Home International ‘Where was Mohammed Siraj?’: Ravi Shastri questions India’s pace selection after struggle...

‘Where was Mohammed Siraj?’: Ravi Shastri questions India’s pace selection after struggle to find ‘140 clicks’ in NZ 1st Test

0
1

‘Where was Mohammed Siraj?’: Ravi Shastri questions India’s pace selection after struggle to find ‘140 clicks’ in NZ 1st Test originally appeared on Cricket News. Add Cricket News as a Preferred Source by clicking here.

KEY TAKEAWAYS:

  • Ravi Shastri has questioned India’s bowling selection after a testing first day in Wellington against New Zealand.

  • Jasprit Bumrah gave India a dream start before the hosts mounted a strong fightback.

  • Batting coach Sitanshu Kotak has defended the thinking behind India’s playing XI for Wellington.

Advertisement

MORE: Best conversion rate after 25: India let slip advantage by allowing Nicholls a start

Ravi Shastri calls out India’s decision to drop Mohammed Siraj after Day 1 struggles in Wellington

The omission of Indian pacer Mohammed Siraj was the primary discussion doing the rounds on Thursday evening, once the dust had settled on a day that began brightly for India at the Basin Reserve and ended with New Zealand firmly in the contest.

The Indian bowlers had looked sharp for most of the morning, yet the way the day unfolded left plenty of people wondering whether the visitors had picked the right set of fast bowlers for the opening Test in Wellington.

Advertisement

India had every reason to feel pleased with themselves for long stretches of the day. They reduced the hosts to 70 for 5 with Jasprit Bumrah leading the way, and the pitch was offering enough movement and bounce to keep the New Zealand batters guessing.

The script changed after lunch. A stubborn stand between Nicholls and Phillips dragged the home side out of trouble. Nicholls finished unbeaten on 113 from 221 balls, an innings that included 14 boundaries, while Phillips was not out on 94 off 182 deliveries, with 13 fours of his own. Together they added 173 runs without being separated, and that partnership swung the day firmly in New Zealand’s favour.

MORE: 14 wkts in 12 Inn: Is Siraj’s lean run of form a factor behind getting dropped

Bumrah was easily the pick of the Indian bowlers with three wickets, whereas Akash Deep and Anshul Kamboj chipped in with one apiece. Prasidh Krishna, on the other hand, ended the day without a wicket as the hosts took back control of the game.

Advertisement

With Phillips just six runs short of a century and Nicholls well settled at the other end, India will need to strike early on Day 2 if they want to stop New Zealand from piling up a big first-innings total.

Shastri took to X after the close of play and wondered whether India’s selectors had overlooked the experience and aggression that the Hyderabad pacer brings to an attack.

“Hope India bounce back strongly. But if pace, skill and seam movement were the criteria, and 140 clicks was hard to come by, one has to ask the question. Where was MOHD SIRAJ?”

The former head coach then listed what he felt the bowler would have added, and we said: “Experience, aggression and the ability to make things happen with the ball. Surely that counts for something!”

Advertisement

MORE: Siraj, Jadeja omitted from India XI: Ashwin takes dig at team selections

Mohammed Siraj Dhruv Jurel

(Getty)

Sitanshu Kotak defends India’s decision to leave Siraj out of the Wellington Test playing XI

Batting coach Sitanshu Kotak responded on behalf of the team management and insisted that the XI was chosen with the whole five-day contest in mind, rather than just the opening day.

He maintained that Siraj had done nothing wrong and backed the combination that took the field in Wellington.

“There is nothing wrong with Siraj. We thought this was the best XI when we picked the side.”

Kotak then pointed out that one day of cricket was too small a sample to judge the selection call.

Advertisement

“I don’t think dropping Siraj was a wrong decision. This is just the first day. We don’t pick a team only for day one, but also for days two, three and four,” Kotak said.

MORE: ‘Flabbergasted’: Experts, fans confused as Siraj left out of India XI for 1st Test

India’s Siraj call will look smart or costly depending on how Day 2 unfolds in Wellington

Shastri’s question deserves a proper hearing, even if the hindsight behind it is a little unfair. India picked their attack with conditions and workloads across five days in mind, and for the first session or so the plan looked flawless, with five wickets down for 70.

Advertisement

A team can hardly be blamed for the way a pitch behaves after lunch. That said, the critics have a fair point.

The movement that troubled New Zealand in the morning faded as the ball grew older, and India had nobody who could bring a fresh kind of threat once Bumrah’s spell was over. Prasidh Krishna’s empty wicket column stood out in particular, because a 173-run stand is exactly the sort of partnership a hard-hitting, aggressive bowler like Siraj is picked to prevent.

His ability to unsettle batters could have changed the mood of the afternoon and evening sessions.

Kotak’s argument about picking for five days is sensible in principle, but it holds only if the chosen bowlers can keep the pressure on for those five days. The first day of a Test won’t settle the debate.

Advertisement

If India clean up the tail early on Day 2 and hold New Zealand to a modest total, the selectors will still be vindicated. If Nicholls and Phillips bat well into the next session, however, the chorus of “Where was Siraj?” will grow louder, and the team management will find it much harder to explain.

For all the latest cricket news, opinion, and commentary, and to share your voice, head to our Facebook, Instagram, and X (Twitter) pages.

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: Sports.yahoo.com