Home Business European Central Bank sees ‘historical parallels with the dotcom and subprime bubbles’...

European Central Bank sees ‘historical parallels with the dotcom and subprime bubbles’ because of AI’s ‘rapid shift’ into debt finance

0
1

For most of this year, markets have been asking how big the AI bubble is and how bad it gets if it pops. On Wednesday, the European Central Bank went through the boom against the last big credit bust, point by point, using the companies’ own filings.

In its twice-yearly Financial Stability Review, the ECB estimated that big tech firms had “total off-balance-sheet commitments of more than USD 4 trillion as of the second quarter of 2026,” which it said was “well in excess of their outstanding on-balance-sheet liabilities.” The sample is Alphabet, Amazon, Meta, Microsoft, Nvidia, Oracle, Broadcom and Anthropic. “The rapid shift towards debt finance invokes historical parallels with the dotcom and subprime bubbles,” the central bank wrote.

The ECB’s count lands a day after the Federal Reserve’s. In its own November Financial Stability Report, the Fed counted more than $3 trillion in signed leases that haven’t started yet, take-or-pay contracts and residual value guarantees at seven big tech companies, none of it showing up as debt, as Fortune reported. The two tallies cover different companies and use different methods.

The ECB’s comparison comes with specifics. In a box on the debt financing of AI, six ECB authors list what looks like 2008: obligations that work like debt but aren’t booked as debt, revenue that loops back to whoever paid for it, credit ratings the bond market may not believe, loans that outlast what they paid for, and leverage building outside the banks. The Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission concluded that “a combination of excessive borrowing, risky investments, and lack of transparency put the financial system on a collision course with crisis.” Here is how the ECB’s list lines up.

Off the books

Then: In December 2007, Citigroup said it would take $49 billion of assets from its structured investment vehicles onto its balance sheet to prevent ratings downgrades and fire sales. The vehicles had been built to sit off its books.

Now: Hyperscalers sign contracts to use data centers and chips owned by someone else. The owners then borrow against those promised payments from “banks, bond investors or private credit funds.” The ECB wrote that “such cash flow commitments are debt-like in economic terms, but they do not appear as liabilities on the balance sheets of hyperscalers under US accounting standards.” Under the U.S. lease rules, a lease isn’t booked until the asset goes into use.

One example: Meta’s $27 billion Hyperion data center in Louisiana. Fortune’s Sharon Goldman reported last year that it was built through a joint venture in which Blue Owl Capital owned 80%, keeping the full debt off Meta’s balance sheet. The bonds were rated A+ and yielded 6.58%.

The ECB’s downside case is the Citi moment in slow motion. If earnings disappoint, it says, “the full debt incurred for the AI buildout would gradually be recognised on balance sheets,” and leverage and ratings would worsen.

Buying your own demand

Then: The FCIC’s “lack of transparency.”

Now: Cloud providers and AI labs buy and lease chips from chipmakers, which often finance the purchases. The ECB says those deals “inflate the expected revenues of both the chipmaker and the service provider, because the reported demand of an involved firm is partly driven by that firm’s own financing decisions.” The loop shows up in earnings too. A footnote says “other income” at Alphabet and Amazon comes from revaluing their stakes in Anthropic, and it notes Nvidia’s stakes in CoreWeave, OpenAI and Anthropic. In the review’s foreword, ECB Vice-President Boris Vujčić wrote that “circular financing is making intrinsic demand hard to gauge.”

Ratings the market doesn’t trust

Then: The FCIC concluded that “the failures of credit rating agencies were essential cogs in the wheel of financial destruction.”

Now: The ECB is more measured. It says spreads on hyperscaler bonds have widened compared with corporate bonds carrying the same ratings, especially at longer maturities, which “could be an indication that markets currently view rating agencies’ risk assessments as too benign.” Elsewhere the review notes credit default swap spreads for a number of big tech firms climbing “to record levels.”

Loans that outlast the chips

Then: Mortgages that ended up worth more than the houses behind them.

Now: “The maturity of hyperscalers’ outstanding debt exceeds the economic lifetimes of a substantial share of the physical capital funded by this debt, especially in the form of advanced chips,” the ECB authors wrote. The ECB cites market intelligence that AI equipment lasts one to three years. The IMF puts GPUs at about two years, against seven for standard equipment. Most hyperscalers, meanwhile, have stretched the accounting life of their servers from three years in 2020 to six years in 2026.

Leverage outside the banks

Then: The FCIC wrote that “we permitted the growth of a shadow banking system,” much of it running on short-term debt.

Now: The ECB says euro area non-banks, meaning funds and other investors, have increased their AI exposures significantly and have started buying debt issued by AI firms. It points to “the near collapse of Situational Awareness, a US hedge fund, in July 2026” as an example of concentration meeting leverage.

What doesn’t match yet

The ECB lists differences too. “So far, however, hyperscalers’ earnings have broadly kept up with expectations,” the authors wrote. Vujčić wrote that even if banks aren’t exposed to an AI correction “in material terms,” they “could face spillovers via strong links with non-banks.”

The ECB also separates the two bubbles it names. The dotcom bust brought “only a shallow recession thanks to a large share of equity finance.” In a footnote, it says “credit booms that turned into a bust were associated with a significant and prolonged contraction in real GDP,” and that a U.S. shock “would likely result in a significant contraction in euro area GDP as well.” The authors wrote that “the rapid acceleration of debt financing raises concerns that the AI buildout might become debt-driven and unsustainable.”

The ECB needed AI to count it

Even the central bank struggled to see the debt. A chart note says ECB staff extracted the off-balance-sheet figures from SEC filings with “an agentic AI model developed by ECB staff,” running on OpenAI’s ChatGPT 5.6-Sol. Staff trained it to match totals they had compiled by hand for the first quarter, then checked its output manually. Anthropic’s figures come from its IPO filing.

On the ECB’s tracker, earnings are the one item still holding up, and every other item depends on them. The central bank’s next check comes in May, if it keeps to this year’s schedule.

Generative AI was used for research assistance and/or transcription of this article. The reporter independently reported and verified the factual claims in this article, and a human editor reviewed it before publication.

Disclaimer : This story is auto aggregated by a computer programme and has not been created or edited by DOWNTHENEWS. Publisher: fortune.com