Home International Why Sydney’s popular three-storey walk-ups are facing extinction

Why Sydney’s popular three-storey walk-ups are facing extinction

0
1
Advertisement
Cindy Yin

Sydney’s three- to four-storey walk-up apartments face extinction unless building regulations are overhauled as the housing sector warns that completion rates lag significantly behind approvals.

Low-rise apartments comprised a much larger share of Sydney’s housing in the early 1990s, making up one-fifth – or 18 per cent – of all home approvals, but this has plummeted to just 1 per cent.

Tamsyn Glen has lived in a three-storey walk-up in Marrickville since 2009 and hasn’t looked back since.Louise Kennerley

A new report from the Committee for Sydney found this sharp decline of the “missing middle” was symptomatic of a new dilemma in Sydney’s housing crisis.

While the state government’s rezoning and planning reforms have unlocked capacity for hundreds of thousands of homes, there is a massive shortfall in delivery, the report says.

Advertisement

Estelle Grech, the think tank’s director of planning, said supply challenges were particularly acute for low density walk-ups because of one-size-fits-all building regulations that treated three-storey apartments the same as a 30-storey tower.

More compliance and red tape drives up the price of construction, making it almost impossible for low-rise builds to financially stack up, she said.

Tam Glen was keen on living in a sturdy 1960s or 1970s older walk-up.Louise Kennerley

“Even if you rezone the land, the buildings aren’t going to come – because no one can afford to build it. Low-rise apartments are drowning in building regulations that no longer make sense,” she said.

Award-winning architect Philip Thalis said what used to take six to eight consultants for the same low-density apartment build now requires 20 to 25 consultants.

Advertisement

“You walk past any new apartment building today, you’ll see a plethora of services that are required, each with their own spatial requirements. They cost money to install, and have ongoing maintenance costs,” Thalis said.

“The cumulative impact is devastating for affordability of apartments.”

One solution proposed by the Committee for Sydney is reducing extra costs from every stage of the development process – from wasted costs accrued during the construction, land acquisition, delays, design or compliance stages.

The think tank has also suggested creating a fit-for-purpose building code for walk-ups that is more proportional to their size, and distinguishes them from towers.

It has urged the state government to implement a trial through state-owned agencies Homes NSW and Landcom before rolling it out more broadly.

Advertisement

The decline in walk-ups being built over time is not reflective of how Sydneysiders want to live.

Research by UNSW City Futures shows that low and mid-rise builds were the most popular apartment type for their greater sense of community and lower strata costs.

These reasons were why Tamsyn Glen moved from the eastern suburbs to a three-storey flat in Marrickville more than 16 years ago and has not looked back since.

“My mother asked if I would ever move, and I told her: ‘You can put a pin in here around about 200 metres, and that’s all I’d move to!’” she said.

Glen said living in a sturdy 1960s or 1970s older walk-up was a non-negotiable when she was house hunting in 2009.

Advertisement

“Red brick buildings just have a reputation for being solidly built. A bigger, fancier place may not have been as affordable, either. I wanted a smaller block to manage strata and other issues better. I also didn’t want a pool or elevator because those are strata fees, too,” Glen said.

In New Zealand, Auckland boosted its housing supply and reduced rents after widespread zoning changes were introduced to encourage more “missing middle” housing a decade ago.

However, as Sydneysiders face a future in which low-density “missing middle” housing becomes scarcer, developers have also sounded the alarm on broader commercial feasibility constraints delaying projects across the property sector and placing upward pressure on house prices.

Urban Development Institute of Australia NSW chief executive Stuart Ayres said housing development had been increasingly squeezed by rising interest rates and supply chain disruptions inflating material costs, putting stress on a housing industry already in crisis.

Advertisement

“This pushes development – particularly in low to mid-rise sites – into the north shore and the eastern suburbs because developers can sell their product at a higher rate per square metre there. Once you drift further west, the availability becomes considerably shallower,” Ayres said.

The state government is behind on its commitment to build 112,000 “missing middle” homes by mid-2029.

However, a spokesperson for the NSW government said there were more than 17,000 homes under assessment, and more than 5400 approved in areas where low- and mid-rise planning reforms allow.

They said the government was implementing measures to improve feasibility and reduce the cost of delivering housing, including pattern book designs, prefabricated homes, changes to insurance requirements for low-rise buildings, and the pre-sale finance guarantee, among others.

Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.

Cindy YinCindy Yin is an urban affairs reporter at The Sydney Morning Herald.Connect via email.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: www.smh.com.au