Casey Schmitt gave fans a reason to watch San Francisco Giants baseball in 2026. That, alone, is valuable. In a frustrating season, Schmitt went ahead and had a career year. He hit 21 home runs before August with a .271 batting average and .784 OPS.
The Giants’ biggest problem is that they had nowhere on the field to put him regularly. He’s an above-average defensive infielder whose natural position, third base, is occupied by veteran Matt Chapman.
Advertisement
The workaround was to throw the 27-year-old into nearly any open position just to keep his bat in the lineup. Schmitt had quite the collection of defensive gloves lined up in his locker by the time his season came to an abrupt end on July 27, when he slammed the brakes too hard rounding first base in a game against the Milwaukee Brewers. A torn meniscus required season-ending surgery with a timeline to be ready by spring training.
Schmitt’s greatest value, though, may not be helping a Giants bounce-back in 2027. A breakout year, defensive versatility and two remaining years of team control make Schmitt valuable in potential trades for a Giants team on the hunt to reinforce its pitching staff.
The team is reportedly open to fielding offers.
Why trade one of the organization’s few bright spots? The Giants’ positional logjam makes moving Schmitt the most logical and perhaps most realistic option. President of baseball operations Buster Posey signed free agents and swung trades that closed off nearly every opportunity for Schmitt to plant roots.
Advertisement
He’s a natural third baseman, but the Giants practically sealed that door when they signed Chapman to a six-year, $151 million contract extension at the end of the 2024 season. Though Schmitt’s above-average infield glove would lend itself to a shift to shortstop, the Giants closed that pathway, too, with Willy Adames‘ seven-year, $182 million contract in the 2025 offseason.
The Giants didn’t put much weight on Schmitt’s torrid run midway through the 2025 season (cut short by injuries, too) and went into last offseason on the hunt for a second baseman. They signed Luis Arraez, but traded him at the deadline and snagged young infielder Marcelo Meyer from the Boston Red Sox. Posey reiterated at the general managers meetings that the team hopes Meyer will earn the everyday second base job.
Left field appears to be the only spot that is kind of open. When Heliot Ramos fell injured and the lineup was in dire need of his bat, Schmitt fast-ordered an outfield glove on Amazon and played there out of necessity in 2026. Schmitt hadn’t played outfield since high school, so his sub-par defensive numbers (negative-2 outs above average) can be excused.
If Schmitt sticks around, starting in the outfield is his most logical avenue for playing time. That changes if Meyer – a former top prospect who struggled against big league pitching with the Red Sox – doesn’t pan out.
Advertisement
Schmitt’s viability should be seen as a huge opportunity for the Giants. Their farm system’s rising value makes them more appealing trade partners, but there’s little incentive to dig too far into the growing trove of homegrown talent to cultivate new relievers and starters for the big league team in 2027.
Schmitt lies somewhere between present and future. He’s under 30, under team control and may have done enough in San Francisco to prove he’s an everyday third baseman. There are a handful of teams on the hunt for one.
The Kansas City Royals just traded their everyday third baseman, Maikel Garcia, to the Seattle Mariners and don’t appear to have a ready internal option. The New York Yankees could be calling as they are reportedly open to moving off Ryan McMahon as their everyday third baseman.
There’s also the slim chance Posey finds a taker for Adames or Chapman, though moving those hefty contracts may require the Giants eat some of the money they’re due, attach a prospect or two, or make contact with a team that believes they can get far more production out of the two aging veterans.
Advertisement
That’s why offering Schmitt in a trade opens a different pathway to reinforce the pitching staff – the clear objective to improve the big league team this offseason. The Royals’ Garcia trade provides a framework for how a Schmitt trade might look.
The Royals traded Garcia, a Gold Glover on a $57.1 million five-year contract, major league reliever James McArthur and minor league reliever LP Langevin to the Mariners for 27-year-old starter Bryce Miller, Logan Evans and reliever Jose Ferrer. Miller is the headliner of that pitching return; he came up the ranks in Seattle as part of a promising homegrown pitching group but wasn’t effective enough to become the cream of their crop. Miller throws a high-velocity fastball and nasty splitter, and has all the tools to be an effective starter.
The parallel isn’t perfect – Garcia is a 27-year-old Gold Glover on a cost-effective, five-year deal – but the Giants may be able to find promising pitching for a player like Schmitt. In an offseason rife with uncertainty due to the pending lockout, the Giants may not want to tie themselves up into any more free agency contracts that could complicate their future roster construction in an unknown CBA context. They’re looking for short-term deals on pitchers that may not be available to them and they’re not seemingly open to signing players who’ve been offered and declined the qualifying offer, for fear of sacrificing more draft picks and international bonus signing money.
Could the Giants be selling too soon if they move Schmitt now? One could argue he has perhaps only touched the surface of what he’s capable of at the plate, and a season-ending injury cut him off before he could put together a full season at his best.
Advertisement
But heading into his age-28 season, his game isn’t without blemishes. Schmitt went over a month without drawing a walk last year, delivering a 2.7% walk rate that ranks among one of the worst in baseball.
Posey has been decisive in capitalizing when necessary. Schmitt may be one of their best players they might be able to flip to get some of the pitching help that the Giants definitely need.
Subscribe
There’s more to San Francisco with the Chronicle. Subscribe today for just 25¢.
This article originally published at Why moving Casey Schmitt might be Giants’ best path to acquiring pitching help.
Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: Sports.yahoo.com




