 Notre Dame, and in 1969 barely missed the Heisman, drawing lots more votes than the next-closest quarterbacks, Ohio State’s Rex Kern and Mississippi’s Archie Manning.

Purdue Boilermakers quarterback Mike Phipps in action at Ross-Ade Stadium, Nov. 11, 1967, in West Lafayette, Ind.

Purdue Boilermakers quarterback Mike Phipps in action at Ross-Ade Stadium, Nov. 11, 1967, in West Lafayette, Ind.

“NFL size, NFL mobility, NFL arm, Academic All-American … as close to can’t-miss as a QB can be,” was the scouting report Browns owner Art Modell bought.

Advertisement

Modell purchased the Browns in 1961, thirsting from the start for a piece of the action.

A big stink over Modell firing Paul Brown after the 1962 season blew over as the post-PB Browns played out the ’60s with seasons of 10-4, 10-3-1, 11-3, 9-5, 9-5, 10-4 and 10-3-1.

Modell feared slippage if he didn’t find a star quarterback for the ’70s. It would look bad if Brown’s expansion in Cincinnati, having jumped from the AFL to the NFL and the Browns’ division in 1970, outplayed Cleveland.

Nelsen was a born leader, and only 29, but he had an old man’s knees.

Dec 21, 1969; New York, NY, USA; FILE PHOTO; Cleveland Browns quarterback Bill Nelsen (16) at the line of scrimmage against the New York Giants at Yankee Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Manny Rubio-USA TODAY Sports

Dec 21, 1969; New York, NY, USA; FILE PHOTO; Cleveland Browns quarterback Bill Nelsen (16) at the line of scrimmage against the New York Giants at Yankee Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Manny Rubio-USA TODAY Sports

Some of the faces from the Paul Brown era were still around in 1970. One was Harold Sauerbrei, who covered the Browns for the Plain Dealer from 1946-54, was the team’s publicity chief from 1954-60, became Modell’s business manager in 1961, and bumped up to general manager when Brown got the boot.

Advertisement

Early in 1970, Modell and Sauerbrei assessed the draft pool and arranged a trade with Miami. The Dolphins were a fifth-year expansion team with an incoming head coach, Don Shula, who had played for the Browns and was head coach of the Baltimore Colts when they lost at Cleveland in the 1964 NFL finals.

Miami general manager Joe Thomas, having grown up in Warren, knew all there was to know about Paul Warfield.

Thomas talked Modell into parting with Warfield, then 27, in exchange for the third pick in the 1970 draft, with which the Browns picked the 22-year-old Phipps.  

There’s a Warfield statue in Warren.

1 / 52

Paul Warfield. Browns-Dolphins legend, NFL champ, Hall of Fame receiver

Paul Warfield played 13 seasons in the National Football League in a career that spanned from 1964 to 1977 with the Cleveland Browns and Miami Dolphins, and also included on season in the World Football League.

Warfield was enshrined into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1983.

(David Boss-US PRESSWIRE, IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect)

He starred at Warren Harding and Ohio State before playing on the Browns 1964 NFL championship team as a rookie. He was a precise craftsman with rocket speed. In three Browns playoff games against the Cowboys in consecutive years, his catches-yards lines were three for 99, four for 86 and eight for 99. He was the ideal offset to the run-first offenses of that era.

Advertisement

On and off the field, he exuded class.

Aug 30, 1969; Cleveland, OH, USA; FILE PHOTO: Cleveland Browns wide receiver (42) PAUL WARFIELD makes a catch in front of Green Bay Packers linebacker (89) DAVE ROBINSON during a preseason game at Cleveland Stadium.  The Browns won the game 27-17. Mandatory Credit: Tony Tomsic-USA TODAY NETWORK

Aug 30, 1969; Cleveland, OH, USA; FILE PHOTO: Cleveland Browns wide receiver (42) PAUL WARFIELD makes a catch in front of Green Bay Packers linebacker (89) DAVE ROBINSON during a preseason game at Cleveland Stadium. The Browns won the game 27-17. Mandatory Credit: Tony Tomsic-USA TODAY NETWORK

The Browns made it to the NFL finals in 1968. Leroy Kelly led the league in rushing yards and touchdowns. Warfield averaged 21.3 yards on 50 catches, with a league-best 12 receiving TDs. The 1969 Browns returned to the finals. Teams couldn’t double-cover both Warfield and Gary Collins, who combined for 21 scores.

The Browns’ quarterback problem could have been solved years earlier, had Paul Brown developed Len Dawson, another Purdue product.

Cleveland Browns quarterback Len Dawson in action at the Los Angeles Rams in a 1960 preseason game.

Cleveland Browns quarterback Len Dawson in action at the Los Angeles Rams in a 1960 preseason game.

Pittsburgh picked Dawson fifth overall in the 1957 draft, but coach Buddy Parker didn’t play him. After Dawson went to Cleveland in a New Year’s Eve, 1959, trade, Paul Brown didn’t play him, either, sticking with Milt Plum.

Advertisement

In 1962, expected back in Cleveland, Dawson jumped to the American Football League.

He went 11-3 in his first AFL season. He took the Chiefs to Super Bowl I, capping the 1966 season. Two weeks before the Browns traded Warfield for Phipps, Dawson was named MVP of Super Bowl IV.

He led the 1971 Chiefs to a 10-3-1 record that included a win over a Browns team using both Nelsen and Phipps.

Dawson would have played in a third Super Bowl if the Chiefs hadn’t given away a home playoff game against Shula’s Dolphins on Christmas Day, 1971.

The most accurate passer of his era, Dawson went 18 for 26 in Super Bowl III. He drove the Chiefs to where a last-second field goal would have won the playoff game against the Dolphins. Future Hall of Famer Jan Stenerud, having missed earlier from 29 yards, missed again from 32. The Dolphins, who got seven catches for 140 yards from Warfield, won 27-24 in overtime.

Advertisement

Phipps took some lumps as Nelsen’s backup in 1970 and ’71, playing enough to throw two TD passes and nine interceptions. Nelsen won a QB competition to open 1972, but, on a short leash because of the heavy investment in Phipps, was benched after an opening loss to Green Bay.

Browns fans seemed ready to support Phipps, who, in his first 1972 start, helped build a 27-3 lead in a win at Philadelphia. The next Sunday, 81,564 stuffed Municipal Stadium to see him beat Paul Brown’s Bengals 27-6.

The crowd was even bigger the next week for a visit from Dawson’s Chiefs, but Phipps Fever fizzled as he threw four interceptions in a 31-7 loss.

The kid rallied. He started completing passes to Frank Pitts, Fair Hooker and tight end Milt Morin. He made plays with his feet.  

Advertisement

He closed the year on an 8-1 hot streak, outplaying Bradshaw in a mid-November thriller. The Steelers took a late 24-23 lead on a 75-yard run by Franco Harris. Phipps drove the Browns to where Don Cockroft’s short field goal with eight seconds left produced a 26-24 win, with 83,009 watching.

Cleveland Browns quarterback Mike Phipps (15) in action against the Miami Dolphins during the 1972 AFC Divisional Playoff Game, Dec. 24, 1972, at the Orange Bowl in Miami. The unbeaten Dolphins won 20-14.

Cleveland Browns quarterback Mike Phipps (15) in action against the Miami Dolphins during the 1972 AFC Divisional Playoff Game, Dec. 24, 1972, at the Orange Bowl in Miami. The unbeaten Dolphins won 20-14.

The Browns reached the ’72 playoffs with a 10-4 record. The opponent was Warfield’s team, undefeated Miami, in a 3 o’clock Christmas Eve kickoff in Miami.

The Dolphins didn’t yet have Griese back from a broken leg and went with 38-year-old Earl Morrall.

Cleveland’s defense bent but didn’t break against the three-headed running monster of Larry, Csonka, Jim Kiick and Mercury Morris.

Advertisement

Phipps’ 23-yard touchdown pass to Hooker provided a 14-13 Cleveland lead with eight minutes left. Old-man Morrall drove 80 yards for a touchdown to take the lead with 4:49 remaining.

The difference in Miami’s 20-14 victory was the Warfield-for-Phipps trade.

On the Dolphins’ go-ahead drive, Warfield made catches of 15 and 35 yards and drew a pass interference call that put the ball on the 8.

Dec 24, 1972; Miami, FL, USA; FILE PHOTO; Miami Dolphins wide receiver Paul Warfield (42) in action against Cleveland Browns cornerbacks Clarence R. Scott (22) and Ben Davis (28) during 1972 AFC Divisional Playoff Game at the Orange Bowl. Miami defeated Cleveland 20-14. Mandatory Credit: Dick Raphael-USA TODAY Sports

Dec 24, 1972; Miami, FL, USA; FILE PHOTO; Miami Dolphins wide receiver Paul Warfield (42) in action against Cleveland Browns cornerbacks Clarence R. Scott (22) and Ben Davis (28) during 1972 AFC Divisional Playoff Game at the Orange Bowl. Miami defeated Cleveland 20-14. Mandatory Credit: Dick Raphael-USA TODAY Sports

Phipps got the Browns across midfield with about two minutes left, but the threat ended when he threw his fifth interception of the day. A week later, the Dolphins beat the Steelers 21-17 in the AFC Championship Game, en route to a 14-7 win over Washington in Super Bowl VII, and a 17-0 record.

Advertisement

It was hardly clear Phipps wasn’t as good as Bradshaw at that point. Bradshaw had thrown 58 interceptions in three years.

There was still time for the Warfield-Phipps trade to work out in Cleveland’s favor. Phipps was 25, now with playoff experience. Warfield was 30.

Warfield kept being Warfield. Phipps veered into a storm.

In 1973, Warfield made first-team All-Pro on another Super Bowl winner. The pattern continued in 1974, when he lost time to an injury but was back for the playoffs, catching a go-ahead touchdown pass against the Raiders. It took a last-second touchdown to win that one for Oakland.

Advertisement

The 1973 Browns had an OK year, 7-5-2, but Phipps, starting every game, took a league-worst 44 sacks. He threw 20 interceptions and just nine TDs. He completed less than 50% of his throws.

New York Giants linebacker Ron Hornsby prepares to tackle Browns quarterback Mike Phipps, Sept. 30, 1973, in Cleveland.

New York Giants linebacker Ron Hornsby prepares to tackle Browns quarterback Mike Phipps, Sept. 30, 1973, in Cleveland.

Cincinnati was getting better mileage out of a 1971 third-round pick, Ken Anderson, who started every game for a Bengals team that won the AFC Central at 10-4.

The Browns had a rough 1974. Tight end Milt Morin was aging. Wideout Steve Holden, a 1973 first-round pick, wasn’t good. The offensive line played musical chairs.

The Browns were about to fall to 1-6 when, trailing the Broncos 21-9, head coach Nick Skorich benched Phipps in favor of Brian Sipe.

Advertisement

Sipe lit up the fourth quarter. He hit Denver with a touchdown run and a TD pass to pull out a win. It was the first sign of how the 330th overall pick of the 1972 draft could work his way to becoming MVP of the NFL in 1980.

Modell kept trying to justify the Warfield trade. Phipps got another chance under a new head coach, Forrest Gregg. The 1975 Browns went 3-11, mostly with Phipps at quarterback. He threw four touchdown passes and 19 interceptions.

There was a last hurrah that came out of nowhere. The Bengals were 8-1 and aiming for home-field advantage in the playoffs. The Browns took an 0-9 record into sparsely populated Municipal Stadium.

Cleveland Browns quarterback Mike Phipps (15) hands off to Greg Pruitt against the Los Angeles Rams, Dec. 16, 1973, at the Coliseum in Los Angeles. The Rams won 30-17.

Cleveland Browns quarterback Mike Phipps (15) hands off to Greg Pruitt against the Los Angeles Rams, Dec. 16, 1973, at the Coliseum in Los Angeles. The Rams won 30-17.

Phipps passed for 298 yards and threw no picks. Greg Pruitt ran for 121 yards and racked up another 106 on receptions. The Browns improved to 1-9 with a 35-23 win.

Advertisement

Phipps returned for a seventh Browns season, looking good in the opener against Joe Namath’s Jets. He threw three touchdown passes in the second quarter, one to, interestingly, Paul Warfield.

A new enterprise, the World Football League, kicked off in July of 1974, and lured Warfield away from the Dolphins in 1975. Warfield went to the Memphis Southmen on a three-year contract worth $3 million, unheard-of receiver money then. Memphis head coach John McVay, a former Massillon player and Canton Central Catholic head coach, posted a 24-7 record before the WFL folded during the ’75 season.

Modell brought Warfield back to Cleveland as a free agent in 1976. The Phipps-to-Warfield story ended after one line. After one game, Phipps broke a collarbone and was replaced, essentially forever, by Sipe.

Dec 7, 1980; Cleveland, OH, USA; FILE PHOTO; Cleveland Browns quarterback Brian Sipe (17) in action against the New York Jets at Cleveland Municipal Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Malcolm Emmons-USA TODAY NETWORK

Dec 7, 1980; Cleveland, OH, USA; FILE PHOTO; Cleveland Browns quarterback Brian Sipe (17) in action against the New York Jets at Cleveland Municipal Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Malcolm Emmons-USA TODAY NETWORK

Sipe quarterbacked the Browns to a 9-5 season. Phipps remained a Brown until the day of the 1977 NFL draft, when he was traded to the Bears.

Advertisement

This time it was a good deal, in that it included Chicago’s first-round pick in 1978, with which the Browns took Alabama wide receiver Ozzie Newsome. New head coach Sam Rutigliano converted Newsome to tight end.

Phipps stands as football history’s only player who cost separate trade partners a Hall of Fame pass catcher.

Browns quarterback Mike Phipps (15) in action against the Cardinals, Sept. 29, 1974, at Busch Stadium in St. Louis.

Browns quarterback Mike Phipps (15) in action against the Cardinals, Sept. 29, 1974, at Busch Stadium in St. Louis.

The Bears actually got some mileage out of Phipps. He went 3-1 as the starting QB in 1978, then 9-2 (including a playoff loss to the Eagles) in 1979.

Phipps started six games in 1980, but he sat while Vince Evans played a memorable Monday night game. Too many standing-room tickets were sold, and too many people sneaked in. The Municipal Stadium crowd was larger than the announced 83,224. Sipe led Cleveland’s “Kardiac Kids” to a 27-21 win.

Advertisement

Phipps disappeared altogether in 1982, opting to retire after Mike Ditka was hired as head coach, and Brigham Young QB Jim McMahon was drafted sixth overall.

Phipps grew up in Columbus, Indiana, 30 miles west of the Ohio border. He beat Notre Dame, which didn’t recruit him, three times. He started for three 8-2 teams at Purdue, doing just as well as Griese, who went into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1990.

A year after Bill Clinton (yes, that Bill Clinton) won a prestigious Rhodes Scholarship and headed for studies in Oxford, Phipps turned down a Rhodes Scholarship, knowing he was headed for the NFL.

Phipps, now 78, could not be reached for this story. In his 2022 “This is Purdue” interview, he said he didn’t care to go into “much detail” about his seven seasons with the Browns.

Advertisement

He did share this:

“They traded Paul Warfield to get me. Paul was born in Ohio. He played at Ohio State. He was All-Pro in Cleveland. He was just … ‘the icon.’ I walked into a hornet’s nest.

“You have to walk in and deliver. I had to win over a lot of fans. and, trust me, a lot of players. Paul was so popular, and a great player. I didn’t get the warmest reception, so I had to win the team over. That was a challenge.

“I had never been booed in my life. The Cleveland fans were just phenomenal fans. They expected to win. Did I ever get used get used to it? It really does motivate you. It was an adjustment. Have you ever been booed?

Advertisement

“I did my best. I prepared. After seven years, it was time to maybe have a change of scenery. I thought it would be best for Cleveland and for me.

“Pro football is not what everyone thinks. It’s very pressure-filled. It’s hard work.

“It’s funny. When I chose to retire, I had lost the passion. You always get that question. Do you miss it?

“I was as happy or happier the day I retired than the day I got drafted. You don’t understand professional football and the pressure we were under, particularly at quarterback.

“Everybody sees what you do.”

Reach Steve at steve.doerschuk@cantonrep.com

This article originally appeared on The Repository: What if the Browns had kept Len Dawson? Maybe a disastrous trade is avoided

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: Sports.yahoo.com